[License-discuss] Fwd: [Osi] [General enquiries] Type of License and Keylock

2014-07-10 Thread Patrick Masson
I'm not sure if anyone got back to Giorgio on this. I am sure he would 
appreciate this group's thoughts.


Thanks,
Patrick


 Original Message 
Subject:[Osi] [General enquiries] Type of License and Keylock
Date:   Tue, 27 May 2014 19:35:13 + (UTC)
From:   gior...@sommaruga.org
To: o...@opensource.org



Giorgio Sommaruga (gior...@sommaruga.org) sent a message using the contact
form at http://opensource.org/contact.

My team is developing a project in business area.
The software is developed in two segment.
A first segment is a basic version of software with an Open Source license,
but we don't want to allow to modify the code and then resell it. We want to
allow changes only for personal use.
And second segment is based over the basic version but with other proprietary
code, for example for more other functions or add-ons.
We want to enable our partners to modify the software and sell it, but only
with our authorization and acquiring the rights of the changes.

Furthermore we would like to combine the software with a hardware protection,
at least for the business but if possible also for the Open segment.
This, at least to keep track of who is using the software.
As an alternative for the Open segment, we would like to force the user to
register the software in order to receive an activation code.

Is this possible in the context of OSI licenses and which one?

Thanks in advance.
Sincerely
Giorgio Sommaruga

Report as inappropriate:
http://opensource.org/mollom/report/mollom_content/140527e8b62565508a

___
Osi mailing list
o...@opensource.org
http://projects.opensource.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/osi



___
License-discuss mailing list
License-discuss@opensource.org
http://projects.opensource.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/license-discuss


Re: [License-discuss] Fwd: [Osi] [General enquiries] Type of License and Keylock

2014-07-10 Thread Ben Tilly
Giorgio clearly is confusing open source and non-commercial.  The point
of open source is that when you get it, you are free to use pretty much
however you want.  Including commercially.  So any personal use only
software is not open source.

See http://opensource.org/osd-annotated for details.


On Thu, Jul 10, 2014 at 2:32 PM, Patrick Masson mas...@opensource.org
wrote:

  I'm not sure if anyone got back to Giorgio on this. I am sure he would
 appreciate this group's thoughts.

 Thanks,
 Patrick


  Original Message   Subject: [Osi] [General enquiries]
 Type of License and Keylock  Date: Tue, 27 May 2014 19:35:13 + (UTC)  
 From:
 gior...@sommaruga.org  To: o...@opensource.org

 Giorgio Sommaruga (gior...@sommaruga.org) sent a message using the contact
 form at http://opensource.org/contact.

 My team is developing a project in business area.
 The software is developed in two segment.
 A first segment is a basic version of software with an Open Source license,
 but we don't want to allow to modify the code and then resell it. We want to
 allow changes only for personal use.
 And second segment is based over the basic version but with other proprietary
 code, for example for more other functions or add-ons.
 We want to enable our partners to modify the software and sell it, but only
 with our authorization and acquiring the rights of the changes.

 Furthermore we would like to combine the software with a hardware protection,
 at least for the business but if possible also for the Open segment.
 This, at least to keep track of who is using the software.
 As an alternative for the Open segment, we would like to force the user to
 register the software in order to receive an activation code.

 Is this possible in the context of OSI licenses and which one?

 Thanks in advance.
 Sincerely
 Giorgio Sommaruga

 Report as 
 inappropriate:http://opensource.org/mollom/report/mollom_content/140527e8b62565508a

 ___
 Osi mailing 
 listOsi@opensource.orghttp://projects.opensource.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/osi




 ___
 License-discuss mailing list
 License-discuss@opensource.org
 http://projects.opensource.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/license-discuss


___
License-discuss mailing list
License-discuss@opensource.org
http://projects.opensource.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/license-discuss