Re: [jbehave-user] Problem with parameter injection when an examples table is used

2014-02-07 Thread Hans Schwäbli 
I debugged it and as it seems, this method does not work as I would expect
it: org.jbehave.core.steps.StepCreator.ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep()

The org.jbehave.core.annotations.Named annotation supports only one
value. But in my use cases I need two values: creditAccount and
debitAccount.

What if you support using an regular expression for the @Named annotation
instead of allowing just one value?

That could be one way to solve it. The method
ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep() would need to be adapted accordingly
to support that logic.


2014-02-07 Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com:

 Hello Mauro,

 I took the time to create an example project for Eclipse so that you can
 reproduce it.

 I attached the zip file to this email. Hopfully it is passed to the
 mailing list. If not, I will have to upload it somewhere and tell you the
 download link.

 You will see that it is not working as I expect it.

 My intention is to use the data from the examples table to pass it into
 the step.

 I have to use two different variable names for the account number, since I
 use both credit account number and debit account number in the examples
 table. If I would only use one account number in the examples table it
 would pass the value into the method.
 But with the way how I tried to use it, debitAccount and
 creditAccount are passed into the step method instead of the actual
 values from the examples table.

 I hope you can help me to achieve my goal.


 2014-02-06 Mauro Talevi mauro.tal...@aquilonia.org:

 Hi

 what is the stated intention here?   You want two steps to match the same
 method with different parameter names?

 Can you please provide a sample project - inclusive of textual stories
 and steps class that reproduces your issue?

 Thanks


 On 06/02/2014 16:52, Hans Schwäbli wrote:

 I have two steps like this with a examples table where the values are
 defined:
 Given the account data of debitAccount is known
 Given the account data of creditAccount is known
 First I tried this in the step class method for the two steps above:
 @Given(the account data of $debitAccount is known)
 It works only for the first of the two steps. But the second step gets
 value creditAccount passed into the method instead of the actual value
 from the examples table.
 So I changed the annotation to be like this:
 @Given(the account data of $acount is known)
 But this does not work for both steps above since debitAccount and
 creditAccount is passed into the method instead of the actual values.
 Then I tried it with an alias:
 @Given(the account data of debitAccount is known)
 @Alias(the account data of creditAccount is known)
 The result was that the story failed without showing me why (no
 exception or any meaningful message).
 I tried also some other things with no success. I use JBehave 3.9 by the
 way.
 Can you please tell me the solution?



 -
 To unsubscribe from this list, please visit:

http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email

Re: [jbehave-user] Problem with parameter injection when an examples table is used

2014-02-07 Thread Hans Schwäbli 
As it seems it can be solved with configuring the MostUsefuleConfiguration
like this:
 .useParameterControls(new
ParameterControls().useDelimiterNamedParameters(true))

It is even documented here:
http://jbehave.org/reference/stable/parametrised-scenarios.html(Parametrisation
by name delimiters).

I think this should be the default, using delimeter named parameters.


2014-02-07 Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com:

 I debugged it and as it seems, this method does not work as I would expect
 it: org.jbehave.core.steps.StepCreator.ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep()

 The org.jbehave.core.annotations.Named annotation supports only one
 value. But in my use cases I need two values: creditAccount and
 debitAccount.

 What if you support using an regular expression for the @Named annotation
 instead of allowing just one value?

 That could be one way to solve it. The method
 ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep() would need to be adapted accordingly
 to support that logic.


 2014-02-07 Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com:

 Hello Mauro,

 I took the time to create an example project for Eclipse so that you can
 reproduce it.

 I attached the zip file to this email. Hopfully it is passed to the
 mailing list. If not, I will have to upload it somewhere and tell you the
 download link.

 You will see that it is not working as I expect it.

 My intention is to use the data from the examples table to pass it into
 the step.

 I have to use two different variable names for the account number, since
 I use both credit account number and debit account number in the examples
 table. If I would only use one account number in the examples table it
 would pass the value into the method.
 But with the way how I tried to use it, debitAccount and
 creditAccount are passed into the step method instead of the actual
 values from the examples table.

 I hope you can help me to achieve my goal.


 2014-02-06 Mauro Talevi mauro.tal...@aquilonia.org:

 Hi

 what is the stated intention here?   You want two steps to match the
 same method with different parameter names?

 Can you please provide a sample project - inclusive of textual stories
 and steps class that reproduces your issue?

 Thanks


 On 06/02/2014 16:52, Hans Schwäbli wrote:

 I have two steps like this with a examples table where the values are
 defined:
 Given the account data of debitAccount is known
 Given the account data of creditAccount is known
 First I tried this in the step class method for the two steps above:
 @Given(the account data of $debitAccount is known)
 It works only for the first of the two steps. But the second step gets
 value creditAccount passed into the method instead of the actual value
 from the examples table.
 So I changed the annotation to be like this:
 @Given(the account data of $acount is known)
 But this does not work for both steps above since debitAccount and
 creditAccount is passed into the method instead of the actual values.
 Then I tried it with an alias:
 @Given(the account data of debitAccount is known)
 @Alias(the account data of creditAccount is known)
 The result was that the story failed without showing me why (no
 exception or any meaningful message).
 I tried also some other things with no success. I use JBehave 3.9 by
 the way.
 Can you please tell me the solution?



 -
 To unsubscribe from this list, please visit:

http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email

Re: [jbehave-user] Problem with parameter injection when an examples table is used

2014-02-07 Thread Mauro Talevi 
Hi,

this is indeed one of the solutions.

I agree that it would be more useful as a default.  Please raise a JIRA issue 
for this and we'll add it to next release.

Cheers

 On 7 Feb 2014, at 15:23, Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com wrote:
 
 As it seems it can be solved with configuring the MostUsefuleConfiguration 
 like this:
  .useParameterControls(new 
 ParameterControls().useDelimiterNamedParameters(true))
  
 It is even documented here: 
 http://jbehave.org/reference/stable/parametrised-scenarios.html 
 (Parametrisation by name delimiters).
  
 I think this should be the default, using delimeter named parameters.
 
 
 2014-02-07 Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com:
 I debugged it and as it seems, this method does not work as I would expect 
 it: org.jbehave.core.steps.StepCreator.ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep()
  
 The org.jbehave.core.annotations.Named annotation supports only one value. 
 But in my use cases I need two values: creditAccount and debitAccount.
  
 What if you support using an regular expression for the @Named annotation 
 instead of allowing just one value?
  
 That could be one way to solve it. The method 
 ParameterisedStep.parametriseStep() would need to be adapted accordingly 
 to support that logic.
 
 
 2014-02-07 Hans Schwäbli bugs.need.love@gmail.com:
 
 Hello Mauro,
 
 I took the time to create an example project for Eclipse so that you can 
 reproduce it.
 
 I attached the zip file to this email. Hopfully it is passed to the mailing 
 list. If not, I will have to upload it somewhere and tell you the download 
 link.
 
 You will see that it is not working as I expect it.
 
 My intention is to use the data from the examples table to pass it into the 
 step.
 
 I have to use two different variable names for the account number, since I 
 use both credit account number and debit account number in the examples 
 table. If I would only use one account number in the examples table it 
 would pass the value into the method.
 
 But with the way how I tried to use it, debitAccount and 
 creditAccount are passed into the step method instead of the actual 
 values from the examples table.
  
 I hope you can help me to achieve my goal.
 
 
 2014-02-06 Mauro Talevi mauro.tal...@aquilonia.org:
 
 Hi
 
 what is the stated intention here?   You want two steps to match the same 
 method with different parameter names?
 
 Can you please provide a sample project - inclusive of textual stories and 
 steps class that reproduces your issue?
 
 Thanks
 
 
 On 06/02/2014 16:52, Hans Schwäbli wrote:
 I have two steps like this with a examples table where the values are 
 defined:
 Given the account data of debitAccount is known
 Given the account data of creditAccount is known
 First I tried this in the step class method for the two steps above:
 @Given(the account data of $debitAccount is known)
 It works only for the first of the two steps. But the second step gets 
 value creditAccount passed into the method instead of the actual value 
 from the examples table.
 So I changed the annotation to be like this:
 @Given(the account data of $acount is known)
 But this does not work for both steps above since debitAccount and 
 creditAccount is passed into the method instead of the actual values.
 Then I tried it with an alias:
 @Given(the account data of debitAccount is known)
 @Alias(the account data of creditAccount is known)
 The result was that the story failed without showing me why (no exception 
 or any meaningful message).
 I tried also some other things with no success. I use JBehave 3.9 by the 
 way.
 Can you please tell me the solution?
 
 
 -
 To unsubscribe from this list, please visit:
 
http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email

[jbehave-user] Problem with parameter injection when an examples table is used

2014-02-06 Thread Hans Schwäbli 
I have two steps like this with a examples table where the values are
defined:

Given the account data of debitAccount is known
Given the account data of creditAccount is known

First I tried this in the step class method for the two steps above:

@Given(the account data of $debitAccount is known)

It works only for the first of the two steps. But the second step gets
value creditAccount passed into the method instead of the actual value
from the examples table.

So I changed the annotation to be like this:

@Given(the account data of $acount is known)

But this does not work for both steps above since debitAccount and
creditAccount is passed into the method instead of the actual values.

Then I tried it with an alias:

@Given(the account data of debitAccount is known)
@Alias(the account data of creditAccount is known)

The result was that the story failed without showing me why (no exception
or any meaningful message).

I tried also some other things with no success. I use JBehave 3.9 by the
way.

Can you please tell me the solution?

Re: [jbehave-user] Problem with parameter injection when an examples table is used

2014-02-06 Thread Mauro Talevi 

Hi

what is the stated intention here?   You want two steps to match the 
same method with different parameter names?


Can you please provide a sample project - inclusive of textual stories 
and steps class that reproduces your issue?


Thanks

On 06/02/2014 16:52, Hans Schwäbli wrote:
I have two steps like this with a examples table where the values are 
defined:

Given the account data of debitAccount is known
Given the account data of creditAccount is known
First I tried this in the step class method for the two steps above:
@Given(the account data of $debitAccount is known)
It works only for the first of the two steps. But the second step gets 
value creditAccount passed into the method instead of the actual 
value from the examples table.

So I changed the annotation to be like this:
@Given(the account data of $acount is known)
But this does not work for both steps above since debitAccount and 
creditAccount is passed into the method instead of the actual values.

Then I tried it with an alias:
@Given(the account data of debitAccount is known)
@Alias(the account data of creditAccount is known)
The result was that the story failed without showing me why (no 
exception or any meaningful message).
I tried also some other things with no success. I use JBehave 3.9 by 
the way.

Can you please tell me the solution?



-
To unsubscribe from this list, please visit:

   http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email