[MENTORS] Create a new mail list
Hi mentors: I will to create a new git repository for TubeMQ which need a new mailing list(comm...@tubemq.apache.org) to receive commit informations. Can you help me to create it? Thanks Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午1:13写道： > Hi, > > Your mentors are here to help, but we cannot help you if you don’t > communicate on this list. The PPMC needs to take responsibility for the > tasks of moving things to the ASF, please see my previous email(s) on what > tasks tasks I think still need to be completed, you need to show progress > on these tasks. I suggest you stop working on the codebase until these > tasks are complete. If any PPMC member wants to take responsibility for a > task just respond with what you are willing to do in my other email. If you > need help on any of the setup task please ask here and tag the subject with > [MENTORS]. > > Thanks, > Justin > > -- Best Regards Guangxu
Re: Mentor responsibility and onlist communication
I am here to help! Thanks, Junping Kayne Wu 于2020年1月3日周五 下午2:59写道： > Hi Justin > thanks for reminding. > I have send my ICLA emil to secret...@apache.org and > priv...@tubemq.apache.org. please help me set up an account. > > thanks > kaynewu > > Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午1:13写道： > > > Hi, > > > > Your mentors are here to help, but we cannot help you if you don’t > > communicate on this list. The PPMC needs to take responsibility for the > > tasks of moving things to the ASF, please see my previous email(s) on > what > > tasks tasks I think still need to be completed, you need to show progress > > on these tasks. I suggest you stop working on the codebase until these > > tasks are complete. If any PPMC member wants to take responsibility for a > > task just respond with what you are willing to do in my other email. If > you > > need help on any of the setup task please ask here and tag the subject > with > > [MENTORS]. > > > > Thanks, > > Justin > > > > >
Re: Mentor responsibility and onlist communication
Hi Justin thanks for reminding. I have send my ICLA emil to secret...@apache.org and priv...@tubemq.apache.org. please help me set up an account. thanks kaynewu Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午1:13写道： > Hi, > > Your mentors are here to help, but we cannot help you if you don’t > communicate on this list. The PPMC needs to take responsibility for the > tasks of moving things to the ASF, please see my previous email(s) on what > tasks tasks I think still need to be completed, you need to show progress > on these tasks. I suggest you stop working on the codebase until these > tasks are complete. If any PPMC member wants to take responsibility for a > task just respond with what you are willing to do in my other email. If you > need help on any of the setup task please ask here and tag the subject with > [MENTORS]. > > Thanks, > Justin > >
Re: Mentor responsibility and onlist communication
Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午1:13写道： > Hi, > > Your mentors are here to help, but we cannot help you if you don’t > communicate on this list. The PPMC needs to take responsibility for the > tasks of moving things to the ASF, please see my previous email(s) on what > tasks tasks I think still need to be completed, you need to show progress > on these tasks. I suggest you stop working on the codebase until these > tasks are complete. If any PPMC member wants to take responsibility for a > task just respond with what you are willing to do in my other email. If you > need help on any of the setup task please ask here and tag the subject with > [MENTORS]. > > Thanks, > Justin > > -- Best Regards Guangxu
Re: Project bootstrapping
thanks! Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午2:34写道： > Hi, > > >Can you add me to the PPMC list [1]? My ID is gxcheng, I will complete > > some of the above tasks. > > Done. > > Thanks, > Justin > -- Best Regards Guangxu
Re: PPMC/committer responsibilities
Great, thanks! On Fri, Jan 3, 2020 at 2:42 PM Justin Mclean wrote: > Hi, > > > My preferred apache id is yihengw > > I requested an account for you, it will take a couple of days for it to be > created. > > Thanks, > Justin
Re: PPMC/committer responsibilities
Hi, > My preferred apache id is yihengw I requested an account for you, it will take a couple of days for it to be created. Thanks, Justin
Re: Project bootstrapping
Hi, >Can you add me to the PPMC list [1]? My ID is gxcheng, I will complete > some of the above tasks. Done. Thanks, Justin
Re: PPMC/committer responsibilities
HI My preferred apache id is yihengw Please help me set my account up. Thanks Yiheng On Fri, Jan 3, 2020 at 2:26 PM Justin Mclean wrote: > Hi, > > I have submitted my ICLA to secret...@apache.org two weeks ago. > > > Great. As described in that email, have you provided the TubeMQ PPMC with > your preferred apache id? > > Thanks, > Justin >
Re: Project bootstrapping
Hi justin, Can you add me to the PPMC list [1]? My ID is gxcheng, I will complete some of the above tasks. Thanks [1] https://whimsy.apache.org/roster/ppmc/tubemq Thanks, guangxu Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 下午1:45写道： > Hi, > > Can anyone help answer this? We have 18 PPMC members on this project. What > are each of you doing to help move this project to the ASF? > > Thanks, > Justin > -- Best Regards Guangxu
Re: PPMC/committer responsibilities
Hi Justin I have submitted my ICLA to secret...@apache.org two weeks ago. Please check the screenshot below. [image: 屏幕快照 2020-01-03 下午2.18.06.png] Regards, Yiheng On Fri, Jan 3, 2020 at 1:09 PM Justin Mclean wrote: > Hi, > > This are people on the PPMC of this project that as far as I can tell not > signed an ICLA: > • Goson Zhang > • Jie Jiang > • Junjie Chen > • Kayne Wu > • Lamber Liu > • Osgoo Li > • Peng Chen(?) > • Yiheng Wang > • Yuhong Liu > • Zak Wu > > I assume these people still want to be initial committers and on the PPMC? > If so what’s the hold up on getting this done? Please reply here once you > have done the paperwork. [1] > > Of the people or so who already had signed an ICLA why (for the most part) > you need to be added to the PPMC roster and sign up to the private email > address. Not many have done so, important email are sent to that list and > it is a requirement that all PPMC members have signed up. > > I suggest that all of the initial committers (if they have not done so) > read what the responsibilities of a PPMC are [2]. > > Thanks, > Justin > > 1. https://www.apache.org/licenses/contributor-agreements.html > 2. http://www.apache.org/dev/pmc.html
Re: Project bootstrapping
Hi, Can anyone help answer this? We have 18 PPMC members on this project. What are each of you doing to help move this project to the ASF? Thanks, Justin
PPMC/committer responsibilities
Hi, This are people on the PPMC of this project that as far as I can tell not signed an ICLA: • Goson Zhang • Jie Jiang • Junjie Chen • Kayne Wu • Lamber Liu • Osgoo Li • Peng Chen(?) • Yiheng Wang • Yuhong Liu • Zak Wu I assume these people still want to be initial committers and on the PPMC? If so what’s the hold up on getting this done? Please reply here once you have done the paperwork. [1] Of the people or so who already had signed an ICLA why (for the most part) you need to be added to the PPMC roster and sign up to the private email address. Not many have done so, important email are sent to that list and it is a requirement that all PPMC members have signed up. I suggest that all of the initial committers (if they have not done so) read what the responsibilities of a PPMC are [2]. Thanks, Justin 1. https://www.apache.org/licenses/contributor-agreements.html 2. http://www.apache.org/dev/pmc.html
Re: Podling Tubemq Report Reminder - January 2020
I've updated some parts of the report, please help to review, thanks! Besides, we will follow the Apache way to bring out all the discussions on the mail list, thanks for your guidance. Thanks Saisai Saisai Shao 于2020年1月3日周五 上午11:27写道： > Thanks Justin for your reply, I will amend the report soon. > > Best regards, > Saisai > > Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 上午7:03写道： > >> Hi, >> >> Thanks for submitting the report but it will not be accepted in it's >> currently form as it doesn't accurately reflect the current podlings state >> and what it needs to do. Next time I suggest you work on the report in the >> open before the due date. >> >> You have user the three most important unfinished issues to address >> before graduating: >> 1. Grow the community to involve more contributors and increase the >> diversity. >> 2. Polish the code and document to satisfy the Apache way. >> 3. Publish the Apache release. >> >> There are far more serious matters that need to be sorted out before >> those are addressed. Number one being moving conversation to this mailing >> list. >> >> Under "Are there any issues that the IPMC or ASF Board need to be aware >> of?" you have said "No" this is incorrect. >> >> Under "How has the community developed since the last report?" you >> mention PRs and commits but the repos have not moved to the ASF yet so how >> is this possible? >> >> User "How has the project developed since the last report?" you mention >> working on the first release and website. I see no conversation of this on >> list or any work towards those gaols. http://tubemq.apache.org currently >> gives 404 not found. >> >> Please rewrite the report to accurately reflect where the podling >> currently is and what issues it faces. >> >> Thanks, >> Justin >> >> >> >> >> >>
Re: Podling Tubemq Report Reminder - January 2020
Thanks Justin for your reply, I will amend the report soon. Best regards, Saisai Justin Mclean 于2020年1月3日周五 上午7:03写道： > Hi, > > Thanks for submitting the report but it will not be accepted in it's > currently form as it doesn't accurately reflect the current podlings state > and what it needs to do. Next time I suggest you work on the report in the > open before the due date. > > You have user the three most important unfinished issues to address before > graduating: > 1. Grow the community to involve more contributors and increase the > diversity. > 2. Polish the code and document to satisfy the Apache way. > 3. Publish the Apache release. > > There are far more serious matters that need to be sorted out before those > are addressed. Number one being moving conversation to this mailing list. > > Under "Are there any issues that the IPMC or ASF Board need to be aware > of?" you have said "No" this is incorrect. > > Under "How has the community developed since the last report?" you mention > PRs and commits but the repos have not moved to the ASF yet so how is this > possible? > > User "How has the project developed since the last report?" you mention > working on the first release and website. I see no conversation of this on > list or any work towards those gaols. http://tubemq.apache.org currently > gives 404 not found. > > Please rewrite the report to accurately reflect where the podling > currently is and what issues it faces. > > Thanks, > Justin > > > > > >
Re: Podling Tubemq Report Reminder - January 2020
Hi, Thanks for submitting the report but it will not be accepted in it's currently form as it doesn't accurately reflect the current podlings state and what it needs to do. Next time I suggest you work on the report in the open before the due date. You have user the three most important unfinished issues to address before graduating: 1. Grow the community to involve more contributors and increase the diversity. 2. Polish the code and document to satisfy the Apache way. 3. Publish the Apache release. There are far more serious matters that need to be sorted out before those are addressed. Number one being moving conversation to this mailing list. Under "Are there any issues that the IPMC or ASF Board need to be aware of?" you have said "No" this is incorrect. Under "How has the community developed since the last report?" you mention PRs and commits but the repos have not moved to the ASF yet so how is this possible? User "How has the project developed since the last report?" you mention working on the first release and website. I see no conversation of this on list or any work towards those gaols. http://tubemq.apache.org currently gives 404 not found. Please rewrite the report to accurately reflect where the podling currently is and what issues it faces. Thanks, Justin
Project bootstrapping
Hi, Again there seems to a be a lack on discussion on list about this, without this conversation (requested several times nows) we cannot help you. Can the PPMC please respond and tell me where they are up to with: - Submitting the software grant - Moving the repos over to ASF infrastructure - Moving the website over to ASF infrastructure - Having all PPMC members sign ICLAs - Adding all PPMC members to the roster - Having all PPMC members signed up to the private list - Moving off list communication to this list Thanks, Justin
Re: Podling Tubemq Report Reminder - January 2020
Agree. TubeMQ PPMC team should be aware of this - only discussions/decisions made on JIRA or dev list are accepted in apache way. Thanks, Junping Justin Mclean 于2020年1月2日周四 下午2:32写道： > Hi, > > > I have pinged the team and they should reply soon. > > How and where is this off list communication happening? This has been > asked several times and no answer has been supplied. Has it been made clear > to the project that communication and decisions needs to happen on this > mailing list? I understand it may take time to move towards that, but the > project needs to show signs of doing so, more so than they currently have, > otherwise they may need to explain to the IPMC why they should be an > incubating project. > > Without communication on this list the mentors and the IPMC can't help the > project. Without communication on this list this project going to find it > hard to grow it's community. Without communication on this list the project > will not graduate. > > Thanks, > Justin >
