Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-08-09 Thread Peter Suber
[From: FOS Newsletter http://makeashorterlink.com/?Z53834B71 ] Interview with Ingenta CEO Mark Rowse In my last issue (FOSN for 6/17/02) I wondered why Ingenta had appointed such an FOS-friendly advisory board. Ingenta produces electronic editions of scholarly journals for publishers of print jou

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-25 Thread Albert Henderson
on Sat, 20 Jul 2002 Stevan Harnad wrote [snip] > What about copyright? > http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#copyright1 > > The author holds the copyright for the pre-refereeing preprint, > so that can be self-archived without seeking anyone else's > permission. For the refereed postpri

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-22 Thread Barbara Kirsop
The posting on July 18th from Stevan relates to email messages sent to both Stevan and Ingenta by myself and the Electronic Publishing Trust (EPT), respectively. I would like to make clear that we were not concerned about copyright issues, the legitimate activities of commercial organisations, com

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-20 Thread Stevan Harnad
>>No. Someone is (passively) failing to provide free access to their own >>contributions to those journals, and that someone is the author of each >>and every article appearing therein (with the exception of a growing >>number of physicists and a few other disciplines at last beginn

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-20 Thread Richard Stallman
No. Someone is (passively) failing to provide free access to their own contributions to those journals, and that someone is the author of each and every article appearing therein (with the exception of a growing number of physicists and a few other disciplines at last beginning to d

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-19 Thread Stevan Harnad
>> ...it is a waste of time ranting and raving against toll-access >> publishers, overpriced or not: They (including Ingenta) are simply doing >> what they can and should be doing: Providing toll-access as long as >> there is a demand for it. On Fri, 19 Jul 2002, [identity removed] wrote: > I don

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-18 Thread Stevan Harnad
This is a reply to another commentator's expression of concern (excerpt will be quoted shortly) about the license that Southampton University has given to Ingenta to develop a commercial service to install, customize and maintain Eprints Archives for Universities who wish to purchase such a service

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-17 Thread David Goodman
Not only is there nothing to worry about: for such a knowledgeable ejournal provider as Ingenta to consider that it can make money from offering this service is an extremely encouraging sign. I hope they sell many copies, and have a great commercial success. It's a major step towards the general ac

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-16 Thread Thomas Krichel
I think that much of this debate comes from a confusion about the meaning of the term "free". When we talk about Eprints software being free, the term "free" should take the meaning as implied by the GNU public license. In this particular meaning, one should think of it as "freedom", rath

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-16 Thread Stevan Harnad
/Amsci/2115.html and: "Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service" http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/2111.html There is nothing wrong with a vendor selling software that is also available for free! (The real service Ingenta is offering is installing and maintaining Ar

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-16 Thread Subbiah Arunachalam
Dear Stevan: I hear that Eprints has entered into an agreement with Ingenta and that future versions of Eprints software may not be free. Is it true? Is this an admission that the Open access movement is losing momentum and even the greatest of its champions is entering into an agreement with a co

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-04 Thread Stevan Harnad
> From: [Identity Removed] > > ...we'd like some more information. There are quite a lot of > questions - not least, I would have thought, regarding the > reliability of the content in the open archives. "The Open Archives" refers to any archive that is compliant with the OAI metadata harvesting

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-02 Thread Stevan Harnad
My friend and ally Chris Green's alarm is understandable, in view of several notable instances in which open-access has been betrayed by erstwhile advocates' defecting to the toll-access camp! But that hasn't happened here, with Eprints and Ingenta: On Tue, 2 Jul 2002, Christopher D. Green wrote:

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-02 Thread Christopher D. Green
Peter Suber wrote: > For immediate release, July 1, 2002 > INGENTA SIGNS STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP WITH THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON TO > CREATE > OPEN ARCHIVE E-PRINT SERVICES > [] > Under the terms of the strategic partnership, Ingenta will create an > enhanced, commercially supported version

Re: Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-02 Thread Stevan Harnad
On Tue, 2 Jul 2002, Peter Suber wrote: > I'm puzzled by Ingenta and want to explain why... Ingenta no doubt has its own agenda, but I think there is nothing at all there for advocates of open access to worry about. > ...Ingenta does not offer open-access. Publishers pay Ingenta to produce > ele

Ingenta to offer OAI eprint service

2002-07-02 Thread Peter Suber
For immediate release, July 1, 2002 INGENTA SIGNS STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP WITH THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON TO CREATE OPEN ARCHIVE E-PRINT SERVICES Ingenta plc, which empowers the exchange of scholarly and professional research content online, has signed a strategic partnership with the Unive