Hi David, nice to have you onboard this discussion as well! :)

On 04/01/2014 08:07 AM, David Baelde wrote:

> For instance you could write
> output.icecast(...,fallback([buffer(radio),default])) where radio
> contains the alsa stuff, and is thus controlled by the alsa clock, and
> default (and the icecast output) are free of alsa and controlled by
> the default wallclock. If radio is too slow the fallback will notice a
> failure and move on to default for a while.

In your suggestion, you mention "default". What is default? And what
does "move on to default for a while"? Won't the clients notice this?
Where is "default" coming from? Can you provide a more complete example?

> With the adaptative buffer, the data from radio will be
> stretched/compressed (there are parameters to control how much) to
> avoid the failure. Obviously, the cost is audio distortion.

Audio distortion is not an option...

> Now, I wanted to comment on what liquidsoap may be doing differently
> from another tool. In general, we keep track of time more precisely
> than other tools, e.g. ices2 for sure. Reading your log again, it
> seems that you're already using a buffer, which clearly makes your
> setup different from what another tool would do. One thing to try,
> then, is to remove buffers completely: then the icecast output will be
> alsa-controlled. Liquidsoap won't complain about clock issues, and
> streaming will drop if it has too, ie. if icecast kicks you because
> you're too slow, which might be less often than currently. But it's
> just hiding the problem, pushing it at the level of icecast's buffers.

Well... This is most probably the issue here, but I'm a bit confused why
there's no "good" solution to this, as I've had no issues streaming from
other machines using other tools (like DarkIce and IceS), with the same
kind of sound card. Is there really no good solution to this problem..?

Is the good solution basically to invest in a new sound card..? Or is
the problem ALSA? And I should be using some other driver instead?

- Marius

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
Savonet-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/savonet-users

Reply via email to