On Thu, 30 Jun 2011, Akemi Yagi wrote:

Here is a rather "neutral" view on the "top post vs bottom post" subject.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style

Andrew Marvell would call that a fine and public site (if, I fear, just a tad tedious); but I have two suggestions, one helpful and one more so.

Always lead out trump: if the listowner(s)/moderator(s) will consent, the list could be ported to Gmane. Then all who wish (particularly those of us without the time or the taste for formalistic if not ritual disputations) can point our newsreaders to news.gmane.org, thereby obviating all but what each chooses to follow.

Pending that, since fnal.gov affords us the use of Listserv itself, we can send the command "SET scientific-linux-users INDEX" (without quotes, and *please* to <lists...@listserv.fnal.gov> and not, repeat *not* to the list.

This is a woefully under-appreciated option, which afaik only Listserv itself offers. (Oh, how I wish Mailman, or any list software I could run would get it!)

The software sends you, not all the messages, but a list or them, with the posters' names. You reply, with your normal reply function (Again, to <lists...@listserv.fnal.gov>, *not* to the list!), after editing the list down to just those posts you wish to see. The server returns just those.

This saves even more aggravation than time. Prithee do not ask how I know.

--
Beartooth Staffwright, Double Retiree,
Linux Duffer, Curmudgeon On Line,
Historian of Tongues from Way Back

Reply via email to