OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 9068-9069
RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9068-9069
=
IDTitleResult
---
9068 Agora of Empires REJECTED
9069 Coauthored Crystals ADOPTED
I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
The quorum for all below decisions was 6.
VOTING STRENGTHS
Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
#: player has voting strength 3
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6
+: player has voting strength 9
PROPOSALS
=
PROPOSAL 9068 (Agora of Empires)
AUTHOR: Yachay Wayllukuq
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (2): Murphy%, Yachay Wayllukuq%
AGAINST (2): Aris%, Janet+
PRESENT (2): juan$, snail^
BALLOTS: 6
AI (F/A): 10/14 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.000
OUTCOME: REJECTED
PROPOSAL 9069 (Coauthored Crystals)
AUTHOR: snail
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (2): Aris%, snail^
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (4): Janet+, Murphy%, Yachay Wayllukuq%, juan$
BALLOTS: 6
AI (F/A): 11/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.333
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: 4st is the Geologist: Endorsement of non-voter 4st: Inextricable
]
The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
//
ID: 9069
Title: Coauthored Crystals
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: snail
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2685 (Crystals) by replacing
{
- If that crystal's owner is not the author of that proposal, the
instability of that crystal is increased by 3.
}
with
{
- If that crystal's owner is not the author of that proposal, the
instability of that crystal is increased by 1.
- If that crystal's owner is not the author or coauthor of that proposal,
the
instability of that crystal is increased by 2.
}
[This makes the rule function the same when there's no coauthors, but if
there's a coauthor that owns the crystal of the modified rule, its
instability is only increased by 1 instead of 3.]
//
OFF: [Assessor] Humiliating Public Reminder for Proposals 9068-9069
For each of proposals 9068-9068, I hereby publish a humiliating public reminder naming the following slackers: Gaelan, ais523, Aris, 4st, kiako, Kate, nix, Ben, Jimmy, Lizz Wake, Mercury, Maloney, mcdg, omd, cuddlbanana, blob, Anneke-Constantine, Zipzap, Crystalizedmire, Goren Barak Please feel humiliated. -- Janet Cobb Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason
OFF: [Arbitor] Weekly Report
To see a (temporary) list of recentish CFJs look here: https://gist.github.com/nixnull/cef47c1e88063177feedfe52a906c59b Below is the Arbitor's weekly report. RECENTLY JUDGED CASES (since last report) CFJ 4067 : LegallyBearded has successfully called a CFJ with substantially the : text 'Does "granting" an asset cause it to be received?'. [2024-03-05] Called by Aris, barring LegallyBearded. [2024-03-09] Assigned to kiako by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-14] Judged FALSE by kiako. CFJ 4054 : It is generally POSSIBLE to alter the holder of the office of : Distributor without objection. https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg45340.html https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-discussion@agoranomic.org/msg56086.html [2023-08-25] Called by Kate [2024-03-09] Assigned to kiako by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-14] Judged FALSE by kiako. CFJ 4066 : In the above message, LegallyBearded successfully granted emself 52 : welcome packages. [2024-03-05] Called by Aris, barring LegallyBearded. [2024-03-09] Assigned to Yachay by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-12] Judged FALSE by Yachay. CFJ 4068 : snail was granted a stamp in this message. [2024-03-10] Called by snail. [2024-03-10] Assigned to ais523 by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-12] Judged FALSE by ais523. CFJ 4071 : The quotes message contains at least one game action. [2024-03-11] Called by nix. [2024-03-11] Assigned to ais523 by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-12] Judged DISMISS by ais523. RECENT ASSIGNMENTS [2024-03-10] CFJ 4057 assigned to Kate by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-11] CFJ 4069 assigned to 4st by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-11] CFJ 4070 assigned to snail by Arbitor nix.* [2024-03-11] CFJ 4071 assigned to ais523 by Arbitor nix. [since jduged] [2024-03-12] CFJ 4072 assigned to nix by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-16] CFJ 4073 assigned to Yachay by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-16] CFJ 4056 assigned to Gaelan by Arbitor nix. *CFJ 4070 may not exist. OPEN CASES CFJ 4056 : Agoran't is ossified. http://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg45551.html [2023-11-09] Called by snail [2024-03-09] Assigned to Yachay by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-12] Self-recused by Yachay. [2024-03-16] Assigned to Gaelan by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4057 : As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, Kate and : Janet won the game. https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg45651.html [2023-11-19] Called by snail [2024-03-09] Assigned to ais523 by Arbitor nix. [2024-03-09] Self-recused by ais523. [2024-03-10] CFJ 4057 assigned to Kate by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4058 : As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, snail : won the game. [2023-11-19] Called by snail [2024-03-09] Assigned to Janet by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4059 : As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, Murphy : won the game. [2023-11-19] Called by snail. [2024-03-09] Assigned to Murphy by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4062 : Proposal 9051, as part of its effect, applied a rule change. [2024-01-28] Called by Janet. [2024-03-09] Assigned to Gaelan by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4063 : Proposal 9055, as part of its effect, enacted a rule. [2024-02-11] Called by Janet. [2024-03-09] Assigned to Kate by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4069 : There exists a rule 105. [2024-03-11] Called by Gaelan. [2024-03-11] Assigned to 4st by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4070* : This CFJ exists. [2024-03-11] Called by nix. [2024-03-11] Assigned to snail by Arbitor nix. *CFJ 4070 may not exist. CFJ 4072 : There exists an entity that is a Rule with ID number 2687. [2024-03-11] Called by Janet. [2024-03-12] Assigned to nix by Arbitor nix. CFJ 4073 : The quoted message contains a game action. [2024-03-12] Called by snail. [2024-03-16] Assigned to Yachay by Arbitor nix. INTERESTED JUDGES To be added to or removed from this list, simply let me know. I will automatically remove any judge that lets a judgment deadline slip without notice. kiako (last: 4067) Kate (open: 4063, 4057) Yachay (open: 4073) ais523 (last: 4071) Janet (open: 4058) Murphy (open: 4059) Gaelan (open: 4062, 4056) nix (open: 4072) 4st (open: 4069) snail (open: 4070*) *CFJ 4070 may not exist. -- nix
