hi alexandre > On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 6:12 PM, ale rimoldi <ale.comp_06 at xox.ch> > wrote: > > >> > - You should create icons in different states (on, off, hovered) > >> > and at different sizes (16, 22, 32 pixel) > >> > >> Oh come on, do you seriously ?want people to submit three times as > >> many icons than you _really_ needs to make decision on? > > > > no, everybody can provide as many icons as he or she thinks allows > > us to understand his or her proposal. > > The original request says nothing about it. Check. > > > and, alexandre, you are talking to a plural "you". personally, i'd > > like to see between 20 to 30 icons (non unique ones, in different > > states and sizes). > > others want just to see five of them, without really caring about > > states and sizes. > > The original request says nothing about it. Check. > > > we won't refuse anybody because he or she didn't met any of the > > criteria... > > The original request says nothing about it. Check. > > When you start a contest, the last thing you want is to end up > explaining you really meant this and you didn't really mean that. You > could discuss a text of the proposal in the dev list first, then post > it here. Given the discussion above I'd suggest to revisit this text, > applly clarifications and repost it. Or, better, wait for more > comments on the text and then do it.
no need to explain those things to the participants. the explanation was for a russian guy who is bitching about the rules of a contest in which he won't participate. if you have questions about the rules i can give you an answer. if you want to change the rules, you're too late. i recall you that your replying to a contest not to a Request for Comments. i have not much more than that to say to you. the next in the queue, please. ciao a.l.e
