Re: [Goanet] Does Francisc Newton Souza qualify as a 'Great Goan?'

2006-12-04 Thread Venantius Pinto
Chris. Is this a rhetorical question? Is this one of those must know answers that needs to be qualitatively analyzed; furthermore to be regurgitated at Goan or for that matter Desi parties. And would it make someone sleep better if it could be proved that FN was one heck of a "Great Goan." Art

Re: [Goanet] Does Francisc Newton Souza qualify as a 'Great Goan?'

2006-12-05 Thread Frederick \"FN\" Noronha
I liked VM's essay on his meeting with Francis Newton Souza in the Jerry Pinto-edited ("Reflected in Water: Writings on Goa"). It's called 'The Man Who Swallowed Goa Whole'. A quote: "Goans are savages, they have no idea about the meaning of high art. I used to talk to Goans about art but all they

Re: [Goanet] Does Francisc Newton Souza qualify as a 'Great Goan?'

2006-12-06 Thread Stanley Pinto
Venantius, I read your very elegant message to Chris Vaz in response to his (I assume) article Does Francis Newton Souza qualify as a 'Great Goan? I haven't seen that original article. But elegance does not legitimise cynicism or ignorance. And so much of your message is a sad melange of those