On Tue, Jul 19, 2022 at 2:49 AM ais523 via agora-business < agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote:
> On Tue, 2022-07-19 at 02:46 -0500, secretsnail9 via agora-business > wrote: > > I do not create the following thing, which may be a proposal: > > > > { > > Title: What is this > > Adoption index: 1.0 > > Author: secretsnail > > Co-author(s): > > > > If this is a proposal, each player that has a valid vote FOR its > > adoption is granted 5 boatloads of coins. > > > > } > > > > If there is a proposal in this message, I create it. > > > > CFJ, barring ais523: I created a proposal in this message. > > > > Arguments: > > > > I think the "thing" up there isn't a proposal, but instead just a > > list of attributes, but a recent CFJ makes me doubt this so I just > > wanna see what happens > > Arguments: Creating a proposal is an action by announcement, meaning > that you can't do it by stating that you aren't doing it. (This was > different under some previous rulesets, IIRC; there are historical > examples of proposals being created by mistake, but that can't happen > under the current rules.) > > -- > ais523 > > Just to be clear, I'm thinking the part that might have created a proposal was "If there is a proposal in this message, I create it.", not the first part of the message. The real question that needs to be answered by the CFJ is what "If there is a proposal in this message" evaluates to. I think it would be false that a proposal was in the message, since it was just the attributes, but maybe the conditional doesn't care about that and works off something else. -- secretsnail