[Wiki-research-l] Grant Proposal: Request for Feedback

2015-04-12 Thread Christina Shane-Simpson
Hello Fellow Wiki Researchers, I’ve recently posted a project proposal under the Inspire Campaign and would love feedback from this community on the research proposal, Characterization of Editors on Wikipedia: In order to accurately explore the main goals of the Inspire Campaign, we must be

Re: [Wiki-research-l] Grant Proposal: Request for Feedback

2015-04-12 Thread aaron shaw
Greeting Christina! Thanks for sharing this and notifying us on the list. Overall, I am very supportive of additional attempts to do more rigorous survey research on Wikipedians. Some questions that I think you could try to address in the proposal: - *Sampling*: You mention that you plan to

Re: [Wiki-research-l] Grant Proposal: Request for Feedback (Response to Aaron Shaw)

2015-04-12 Thread Christina Shane-Simpson
Hello Aaron and Other Wiki Researchers, Thank you for responding so quickly and thoroughly to my recent proposal! Many of your concerns align with issues I’ve been discussing with my research team, so I’m glad to hear that we’re overlapping in that sense. Apologies in advance for the length

Re: [Wiki-research-l] Grant Proposal: Request for Feedback (Response to Aaron Shaw)

2015-04-12 Thread WereSpielChequers
Dear Christina, 1 are you defining your super editors by total or recent edits? Whilst we have pretty good editor retention amongst high edit count editors, even amongst those with over a 100,000 edits there are inactive and semi active editors. 2 how are you going to ensure that talkpage

Re: [Wiki-research-l] Grant Proposal: Request for Feedback (Response to Aaron Shaw)

2015-04-12 Thread Pine W
I'm just wondering if this survey could be combined with an upcoming WMF survey, and combined with the survey I proposed regarding female editors on projects other than English Wikipedia. Pinging Tilman and Jaime to ask for their comments about those suggestions. Thanks, Pine On Apr 12, 2015