[Goanet] Constitutional Propriety

2005-10-07 Thread tonyca
The Supreme Court has rightly held that the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly was unconstitutional. On assuming office, the President of India takes a solemn oath to uphold the Constitution. The same Consitution as currently amended enjoins him to accept any recommendation of the Cabinet f

[Goanet] Constitutional Propriety

2005-10-09 Thread Sachin Phadte
Tony Correia-Afonso has rightly asked the question whether the President of India should have signed the reommendation for governor's rule in Bihar, in light of the Supreme Court declaring the event as unconsitutional. Even while I full agree with Tony's suggestion that the President should ta

[Goanet] Constitutional Propriety

2005-10-10 Thread tonyca
In his response to my posting on the subject, Sachin Phadte asks about the role of the President: "Under the circumstances, what could he have done?" As pointed out by M.J. Akbar, the editor of "Asian Age" in a recent issue of the paper, he could have: 1) Asked for time and stated that he woul