Follow-up Comment #31, task #16685 (group administration): hi ineiev
i have submitted the request for change of email id as a support request. i have also submitted support request for a review of relysam for rejection/approval as per your process, as i am not able to understand your comments any further. in case i do get any further guidance on relysam, which is specific and comprehensive for action, lets proceed. otherwise please consider this request as closed from my end. thank you for your guidance till now, it helped a lot. [comment #29 comment #29:] > > [comment #28 comment #28:] >> [comment #27 comment #27:] >>> >>> 1. are there any more corrections or changes which i need to make and >>> submit. i haven't received any feedback to work on. let me know if there is >>> any critical or mandatory changes for any further issues. >> >> I haven't received the latest changes from you as well, so I think yes, >> there are, but I really can't point them out. > >> i have already provided my feedback as per my comments >> https://savannah.nongnu.org/task/index.php?16685#comment26. and i have >> received any feedback on what do you suggest to close them. maybe you have >> missed this. let me know how do you recommend? > > > >>> 2. is there some available tool or script with which i can work further to >>> make relysam compliant to group's approval? >> >> I'm not aware of such scripts. >> > ok, noted. thanks > >>> 3. how many days would it further take to get the group's approval for >>> hosting relysam, if it meets all requirements? >> >> The point is not to build a compliant tarball; the point is to make sure >> that the maintainer is able and willing to follow Savannah hosting >> requirements. So far, you are obviously not. >> > > to be frank i do not understand what do you mean by "obviously not". if i > understand that relysam isnt what you understand or relate to, i can > understand. however if you mean to say, the relysam application is not as per > non-gnu applications standard, i cannot comment. however i did submit it for > being hosted. if there should be some other point of view of "obviously not", > its ambiguous to me. > >>> 4. there is a votes feature down below on this page. what is the >>> significance of it? >> >> Basically, none. >> > > great. thank you > >>> 5. i had applied to change of my email on savannah site through account >>> configuration, and confirmed on the email link, but there is no change. can >>> you guide me on this. >> >> Yes, I can; please submit a support request. >> > noted, i will. let me reconsider if it is actually required, as i may not > like to do this till relysam gets approved or rejected, for which i will have > to wait for your next steps. > > thanks > >> [comment #26 comment #26:] >>> >>> noted, the readme file has been prepared by following the below guidance on >>> same page -- >>> >>> "On the other hand, when merging some public domain code into an >> ... >>> The notice saying that the whole file is under the GPL (or other license) >>> is legally sufficient. " >>> >>> verbatim. >>> >>> so what should be the correct way to proceed? please suggest. >> >> You don't merge parts of these files, you effectively copy them. >> >>>> Also, files like ai/data/failure_modes_data.csv are text, they should >>>> include copyright and license notices. >>> >>> well these are just initial synthetic data files, which should be removed >>> from the relysam distribution .tar.gz. noted for future. >> >> Thank you! Please make a tarball that will contain all and only files the >> distribution will contain. Unrelated files make the evaluation harder. >> >>> should there be any more points, do share. thank you. >> >> Yes, there is, >> >>>> More important, I can tell if the legal notices are correct when I'm >>>> familiar with the files in question; for most files, I can't really check >>>> their origin and legal status. >> _______________________________________________________ Reply to this item at: <https://savannah.nongnu.org/task/?16685> _______________________________________________ Message sent via Savannah https://savannah.nongnu.org/
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
