As nobody answered I'll answer:

I wrote:

> Is it a general problem to use X 4.x.x together with RTLinux?
> I saw there was some discussion about the accelerated drivers some time 
> ago.

I decided: YES, it is (but what in some years when X3.3.x died)!

 
> My problem:
> 
> If I start RTLinux from X (xterm) and my module everything is okay 
> (except some jitter - that's maybe from direct irq handling of X - as 
> the discussion showed ...).


okay, it's maybe the pci_retry function that's part of the PCI2.1 spec. 
Can one disable this feature? I heard it's only implemented in 
Intel440BX and later chipsets ...

> 
> When the whole thing runs and I shutdown X -> the machine hangs (also my 
> rtl-module) -> reset -> fsck -> some files are lost -> ...
> 

I'm now using XFree 3.3.6 (recent Debian packages and a old Redhat 6.2). 
  I have definetely less jitter than before. But still, when I do some 
crazy things with my windows -> jitter (not with Redhat).
A X4.x.x without hardware acceleration will cause more jitter.

Letting X crash (or whatever) doesn't do any harm now to RT (except some 
jitter with the Debian version).

A good test for the realtime capability is the resizing of the search 
panel in mozilla ...

Funny is that a 2.2.19 RTL3.1 kernel will reduce the jitter. 2.4.4 
RTL3.1 will give me more jitter.
And a SMP kernel will give me even more jitter.


All together means:
Any new Linux program (X, kernel, ...) and a video card with the 
pci_retry feature can't provide me realtime.

Redhat6.2 with RTL3, 2.2.18 seems to be 'realtime' (but it crashes once 
in a while and is a old uniprocessor configuration (on a SMP box) ...)


If anyone has a comment to one or all these results: post it ...
Stefan


b.t.w.: posting is now faster: 9 hours ...

-- [rtl] ---
To unsubscribe:
echo "unsubscribe rtl" | mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] OR
echo "unsubscribe rtl <Your_email>" | mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--
For more information on Real-Time Linux see:
http://www.rtlinux.org/

Reply via email to