Re: [patch/rfc] setting version type based on vendor

2008-02-18 Thread Ralf Wildenhues
Hello Mike,

Please post patches to the libtool-patches list in the future, thanks.

* Mike Frysinger wrote on Sat, Feb 16, 2008 at 09:48:52AM CET:
 i dont know if there's a policy on this, but we've been treating the shared 
 libraries in the Gentoo/FreeBSD port like Linux shared libraries.  we control 
 this based upon the vendor field in the toolchain tuple.

I have no problem with this, other than: the fact that it may create an
incompatible switch-over point for gentoo users, and the unwary may be
expecting for her libraries, built on gentoo, could be usable on other
(gasp!) FreeBSD (-like) systems, and also that GNU/FreeBSD distributions
other than gentoo (if there are any) should not be discriminated
against.  At least with GNU/Linux, the vendor field is completely useless
-- what about spin-offs of Gentoo for example, what do they use?

What do the others think?

Cheers,
Ralf

 2008-02-16  Diego Pettenò  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
   * libltdl/m4/libtool.m4: Treat Gentoo/FreeBSD shareds libs as Linux.
 




RE: [patch/rfc] setting version type based on vendor

2008-02-18 Thread Duft Markus
Hi!

Ralf Wildenhues  wrote:
 Hello Mike,
 
 Please post patches to the libtool-patches list in the future, thanks.
 
 * Mike Frysinger wrote on Sat, Feb 16, 2008 at 09:48:52AM CET:
 i dont know if there's a policy on this, but we've been treating the
 shared libraries in the Gentoo/FreeBSD port like Linux shared
 libraries.  we control this based upon the vendor field in the
 toolchain tuple. 
 
 I have no problem with this, other than: the fact that it may create
 an incompatible switch-over point for gentoo users, and the unwary
 may be expecting for her libraries, built on gentoo, could be usable
 on other (gasp!) FreeBSD (-like) systems, and also that GNU/FreeBSD
 distributions other than gentoo (if there are any) should not be
 discriminated against.  At least with GNU/Linux, the vendor field is
 completely useless -- what about spin-offs of Gentoo for example,
 what do they use? 
 
 What do the others think?

I'm running a gentoo/alt-prefix inside Interix on Windows, which i think could 
also be titled gentoo, but for sure does not behave fully like linux :)

Cheers, Markus

 
 Cheers,
 Ralf
 
 2008-02-16  Diego Pettenò  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
  * libltdl/m4/libtool.m4: Treat Gentoo/FreeBSD shareds libs as Linux.