Re: Bug#306476: quick question about Bug#306476

2006-03-10 Thread Frans Pop
On Monday 27 February 2006 04:21, Randall Wayth wrote:
 To get to this point, I had also tried the latest etch cd installer
 which uses a 2.6 kernel. This installer failed at other points (I had
 to modprobe esp and it couldn't mount the disk after partitioning, and
 something else too...) but what was useful was that it told me that the
 module for the scsi controller was called esp. Since this is an sbus
 system, not pci, there doesn't appear to be an equivalent of lspci
 which would have solved my problem immediately. (If there is such a
 thing, please let me know.)

There is actually. Recent sparc images include 'prtconf' and use that to 
detect sbus devices.

 So all's well that ends well. If you think that the failure to load the
 correct scsi driver modules during the detect cdrom phase is a bug,
 then I'll be happy to submit one.

No need to open a new bug, just keep following up to this one.

Could you please try an install using the latest daily image [1], which is 
the candidate for the installer's Beta2 release. See if the CDROM is 
detected and the esp driver is loaded automatically.

If it does not work, could you send us the output of prtconf?

You can also try to add a line 'set -x' in /bin/discover-sbus before 
hardware detection [2]. That should give you debugging output in
/var/log/syslog that shows what's happening.

You can stop before partitioning, so no need to overwrite your exiting 
installation for this test.

TIA,
Frans Pop

[1]http://cdimage.debian.org/cdimage/daily-builds/etch_d-i/arch-latest/sparc/iso-cd/

[2] Boot the installer with 'install debconf/priority=medium' and, before
the step to detect cdrom hardware, switch to VT2 and edit that script
using nano.


pgpVembFEVKBG.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: Bug#306476: quick question about Bug#306476

2006-02-26 Thread Randall Wayth

Hi Jim and Frans,

Thanks very much for the follow-up and suggestions. For the sake of 
creating a useful record I'll let you know what happened here.


I ended up getting this working using the standard sarge minimal-cd net 
installer, which was the thing that failed in the first place. To get it 
working, after the detect and mount cdrom phase failed, I went into a 
shell and did modprobe esp. This then starts the in-built scsi card 
and detects the cdrom and hard disk. I then exited the shell, tried the 
detect cdrom step again, and the rest of the install proceeded 
normally. (I also needed to know that the network controller was a Happy 
Meal card).


To get to this point, I had also tried the latest etch cd installer 
which uses a 2.6 kernel. This installer failed at other points (I had to 
modprobe esp and it couldn't mount the disk after partitioning, and 
something else too...) but what was useful was that it told me that the 
module for the scsi controller was called esp. Since this is an sbus 
system, not pci, there doesn't appear to be an equivalent of lspci 
which would have solved my problem immediately. (If there is such a 
thing, please let me know.)


So all's well that ends well. If you think that the failure to load the 
correct scsi driver modules during the detect cdrom phase is a bug, 
then I'll be happy to submit one.


Cheers,
Randall.

P.S I did all this using the serial terminal on the back of the box 
since it has no graphics card. That works fine when connected to a 
terminal with minicom (in this case an Ultra10 running linux), but you 
must turn off all flow control.



--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: Bug#306476: quick question about Bug#306476

2006-02-24 Thread Frans Pop
On Friday 24 February 2006 03:52, Randall Wayth wrote:
 Thanks for this info. I actually tried the latest etch cd yesterday but
 it failed also (to mount the CD) even though it seems to explicity
 handle SCSI cdrom devices. (At least one gets that impression from the
 messages that come up that it does.) So I wonder now exactly what the
 problem is?

I have no experience with SCSI CD-ROM drives.
The daily builds of the installer have lspci. The output of that may help 
to determine what type of controller you have (and thus what driver you 
need).

For the rest, trying things manually from VT2 is a good idea as it will 
show you any error messages better then when commands are run within the 
installer.

SunBlade 100 systems are notorious though. I tried installing one at a 
developers meeting recently and ran into the weirdest problems which were 
not even consistently reproducible. I did succeed in installing from CD 
some times, but at other times had errors halfway through the 
installation.
The only really successful installation reports we've had, have been with 
netboot installs.

It seems to me there is a serious kernel or driver bug somewhere that 
someone who has both the hardware and skills needs to trace...


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: Bug#306476: quick question about Bug#306476

2006-02-24 Thread Jim Watson
On Fri, Feb 24, 2006 at 12:18:59PM +0100, Frans Pop wrote:
 SunBlade 100 systems are notorious though. I tried installing one at a 
 developers meeting recently and ran into the weirdest problems which were 
 not even consistently reproducible. I did succeed in installing from CD 
 some times, but at other times had errors halfway through the 
 installation.
 The only really successful installation reports we've had, have been with 
 netboot installs.

I remember when I bought my sunblade 100 there were 2 type of solaris boot
disks in the package, one special was for the sunblade 100, the other would
fail half-way through.

Anyway the cdrom stopped working when it was just after warranty, and since
then it has installed debian by net boot several times with no problems.

jim


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]