Hi all !

Le jeudi 24 septembre 2009 09:36:23, Gilles PIETRI a écrit :
> > I've been reading for hours and I think Im more confused than ever.  
> > Does anyone have any experience with licensing?  Anyone know if/how the 
> > laws apply to mixes and live broadcasts as opposed to singles playing?
> 
> In France, no matter what you broadcast (remixes, bootlegs, live 
> shows..), you have to get an agreement with several of the rightholders 
> defenders.. That is the SACEM, SCPP, SCPF & so on..
> 
> Even if you play unlicenced (or licenced but on other terms than theirs) 
> music, there is some case you still have to pay a fee.. Which is rather 
> irritating obviously.. And it's not cheap also ;)

Hmmm. Do you also mean it for Creative Commons licensed music ?

About the MP3 format, which was in the initial question, this depends. The 
basics of the license for using mp3 is the patents over the corresponding 
audio technologies. 

However, such patents are not filed worldwide but localy, one for the USA, one 
for Europe etc.. So if there is no patent in your country (say... Russia ?), 
then you don't have to pay a license.

Furthermore, some countries, like the countries in European Union do not 
recognize software patent (to some extend), hence it is highly possible that 
such license fees would be illegal. (to be confirmed)

In any way, one of the main purpose of the ogg codecs was precisely to have 
patent free technologies. So if you stream using one of the ogg codecs, say 
ogg/vorbis, you do not have to pay fees, and will never have.

This fact, by the way, really makes me wonder why hardware manufacturers still 
push for patent-encumbered technologies, which is exactly like shooting its 
own foot where they could use patent-free technologies and save costs..

> As for mixes or bootlegs, there are even artists who refuses them, in 
> case you might alter how good their music sounds..

Hmmm... But I am not sure this is legal for the artist. So far, my 
understanding is that, in France, as soon as you pay the required fees you 
have the right to broadcast the artist's performance. This is probably linked 
to the legal requirement that an artist cannot cancel a publicaly exposed 
artistic thing. 

Most similar to the fact that they can't refuse a cover of their song, can 
they ?

In particular, I remember that radio show on sunday on Skyrock when I was a 
teen that was playing bootleg lives for a couple of hours and was, I believe, 
totaly legal.



Romain

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Come build with us! The BlackBerry® Developer Conference in SF, CA
is the only developer event you need to attend this year. Jumpstart your
developing skills, take BlackBerry mobile applications to market and stay 
ahead of the curve. Join us from November 9-12, 2009. Register now!
http://p.sf.net/sfu/devconf
_______________________________________________
Savonet-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/savonet-users

Reply via email to