DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Long Overdue Resolution

2013-08-07 Thread omd 
On Thu, Aug 8, 2013 at 2:11 AM, Sean Hunt  wrote:
> I hereby resolve the Agoran Decision to select a degree to award for
> ais523's thesis "A History of Agoran Wins, 2009-Present"

Of note, this decision was initiated about three years ago.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Long Overdue Resolution

2013-08-08 Thread Aaron Goldfein 
On Wed, Aug 7, 2013 at 11:11 PM, Sean Hunt wrote:

> I hereby resolve the Agoran Decision to select a degree to award for
> ais523's thesis "A History of Agoran Wins, 2009-Present"
>
> The votes were as follows:
>
> scshunt: FAILING GRADE (x2)
> Yally: FAILING GRADE
> Keba: FAILING GRADE
> G.: FAILING GRADE
> Murphy: FAILING GRADE (x2)
> Tiger: Bachelor of Nomic
>
> FAILING GRADE is the option selected by Agora.
>
> -scshunt
>

What was this and why did I vote FAILING GRADE?

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Long Overdue Resolution

2013-08-08 Thread Aaron Goldfein 
On Thu, Aug 8, 2013 at 12:15 AM, Aaron Goldfein wrote:

>
>
> On Wed, Aug 7, 2013 at 11:11 PM, Sean Hunt wrote:
>
>> I hereby resolve the Agoran Decision to select a degree to award for
>> ais523's thesis "A History of Agoran Wins, 2009-Present"
>>
>> The votes were as follows:
>>
>> scshunt: FAILING GRADE (x2)
>> Yally: FAILING GRADE
>> Keba: FAILING GRADE
>> G.: FAILING GRADE
>> Murphy: FAILING GRADE (x2)
>> Tiger: Bachelor of Nomic
>>
>> FAILING GRADE is the option selected by Agora.
>>
>> -scshunt
>>
>
> What was this and why did I vote FAILING GRADE?
>

Well, I should have greped the logs before asking that. As far as I can
tell ais523 never resubmitted eir thesis.

I wrote:

> > I'm going to have to cast both my votes for FAILING GRADE, as the thesis
> > contains a significant factual error (it documents a win that did not
> > occur). The applicant is encouraged to resubmit a corrected version.
> >
> > -coppro
> >
> I vote FAILING GRADE by the same logic.