Re: [MOPO] The Posterfix/Andrea saga

2008-10-29 Thread Greg Pflugfelder
Dear Phil: I completely agree with you. I should probably keep my  
mouth shut here, but it seems nobody else is, so here goes. I find it  
pretty amazing that all this discussion (if that's the word) has been  
been going on under the premise -- I believe somebody actually assured  
the rest of us it was the case -- that Chris was always free to speak  
up and defend himself, and here the guy doesn't even know what MOPO  
is. I believe it's called the Obama strategy--where you buy up all the  
airtime so that only one view can be represented (don't get me wrong,  
I'm an Obama supporter). Frankly, I find that self-righteousness is  
the ugliest form of human behavior. No prettier is trying to drive  
someone's business into the ground by taking advantage of the closed  
nature of the community and the communications channels by which it  
sustains itself. It feels like I have been witnessing a lynching; or  
maybe it's just a bad Fifties sci-fi movie. I have a lot of respect  
for MOPO and all the people on it, but I don't think it's only Chris  
that this entire exchange casts a pretty dismal light on.


I guess I'll just keep my mouth shut from here on in. Wouldn't want to  
get in trouble with law enforcement!


Greg Pflugfelder

Quoting Phil Edwards <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:


Kirby - I can't see where you did anything wrong or any need make any kind
of an apology.

Unless the full texts of these emails - from both sides - is posted (here
and not "extracts" on NSF as I have seen), and transcripts of the phone
calls, then there is now so much hearsay, that whatever or not this guy did
or said, and whatever Andrea did or said has gone way beyond the pale of
this dicussion group and ethics of any kind, I'm appalled and it takes
something serious for that.

Scott, this whole thing needs deleting in my opinion, and needs to be sorted
out bewteen the parties involved. If the abusive emails are what has been
stated and without provocation, then surely it's time to call law
enforcement in.

Gee, and I thought NSF could get spikey and vicious.
Phil




- Original Message -
From: "McDaniel Kirby" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Freedom Lover" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "Halegua Richard" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Patrick Tupy Michael"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Phil Edwards" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Wednesday, October 29, 2008 4:00 PM
Subject: CLOUTIER debacle



Andrea, I called him ONCE this morning and told him there was a
discusssion about him
on MOPO and that it wasn't very favorable to him, and that it was in his
interest to know this.  This was the first time I have
spoken to him in more than a few years.  He said he did not know what
MOPO was
and so I told him that MOPO was a discussion group and that he was  being
discussed
and not in a good light and that he might want to address this.

I probably should have minded my own business.  I certainly did not
understand all this.  Sending abusive and threatening e-mail and name
calling is utterly reprehensible and I strongly condemn this
behavior toward you or anyone.

All good wishes,
Kirby

On Oct 28, 2008, at 8:45 PM, Freedom Lover wrote:


Thank-you.  Well, I shared those emails with Claude, too.  That's  it.
There's more that arrived later.  Wow!  He called 3 more times  tonight.
And replied to different emails from days before, that had  been
previously answered.   I'm thinking of buying a pit bull!

So let me see if I'm getting this right:

This morning he emailed saying he was sending my poster back, undone
(again).  This is good.

Later he starts harassing the he** out of me with his vulgarity and
incessant phone calls and leaves a message that he's keeping my  poster
(suddenly backed) and I assumed that included my money.  This  is an
about face.

Kirby, is it from you calling him?

I lost more than Richie, folks.  Hey, if I'm going to lose my  poster, I
may as well have some good come out of it.  I'm glad to be  of service to
you and I thank those of you who've stood up for me  and those who spoke
about their own experiences with Chris.

Andrea

On Oct 28, 2008, at 9:12 PM, Richard Halegua Comic Art wrote:


well that's equally onerous to the language that he used in the  letter
to Andrea that she shared with me as well as sue

the one where he calls her a "C"

I think he should start there. I mean, I don't think I've used that
word in front of a woman since I was a sophomore in hi-school and I
most certainly have never used it AT a woman in my entire life.
Behavior of that nature is much more telling than anything Chris  could
say here..

but like I said.. I had my single experience with Posterfix in  2004,
and based on that single experience I determined they were  not worthy
of any further business . It was a $50 lesson for me and  $50 worth of
bad advertising for Posterfix

Rich==


At 05:42 PM 10/28/2008, Freedom Lover wrote:

Well then, I'd like Chris to explain to MoPo how he decided he  gets to
keep my poster AND my money because I told MoPo 

[MOPO] The Posterfix/Andrea saga

2008-10-29 Thread Phil Edwards
Kirby - I can't see where you did anything wrong or any need make any kind 
of an apology.

Unless the full texts of these emails - from both sides - is posted (here 
and not "extracts" on NSF as I have seen), and transcripts of the phone 
calls, then there is now so much hearsay, that whatever or not this guy did 
or said, and whatever Andrea did or said has gone way beyond the pale of 
this dicussion group and ethics of any kind, I'm appalled and it takes 
something serious for that.

Scott, this whole thing needs deleting in my opinion, and needs to be sorted 
out bewteen the parties involved. If the abusive emails are what has been 
stated and without provocation, then surely it's time to call law 
enforcement in.

Gee, and I thought NSF could get spikey and vicious.
Phil




- Original Message - 
From: "McDaniel Kirby" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Freedom Lover" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "Halegua Richard" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Patrick Tupy Michael" 
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Phil Edwards" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Wednesday, October 29, 2008 4:00 PM
Subject: CLOUTIER debacle


> Andrea, I called him ONCE this morning and told him there was a 
> discusssion about him
> on MOPO and that it wasn't very favorable to him, and that it was in his
> interest to know this.  This was the first time I have
> spoken to him in more than a few years.  He said he did not know what 
> MOPO was
> and so I told him that MOPO was a discussion group and that he was  being 
> discussed
> and not in a good light and that he might want to address this.
>
> I probably should have minded my own business.  I certainly did not 
> understand all this.  Sending abusive and threatening e-mail and name 
> calling is utterly reprehensible and I strongly condemn this
> behavior toward you or anyone.
>
> All good wishes,
> Kirby
>
> On Oct 28, 2008, at 8:45 PM, Freedom Lover wrote:
>
>> Thank-you.  Well, I shared those emails with Claude, too.  That's  it. 
>> There's more that arrived later.  Wow!  He called 3 more times  tonight. 
>> And replied to different emails from days before, that had  been 
>> previously answered.   I'm thinking of buying a pit bull!
>>
>> So let me see if I'm getting this right:
>>
>> This morning he emailed saying he was sending my poster back, undone 
>> (again).  This is good.
>>
>> Later he starts harassing the he** out of me with his vulgarity and 
>> incessant phone calls and leaves a message that he's keeping my  poster 
>> (suddenly backed) and I assumed that included my money.  This  is an 
>> about face.
>>
>> Kirby, is it from you calling him?
>>
>> I lost more than Richie, folks.  Hey, if I'm going to lose my  poster, I 
>> may as well have some good come out of it.  I'm glad to be  of service to 
>> you and I thank those of you who've stood up for me  and those who spoke 
>> about their own experiences with Chris.
>>
>> Andrea
>>
>> On Oct 28, 2008, at 9:12 PM, Richard Halegua Comic Art wrote:
>>
>>> well that's equally onerous to the language that he used in the  letter 
>>> to Andrea that she shared with me as well as sue
>>>
>>> the one where he calls her a "C"
>>>
>>> I think he should start there. I mean, I don't think I've used that 
>>> word in front of a woman since I was a sophomore in hi-school and I 
>>> most certainly have never used it AT a woman in my entire life. 
>>> Behavior of that nature is much more telling than anything Chris  could 
>>> say here..
>>>
>>> but like I said.. I had my single experience with Posterfix in  2004, 
>>> and based on that single experience I determined they were  not worthy 
>>> of any further business . It was a $50 lesson for me and  $50 worth of 
>>> bad advertising for Posterfix
>>>
>>> Rich==
>>>
>>>
>>> At 05:42 PM 10/28/2008, Freedom Lover wrote:
 Well then, I'd like Chris to explain to MoPo how he decided he  gets to
 keep my poster AND my money because I told MoPo about all this.  He
 left me a voice message.  Actually, he called my house 30 times  today.

 Start there, Counselor.

 Andrea


 On Oct 28, 2008, at 12:21 PM, McDaniel Kirby wrote:

> Wait a minute.  Kangaroo Court in now in session.
>
> All rise!
>
>
> I have telephoned Chris Cloutier and alerted him to the brou-ha-ha
> on MOPO.  I suggested he get in touch
> with mopo to address the concerns.  He said he would.
>
> We don't have a dog in this hunt.  We use different restorers.
> Understand that this is not a comment
> on Chris or his work, it's just a fact.
>
> Kirby McDaniel
>
>
>
>
> Kirby McDaniel
> MovieArt Original Film Posters
> P.O. Box 4419
> Austin TX 78765-4419
> 512 479 6680  www.movieart.net
> mobile 512 589 5112
>
>  Visit the MoPo Mailing List Web Site at www.filmfan.com
> ___
>   How to UNSUBSCRIBE from the MoPo Mailing Lis