Boy, talk about fixing what isn't broken

2004-06-14 Thread Dan Kolis
The existing RFC creation/ratification process works so much better than other structures I can't see a reason to tinker with it whatsoever. Its a weridly beautiful comprimise that slices thru B.S. and gets things that work, for a *really long time* (so far: forever) into play fast. Boy.

[Ietf] TLDs a thing not to do

2004-04-29 Thread Dan Kolis
Karl A said: Anybody who wants a new TLD should have to pledge allegance to the end-to-end principle (i.e. no new sitefinders) and promise to adhere to applicable internet technical standards and practices. Dan K says: The idea of harvesting bad DNS accesses as a business plan never occured to be

Patents? we don't need no stinking Patents!

2004-04-02 Thread Dan Kolis
Dean Anderson said, and is While finding prior art is hard problem in any field, it would be helpful if the Patent Office hired more experts in the fields that they offer patents in, and in particular, more computer scientists. Dan says: In the above, a chemist would substitute Chemist

License for downloading music - well!

2004-02-26 Thread Dan Kolis
The Electronic Frontier Foundation has proposed a scheme to decriminalize file-swapping, whereby users would pay $5 a month in license fees. The annual $3 billion this would net would compensate artists and record labels, the group says. San Jose Mercury News (2/26), Wired (2/26)

Peppercoin

2004-02-26 Thread Dan Kolis
Hi, John S mentioned this micropayment scheme: http://www.peppercoin.com/General/FAQAnswerPage.ppp?keyID=helpfaq/faqs/Abo utPeppercointopicIndex=3 Interesting, but its really built on information goods specifically. Like tradedoor crypto sprinkled with dollar value connections. Thanks.

Primal urges in the can-the-spam movement

2004-02-13 Thread Dan Kolis
Robert Brown said: Let's BUY the MTA server and two encryption nodes whose only job is to ensure that the MTA queue never runs dry, each equipped with 600 GB in RAID3. Let's see, that would be, hmm, less than $10K if one got gold plated parts, less than $4K at my local OTC no-name computer store.

Multiplication, specifically large numbers by small ones

2004-02-12 Thread Dan Kolis
Further, any cost increase in email that is less than the cost of bulk postal mail will not deter genuine spammers. But even the regular user would feel the crunch if each email cost $0.37. If the IETF had to pay $0.37 per email, or even $0.15 per email, its 2 million/yr or so budget would not

My first hand routed SIP call - Good example for new users

2004-01-21 Thread Dan Kolis
: 4769498 First SIP call Regards, Dan Kolis

RE: Effectiveness of STUN protocol

2004-01-20 Thread Dan Kolis
Masataka Ohta wrote about STUN Is it a client server app or a P2P app? Hi. Well, I read the RFC in some detail, and it is an application which should be on the public internet side on a stable server. Its clients could be all kinds of processes/apps, from P2P programs mostly, but its a

STUN protocol implementations

2004-01-20 Thread Dan Kolis
About STUN: Reading it, it would seem like the app could ask about itself and then forward the real IP(s) and ports, avoiding having the STUN server get a lot of hits. But this is a REAL workaround no matter what. That doesn't make it a bad thing. The documents really clear that it is a way to

P2P - Crime / NAT

2004-01-19 Thread Dan Kolis
This really doesn't say much about the scalability of the solution. What it indicates is how much effort people are willing to go to to commit what is perceived as victimless crime. Two things. First, here in Canada there is a new tax on media like writable CD's; (extendable to Memory cards, or

Effectiveness of STUN protocol

2004-01-19 Thread Dan Kolis
Michel said: This is not true. Kaaza does not require to open any ports nor configure anything in the NAT box. The latest versions of SIP using STUN don't either. Dan asks: Yes indeed. Probably the #1 biggest use for STUN short term is going to be SIP. It seems like not too much information has

Your all complaining about NAT mostly

2004-01-13 Thread Dan Kolis
I'm making a product from scratch shortly and think the tide has turned to support IPv6 as much as possible. I haven't looked. Are Docsis Cable modems 2.0 IPv6 aware? How about MS operating systems? If ISP's and cable ops didn't ration fixed IP's NAT wouldn't be so popular. Its a way to evade an

Re: Your all complaining about NAT mostly

2004-01-13 Thread Dan Kolis
Actually, I'm told by ISP people that they don't make money off their address charges, that they basically just cover their own costs. Noel Bell Canada here charges $10 or so for a few fixed IP's per month. They are bought for $0.60 US as a one time cost. A pretty good cover. Regs, Dan Dan

10 Years

2004-01-13 Thread Dan Kolis
behind the scenes thing a little. slightly different. But I think your right if 10 years of waiting doesn't get an internet innovation adopted much its at least sick and maybe dead. regs Dan Dan Kolis - Lindsay Electronics Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED] 50 Mary Street West, Lindsay Ontario Canada K9V 2S7

Re: Death of the Internet - details at 11

2004-01-13 Thread Dan Kolis
Yup, it needs a killer app or feature. Bigger address space was that feature, but one made moot by NATs. VoIP and multimedia via SIP without having a resident network engineer in your attic. Enough said? Dan

Eating the canned from the new information society

2003-12-11 Thread Dan Kolis
I was curious enough to read the contents of this URL, (about the U.N. about to meet to do something or another with the information society): http://www.itu.int/wsis Site barely moves. We have good bandwidth and its 400 bit/S, says my browser. So, for fun, I tried: http://www.alpo.com/

Re: Worst case question I guess

2003-12-09 Thread Dan Kolis
. Statistically, that means your 24 hour rollback might, often, have zero effect. Now compare this to the change rate in some very large ccTLD or gTLD, which is, I would assume, measured in the thousands per day range. john Dan Kolis - Lindsay Electronics Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED] 50 Mary Street

Worst case question I guess

2003-12-08 Thread Dan Kolis
. There was an outage in the switched telephone system much like this about 12 years ago. None of the technocrats who could fix it could find each other, so the outage persisted for a long time until an unnamed vendor! bicyled new binaries to 400 phone switches. regards Dan Dan Kolis - Lindsay Electronics

Synopsis of Internet relevant White house document(s) regarding security

2003-12-05 Thread Dan Kolis
Greetings, The cleaning people came through my building so I decided since I shouldn't walk on there wet floors (until they dry), I might as well save the free world with my unsolicited, amazing opinions. The below I gather is the White House official policy on tinkering with everything

Re: Ietf ITU DNS stuff III

2003-12-04 Thread Dan Kolis
Franck said: Well to come back to my original comment, is that IETF, IANA and ICANN by being individual members organisations do not have the front of ITU, which is unfortunate as the Internet is not being done in ITU. Governments have to understand that and for that dissociate themselves from the

An apology of sorts

2003-12-04 Thread Dan Kolis
Hi One paragraph to apologize about being aggressive about the ITU. So much comes out of them as a group that is nessessary and excellent, I'm sorry to be critical of their proposed increased role in internet. Stuff like AC-3 sound, the WARC process, is good work. Its not the people that slow it

Ietf ITU DNS stuff

2003-12-03 Thread Dan Kolis
Dean said: But of course, governments have the sovereign right to control the communications of their citizens... Dan says: Well, I don't agree. If you believe in speech divorced from action; (ex. Commercial speech, inciting to riot, fraud), in which speech is a component of an act... Just

Ietf ITU DNS stuff III

2003-12-03 Thread Dan Kolis
Dean said: There are, though, good reasons to have some government controls on telecom. Whether these controls are too excessive or too lax is not up to ICANN or the ITU. I can think of cases were some good has come of it. E911, for example. Radio, TV, cellphone allocations. Ham Radio

ICANN but I CAN'T, sometimes

2003-12-01 Thread Dan Kolis
Any formal body has to have some jurisdiction in which it is constituted. One can argue whether California non-profit law is better or worse than being a UN entity. I believe there are arguments against the latter as much as there may arguments against the former. The IETF is about as close as

Verisign problems - redirection without RR's

2003-09-23 Thread Dan Kolis
I'm hoping for a 'change of faith' based on the $100 Million lawsuit. I can't believe anyone capable of doing this, would do this. Even the paper newspapers get this is somehow a bad development; (ie wall st journal). Proves ICANN is not interested in the integrity of the DNS to have permitted

Verisign problems - redirection without RR's, how did it come to be?

2003-09-23 Thread Dan Kolis
Dan said earlier: Proves ICANN is not interested in the integrity of the DNS to have permitted this. Marc said is reasponse (to some extent): ICANN is probably busy trying to find a way to copyright the root domain. Everyone wants his slice of the unlimited possibilities for manufactured

POP3 extensions - thanks

2003-09-09 Thread Dan Kolis
Pete Resnick at Qualcomm tells me/us of POP3 extensions: RFC 2449: POP3 Extension Mechanism. and POP already has authentication (RFC 1734) and TLS (RFC 2595), but I don't think that's what you're talking about. I don't see how crypto or authentication apply to spam in the context of POP here.

POP3 delivers, not deletes III

2003-09-08 Thread Dan Kolis
Harold I / Dan K said: A *lot* of POP-using programs have the Leave Mail On Server option. And a lot of people have used Leave Mail On Server as a poor man's 1-folder IMAP, leading POP providers to implement mail retaining policies of the RETR it once and it's gone, whether you DELEted it or

POP3 prograsm that enforce old message policies

2003-09-08 Thread Dan Kolis
John K said: I am pretty sure Vint knows what the protocol says. So, certainly, do I. In the real world, several ISPs have insisted that their servers provide an implicit DELE after messages have been successfully downloaded and the connection closed. If leaving the mail on the server (not

Portable voice services with switching between urban and home

2003-09-04 Thread Dan Kolis
Greg Cunningham said: Personally I would be more interested in a cellular phone that would hop to a private home network signal. Once you get home (or within a 1/2 mile or so) you the cell phone becomes an extension in your house. Would be even nicer if the line went out, and the phone company

VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Dan Kolis
Masataka Ohta and/or Simon said: You should, at least, distinguish VoIP as a telephone network and the Internet telephony. In Japan, TAs to connect the Internet and POTS telephone devices are rapidly replacing the telephone network including VoIP ones. a. VoIP is telephony and should be regulated.

Multimedia presentation services like (ugh) VoIP

2003-09-02 Thread Dan Kolis
I think SIP does more things that are fun rather than only things that are useful. This matters all the time; Not just when there is an earthquake, etc. Spending and planning, not technology per se determines whether things work in an emergency. Besides, the future is long. What familiar now

Well, Marketing maybe (SIP, etc)

2003-09-02 Thread Dan Kolis
with more sizzle (and accuracy) than poor peoples phone services. While on the subject... Has anybody seen a fer sure count of how many LDAP or RR named persons are out there for SIP names? Obviously, that's one bottleneck for SIP that's hard to overcome. regs, Dan Dan Kolis - Lindsay

Pretty clear ... SIP

2003-08-21 Thread Dan Kolis
Since SIP is IETF not ITU its only reasonable to have internet believers lean towards it. H.323 ? Ahhh no thanks. No serious look at these can even consider H.323 etc and its derivitives as useful in the general case. The only reason they were used is the absence of a better alternative. Try to

That's *really* new!

2003-07-14 Thread Dan Kolis
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ...IPv6 over telepathy Dan says: Wow! I had that idea yesterday; (It's almost like you where reading my mind) !!! Scoundrel!

Innovations in protocols

2003-07-14 Thread Dan Kolis
On Mon, 14 Jul 2003 13:35:42 EDT, [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Dan Kolis) said: [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ...IPv6 over telepathy Dan says: Wow! I had that idea yesterday; (It's almost like you where reading my mind) !!! The draft for IPv6 over telepathy strongly recommends the use of IPSEC in multi-hop

IMAP v. POP

2003-06-05 Thread Dan Kolis
Lots of users don't like you have to be connected to IMAP to do routine things fulltime. If your paying by the minute for CDMA2000, (for instance), getting frozen out of doing anything when your not connected turns people off. Network people like the reduced traffic on the network for POP logins

IMAP v. POP

2003-06-05 Thread Dan Kolis
It was said about IMAP versus POP mail: Perhaps those folks should use an implementation that can manipulate mail offline and then sync with the server later. Dan says: The group I know have an information technology group which raid and confiscate anything they don't install. They terrorize

Stray question, (a little bit) (What's the best practice on this?)

2003-06-05 Thread Dan Kolis
Hi, A little off the center of the road, but that's nothing new here. As users tend to use HTTP email accounts; (for privacy, flirting, whatever) in enterprises this makes it hard to snag viruses to some extent. If the preferred solution in some server farm of linux and NT's whatever is

SMS, New media, old media

2003-05-27 Thread Dan Kolis
Said presumably moments ago: we (the e-mail producing/consuming community) have the technology, we have the collective wit and wisdom, we have the proven commercial value of the service. what we lack, dear ietf, is simply: leadership. Paul Vixie Dan (Me) says. Well. I like Short Message Service

The utility of IP, port blocking

2003-05-27 Thread Dan Kolis
Said today: In a major example of false positives, we already have examples of one real cost of spam. AOL (as one example of many) has declared ranges of IP addresses marked 'residential' as invalid for running a particular application. In this case SMTP, but which app is next? There is a 'guilt

IAB policy - Spam, etc

2003-03-05 Thread Dan Kolis
is a voluntary method by which they can reduce or limit their support expenses on customers who are not paying extra for the initiate SMTP service. if you don't believe that comcast ought to have the ability to control how its services are used, then your recourse is the local PUC, and the FCC. Dan Kolis

The essential non-weirdness of Son'ys Playstation PS2

2003-01-02 Thread Dan Kolis
is on the CC line and the leading comments. Thanks for WWW access to this code! Regards to all, Dan Kolis // lilplasma.c // my non-vpu-using first attempt at PS2 graphics. // inefficient, but pretty! // // - [EMAIL PROTECTED] // (or) [EMAIL PROTECTED] // to compile: // cc -o lilplasma lilplasma.c

COM? Ho

2002-12-04 Thread Dan Kolis
COM is a failed experiment and needs to be closed and/or eliminated. What about X.400 ??? Regards, Dan

Dislike your Spam for breakfast?

2002-12-02 Thread Dan Kolis
Seems like there is a sort of mail loop or some nasty business on this list. I like my ideas enough to hope to see them repeated here: once. If you get an extra serving. Sorry. its not me doing it. Well, if you *never* pay a ransom, you *never* give to a panhandler and

The dismal science meets computer science - The obvious thought experiment

2002-09-30 Thread Dan Kolis
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On [EMAIL PROTECTED] Hmmm. Very interesting material here on economics and traffic analysis. I remember when I heard as a young teen Kruschev and Kennedy agreed and primarily designed Intelsat, that anything upon which those guys agreed with

Bernie Ebbers - Worldcom

2002-07-12 Thread Dan Kolis
but, for one thing, there is real value in the big pipes. The general public thinks this is Enron II. Its completely different. Yea, off topic, but it effects this community, Dan (KL: This was sent to the Internet Engineering Task Force reflector) Dan Kolis - Lindsay Electronics Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED

Dynamic DNS - The dark side

2002-03-01 Thread Dan Kolis
software will strand them on ocassion. Regs to all, Dan Dan Kolis - Lindsay Electronics Ltd [EMAIL PROTECTED] 50 Mary Street West, Lindsay Ontario Canada K9V 2S7 (705) 324-2196 X 268 (705) 324-5474 Fax An ISO 9001 Company; SCTE Member ISM-127194 /Document end

Dynamic DNS - The dark side III

2002-03-01 Thread Dan Kolis
Tony Hain [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Mobility is not the only reason to use DDNS. Consider the case of Dan's residential gateway. If it provided a consumer-friendly automated DDNS server for a sub-domain delegated to the residence, what are the hard issues? First would be security, but that is

Utility of dynamic DNS

2002-03-01 Thread Dan Kolis
Randy Bush [EMAIL PROTECTED] suggested a URL about dynamic relocation and the DNS at: http://ops.ietf.org/dns/dynupd/secure-ddns-howto.html Its very interesting and a bit over my head, perhaps. Maybe its a friday document! Why Dynamic Update? Dynamic update proposes to provide a workable

Bagged cats and DNS elfs

2002-01-24 Thread Dan Kolis
Ed Gerck or Vint Cerf said: Since the cat can, and indeed may, go back to the bag in this case, it seems to be in our best interest to find ways to induce trust without recourse to control (or fear of) as the only solution. Dan says: Oh. Cats back into the bags? Easier to say then do.

Bandwidth? BANDWIDTH! We do (maybe) need more stinking bandwidth

2002-01-22 Thread Dan Kolis
Seemingly of interest specifically to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] At 08:57 PM 1/21/2002 -0800, Lixia Zhang wrote: Note I am not saying MPLS is the right solution for the problem. To me the right solution to the above mentioned problem should be a multi-path

Bandwidth? BANDWIDTH. We don't need no stinking bandwidth... we gots labels and a fancy RSVP to fix us up!

2002-01-21 Thread Dan Kolis
[EMAIL PROTECTED] asks in jest: Of course its true: no amount of QOS can generate any additional bandwidth But is the converse also true? Seriously though I say: Huh? If its free... QoS = not having QoS because everybody's app will ask for it. If there is a tarriffed QoS service every process

Cable modem spec(s) sites - lookie here

2001-11-30 Thread Dan Kolis
hi, Cablemodem means you would like info on DOCSIS (Data Over Cable Systems Interface Specs) right!! Well i guess DOCSIS 1.1 is currrent. Following are the MIBs for DOCSIS: Hi Probably full specs in PDF (about 800 pages in pieces by ISO layer) at: http://www.cablelabs.org but you have to poke

Cable Co's view: NAT is bad because we want to charge per IP, etc

2001-11-28 Thread Dan Kolis
[EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Of course, cable companies probably won't impose rate limits as long as DSL remains an option, because then they wouldn't be able to claim (inaccurately) that cable gives you more bandwidth than DSL. At least publicly ... In Canada, several cable carriers put rate limits

Question about posts on this forumn

2001-10-24 Thread Dan Kolis
Hello, Does this email reflector pass through plan text attachments to all? I sort of think its a strength of the odd email community that it gets off topic *some*. FOr instance I really found the dialog I just got about 3D teleconferencing interesting and want to post it, but think, Hmmm pretty

3D technology? I'm afraid to ask, but I am too curious not too

2001-10-23 Thread Dan Kolis
Why isn't the Internet and 3D technology used for the IETF meetings ? The Next Generation IPv8 Internet has that. Why is the IPv4 Internet Ok. MBone or not, Mime type or not, whatever. Is there some 3D imaging thing that actually exists for teleconferencing actual people I don't know about? A

3D technology? An interesting Teleconferencing box thing

2001-10-23 Thread Dan Kolis
This thing is a university type experimental gadget, It's completely irrelivant to this forum, but I would sure like to have one. http://www.evl.uic.edu/research/vrdev.html On the Internet planning side, I'd guess a three sided box of projection TV's and a camera and whatnot is probably 10

802.11B on CATV

2001-09-13 Thread Dan Kolis
Greetings, I'm looking at techniques of moving 802.11B traffic on and off two way Cable TV systems. Most proposals try to avoid any serious store and forward and instead want high response systems which are somewhat coarse. This may gnaw off the leading edge of packets and protract the trailing

Packet loss graphic - current affairs

2001-09-12 Thread Dan Kolis
Greetings to all, The useful Internet traffic report which sort of graphs ping like info including packet loss, etc shows some network congestion around 19:30 GMT (0 Zulu) about 4 hours wide. I've attached one of the packet loss graphics. For others the URL is:

Disaster Management medical info HL7

2001-09-12 Thread Dan Kolis
It was said by [EMAIL PROTECTED] earlier today: There has been many disaster happening in the past, like in Turkey, or like in Taiwan earthquake where a submarine cable was cut. I think it is time that the Internet become serious and reliable and that the IETF work on internet and disaster to

OAM - Operation, Administration, and Maintenance

2001-09-11 Thread Dan Kolis
Hello, See: Operation, Administration, and Maintenance http://www.cisco.com/univercd/cc/td/doc/product/atm/c8540/12_1/peregrin/sw_c onfg/op_maint.htm#30838 Good luck. If you didn't get a good overview it will be a crapshoot to write a program to do it. Hmmm, hope the above helps. Let me

SIP versus H.323 Multimedia teleconferencing iii

2001-08-16 Thread Dan Kolis
Thoughts from Paul as { [EMAIL PROTECTED] } begin with those from myself with { [EMAIL PROTECTED] } Thanks for your thinking. I don't want to overburden this list with items which might best be discussed elsewhere, so if there is a perception this goes on and on, just email me and I'll move it

Off season locations

2001-03-29 Thread Dan Kolis
Harald Tveit Alvestrand [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: actually the cheapest place, hotel-price-wise, to hold IETFs would probably be in a tourist trap on the off-season (the Riviera in October, after all the bathers have gone home, but before the staff leaves the hotel...) I say:

URL Resolution in printed matter

2001-03-19 Thread Dan Kolis
a field getting a fair amount of attention seens not to have mush pseudo-formal input. Regards, Dan Kolis

Question of applicability, please express an opinion if you have one on this

2001-03-15 Thread Dan Kolis
appreciate the allocation). Dan Kolis

Balkanize - IDN

2000-12-07 Thread Dan Kolis
protocols perfected in the absence of knowing how to apply them. Subtle work. I'd liek to do more of substance other than theorize. I think I will study the concepts behine unicode this weekend and try to develop a better understanding of that work. Regards to all, Dan Kolis Dan Kolis - Lindsay E

Re: Balkanize - IDN ii

2000-12-07 Thread Dan Kolis
Dan Kolis [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: One reason the IDN thing is so daunting is the work arounds are not that bad. For instance, you can embed a backgroundless GIF into a web page and have any ideogram link to a URL. That's nearly ideal in many ways. Keith Moore [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: only

Babel and the works of many - IDN

2000-12-07 Thread Dan Kolis
Matt Crawford [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: If the world had asked you or me to design an international language, I think either of us would have done better. Dan Kolis [EMAIL PROTECTED] says: Well in biblical theology; I've heard it goes like this: Everyone on earth (well on the building site

Example of dns (non) fun iv

2000-12-06 Thread Dan Kolis
foobarr, or a systemic misunderstanding. The cause of non connectivity is a new axis of freedom for error. regards, Dan Kolis

Cannot be, those wacky lawyers

2000-12-06 Thread Dan Kolis
And the lawyers would insist that something like: 180.035.069.037 would spell 1-800-Flowers and try to reserve an IP address based on that name. oh, That's ridiculous! Besides, 180.035.069.037 is already taken. It spells "Isotoner gloves" ... everybody knows that. Dan K

Diacritical application in the DNS

2000-12-05 Thread Dan Kolis
ot;snömos.se", I really want people to be able to get to http://www.snömos.se So, if I think it is perfectly all right to have http://www.bq--abzw55tnn5zq.se - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Dan Kolis [EMAIL PROTECTED] says: Now we are getting down to the nuts and bolts of the feeling

Example of dns (non) fun

2000-12-04 Thread Dan Kolis
In the present regime, its not surprising the frist below does not resolve and the second does: http://www.déjà.fr/ http://www.deja.fr/ In the proposed regime, its not obvious what to do from a purely consumer point of view. Verisigns view would be each is completely unique. ICANN's dispute