Hi, Karl (Berry) told me that Savannah Admin project is needs an active projects reviewer and asked for my help. So, I following the "How to become a savannah hacker" guide, here is 2 answers for pending revision projects (shoot and hybrid).
SHOOT: (https://savannah.gnu.org/task/?7818) --------- License: Its Ok. A copy of GPLv3 license is included in the package. As no source code is provided I cannot say anything about legal notices in code. Source code: No source code is provided, so Its not possible to check license compatibility or dependencies problems. Source code must be included before Savannah can aprove your project. Other notes: A README file is included with contact information but no information about versions, supported platforms or authors names. CONCLUSION: The project cannot be approved until the source code is provided. If the developer needs Savannah right now, an explanation is needed. HYBRID: (https://savannah.gnu.org/task/?7822) ---------- License: Its Ok. A copy of GPLv2 license is included in the package. The legal notices in the source files are ok. Source code: Source code is provided but it cannot be compiled because ELKlib is required. This library is not available for download, so I cannot check if the source compile and works in a free OS. As ELKlib is already a Savannah approved project, I assume that this dependencies doesn't have compatibility problems. CONCLUSION: Project can be approved, bust must be checked when ELKlib is released. I wait for your comments. Regards, -- Franco Iacomella [ GNU Project ]
