DIS: Proto: Beads and Wins

2007-05-07 Thread Ed Murphy

Proto-Proposal:  Beads and Wins

Rename Rule 2126 (Voting Credits) to Beads, change its Power to 2,
and amend it to read:

  Beads are property, but cannot be traded.

  The Jewelor is an office.  The Jewelor's report shall include
  each player's beads.

Create a rule titled Earning Beads with Power 2 and this text:

  Players may only earn beads as follows:

1) 2 beads for authoring an ordinary proposal that is adopted.
2) 1 bead for co-authoring an ordinary proposal that is adopted.
3) 1 bead for holding an office for the majority of a quarter.
4) 1 bead for judging a CFJ during the Deliberation Period.
5) Up to 5 beads per month as specified by contests.

Create a rule titled Forfeiting Beads with Power 2 and this text:

  Players may only forfeit beads as follows:

1) All beads when one or more players win the game.
2) 1 bead for having one's judgement overturned.

Create a rule titled Spending Beads with Power 2 and this text:

  Players may only spend beads as follows:

1) 2 beads to increase eir voting limit on ordinary proposals
 by one.
2) 1 bead to increase another player's voting limit on ordinary
 proposals by one.
3) 2 beads to decrease another player's voting limit on ordinary
 proposals by one, to a minimum of zero.
4) 2 beads to increase a proposal's adoption index by 0.1.
5) 2 beads to ban a player from judging a CFJ to which e is not
 already assigned.

Amend Rule 2137 (The Assessor) by replacing this text:

  The Assessor's report shall include the following:

  a) Each player's voting limit on ordinary proposals.
  b) Each player's voting credits.

with this text:

  The Assessor's report shall include each player's voting limit on
  ordinary proposals.

Create a rule titled Win by Beads with this text:

  A player with 42 or more beads is eligible to win.

Amend Rule 2134 (Win by Voting Power) to read:

  A player satisfies a win condition if eir voting power on ordinary
  proposals is greater than or equal to the total voting power on
  ordinary proposals of all other players.

Amend Rule 1922 (Defined Regular Patent Titles) by removing the first
instance of this text:

  (d)  Champion, to be awarded to players who win the game.

Repeal Rule 2128 (Winning).

Amend Rule 2136 (Contests) by replacing this text:

  A contest is a contract that identifies itself as such, and
  identifies exactly one party as its contestmaster; all other
  parties are its contestants.

Create a rule titled Win Conditions with this text:

  When one or more players satisfy at least one win condition, and
  this is correctly announced with a list of all such players, then
  those players win the game.


Re: DIS: Proto: Beads and Wins

2007-05-07 Thread Zefram
Ed Murphy wrote:
Create a rule titled Earning Beads with Power 2 and this text:

Needs updating due to P4943.  So does Forfeiting Beads.

4) 2 beads to increase a proposal's adoption index by 0.1.

I'm dubious about letting this influence Democratic proposals.

5) 2 beads to ban a player from judging a CFJ to which e is not
 already assigned.

Does banning make em ineligible for assignment, or only oblige em to
not return a judgement?

  A player with 42 or more beads is eligible to win.

Should be Having 42 or more beads is a win condition., to match the
format of the Win Conditions rule.

Amend Rule 2136 (Contests) by replacing this text:

Replacing it with what?

-zefram


Re: DIS: Proto: Beads and Wins

2007-05-07 Thread Ed Murphy

Zefram wrote:


   5) 2 beads to ban a player from judging a CFJ to which e is not
already assigned.


Does banning make em ineligible for assignment, or only oblige em to
not return a judgement?


This should be bar (R897) rather than ban.


 A player with 42 or more beads is eligible to win.


Should be Having 42 or more beads is a win condition., to match the
format of the Win Conditions rule.


Yes, this was a missed edit.


Amend Rule 2136 (Contests) by replacing this text:


Replacing it with what?


Should have been Amend Rule 2136 (Contests) to read:.  (The rest of
the rule talked about points, which get rolled into beads.)