Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-18 Thread Christopher.Fouts
Ok, I deleted a CVS tag using > cvs rtag -d proj Now, when I do a check out with the tag, I get > cvs co -r proj cvs checkout: Updating proj/file1 cvs checkout: Updating proj/file2 cvs checkout: Updating proj/file3 .. I expected

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-18 Thread Jim.Hyslop
Christopher Fouts wrote: > What am I missing? CVSROOT/val-tags Tags never get removed from val-tags. The "no such tag" message will appear only if the tag does not appear in val-tags. If the tag appears in val-tags, then CVS has to search each file in each directory to determine which files may or

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Christopher.Fouts
>-Original Message- >From: Jim.Hyslop [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Tuesday, January 18, 2005 4:25 PM >To: Fouts Christopher (IFNA MP DC); info-cvs@gnu.org >Subject: RE: Question re: deleted tags > > >Christopher Fouts wrote: >> What am I missing? >C

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Christopher.Fouts
>-Original Message- >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >] On Behalf Of Fouts Christopher (IFNA MP DC) >Sent: Wednesday, January 19, 2005 8:46 AM >To: info-cvs@gnu.org >Subject: RE: Question re: deleted tags > > > > >>-Original

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Derek Price
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: "Tags never get removed from val-tags." Why? If I delete a tag, I I want to, well, delete it! Only because it would be a lot of overhead to traverse the entire repository to make sure that _ALL_ files are really missing the tag. In other words, just because you execute

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Larry Jones
Derek Price writes: > > Since tag deletion is considered a relatively rare operation (as well it > should be), no one has ever bother to write the code for the expensive, > complete tag search that would be necessary to determine if the tag is > really completely gone and should really be delet

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Derek Price
Larry Jones wrote: Derek Price writes: Since tag deletion is considered a relatively rare operation (as well it should be), no one has ever bother to write the code for the expensive, complete tag search that would be necessary to determine if the tag is really completely gone and should real

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-19 Thread Larry Jones
Derek Price writes: > > Well, "fixing" it this way would put us back in the position where > checkouts and updates could sometimes report that tags don't exist when > they do. I think this is worse than not checking out any data when the > tag doesn't exist in the project or sub-project being

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-20 Thread Derek Price
Larry Jones wrote: Derek Price writes: Well, "fixing" it this way would put us back in the position where checkouts and updates could sometimes report that tags don't exist when they do. I think this is worse than not checking out any data when the tag doesn't exist in the project or sub-pro

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-20 Thread Christopher.Fouts
Jones [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Wednesday, January 19, 2005 5:56 PM >To: Derek Price >Cc: Fouts Christopher (IFNA MP DC); info-cvs@gnu.org >Subject: Re: Question re: deleted tags > > >Derek Price writes: >> >> Since tag deletion is considered a relatively rare oper

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-20 Thread Rick Genter
- >From: Larry Jones [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Wednesday, January 19, 2005 5:56 PM >To: Derek Price >Cc: Fouts Christopher (IFNA MP DC); info-cvs@gnu.org >Subject: Re: Question re: deleted tags > > >Derek Price writes: >> >> Since tag deletion is con

RE: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-20 Thread Christopher.Fouts
>-Original Message- >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On >Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Thursday, January 20, 2005 11:04 AM >To: info-cvs@gnu.org >Subject: RE: Question re: deleted tags > >I understand WHY now. Since val-tags is just a c

Re: Question re: deleted tags

2005-01-20 Thread Larry Jones
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > > I understand WHY now. Since val-tags is just a cache, > where is the "real" tags repository. The individual RCS files in the repository. -Larry Jones I thought my life would seem more interesting with a musical score and a laugh track. -- Calvin _