OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report
Herald’s Weekly report Date of Last Report: 04 Nov 2018 Date of This Report: 16 Nov 2018 KarmaEntity (np=not player) - +7 twg <= SHOGUN -ABOVE HERE BE THE SAMURAI +3 D. Margaux +2 Corona +1 Trigon +1 ATMunn +1 Aris +1 Sky Fox -1 Kenyon (np) -1 Telnaior (zombie) -2 G. -2 Ouri (np) -2 CuddleBeam -2 Gaelan -3 Murphy -3 V.J. Rada -BELOW HERE BE THE GAMMAS <= HONOURLESS WORM - All other entities have 0 Karma (0's included on the list indicate an honour change since the last report). Notations of player/not-player and zombie status above are not complete switch reports, so are not self-ratifying. Notices of Honour: [New Week 12-Nov] twg (11 Nov 2018) -1 G. (not having properly judged CFJ 3681 yet) +1 Sky Fox (being an obedient zombie) [New Week 05-Nov] ATMunn (04 Nov 2018) -1 twg (rebalancing) +1 VJ Rada (rebalancing) [Time of Last Report] Trigon (01 Nov 2018) -1 G. for acting recklessly and not considering eir actions' effects +1 Gaelan because why is e at -3 when e hasn't even been here for months? G. (31 Oct 2018) +1 twg (for reminding us about violet ribbons) -1 Trigon (for only awarding a violet ribbon to emself) [New Week 29-Oct] [New Week 22-Oct] D. Margaux (20 Oct 2018) twg +1 (Doomsday Clock was a very clever way to blow up the land minigame) Murphy -1 (impeding the due course of justice by leaving Arbitor stuff undone) [New Week 15-Oct] [New Week 08-Oct] D. Margaux (07 Oct 2018) +1 Aris for giving careful consideration to arguments -1 D Margaux for persisting in advocating perhaps a tenuous interpretation of the rules Gaelan via Master G. INVALID, NOT FIRST IN WEEK -1 twg (for making someone a zombie who was clearly returning) +1 ATMunn (welcome back! twg (03 Oct 2018) +1 D. Margaux (managing to sneak this one past me) -1 Kenyon (arbitrarily selected zombie) Gaelan via Master G. (01 Oct 2018) +1 CuddleBeam (for taking the burden G.'s RL bank balance). -1 Ouri (more karma decay for zombies) D. Margaux (02 Oct 2018) +1 CuddleBeam for an ingenious pledge -1 D Margaux because eir karma is too high G. (01 Oct 2018) +1 twg (for this great addition to the assessor's results) -1 Ouri (zombies close to deregistration mean nonzero karma balance in Agora eventually). [New Week] twg (30 Sep 2018) +1 D. Margaux (fulfilling agreed obligation) -1 Telnaior (arbitrarily selected zombie) Aris (24 Sep 2018) -1 G. (unclear communication) +1 omd (serving as our Distributor) Gaelan, via master G. (24 Sep 2018) -1 Aris (because Gaelan may or may not feel like it). +1 V.J. (or VJ) Rada, because eir name is confusing enough to be listed in two different ways within the Registrar's Report, and I like that. G. (24 Sep 2018) -1 Aris (because really, I feel like it). +1 CuddleBeam (because I'm tired of seeing that name at the bottom). [New Week] Trigon (23 Sep 2018) -1 to D. Margaux for being a manipulator +1 to D Margaux for helping debug zombie rules Aris (23 Sep 2018) -1 G. (complaining about proposals being readded while resisting any attempt to lower quorum or otherwise resolve the problem of them failing quorum) +1 D Margaux (helping fix problems by debugging the proposals) Telnaior, via master Aris (23 Sep 2018) -1 D Margaux (manipulating zombies to gain honor) +1 nichdel (being mainipulated) D. Margaux (23 Sep 2018) -1 nichdel (having the misfortune of being D. Margaux’s zombie) +1 D Margaux (for revealing what might be yet another zombie exploit) G. (23 Sep 2018) -1 Aris (for persisting with group of low-quorum proposals). +1 D. Margaux (for finding bugs after several votings). [New Week] D. Margaux (15 Sep 2018) -1 D. Margaux (misnaming G.) +1 G. (being gracious about that misnaming) [New Week] G. (9 Sep 2018) -1 Trigon (being generally MIA on land) +1 D. Margaux (keeping up officer report standards via SJ) [New Week] [New Week] G. 29 Aug 2018 -1 G (not reading proposals carefully) +1 D. Margaux (reading carefully and researching back beyond eir tenure) twg 26 Aug 2018 [attempted to issue a Notice of Honour, but failed because it was eir second that week] twg (20 Aug 2018) -1 Corona (violating rule 2201, which e cannot be fined for because it occurred >14 days ago). +1 Trigon (twg believed that Trigon did not have a zombie at the time of the last proposal distribution; Trigon attempted to point this out, but e didn't listen properly). [New Week] [New Week] [New Week] Trigon (4 Aug 18) +1 twg (being a good, friendly Agoran) -1 Trigon (needlessly calling twg cruel and being initially ungrateful) twg (4 Aug 18) -1 twg (being nitpicky) +1 Trigon (being patient with the nitpicks) [New Week] [New Week] G. (19 Jul 18) -1 G. for fleeing from office leaving unresolved CoEs. +1 twg for fixing. [New Week] G. (9 Jul 18) -1 Trigon (for not tracking land stuff) +1 twg (for tracking la
OFF: [Arbitor] Court Gazette
COURT GAZETTE (Arbitor's weekly report) Disclaimer: Informational only. No actions are contained in this report. Information in this report is not self-ratifying. May contain inadvertent errors due to newbie arbitor learning the ropes. Open cases (CFJs) - 3674 called by twg 15 October 2018, assigned to Aris 20 October 2018, re-assigned to Aris 11 November 2018: "In the quoted message, G. objected to at least one intent to perform a dependent action." 3687 called by Gaelan 5 November 2018, assigned to Murphy 10 November 2018: "There are two Shoguns." 3688 called by D. Margaux 11 November 2018, assigned to G. 11 November 2018: "D. Margaux’s attempt to assign a judgement to CFJ 3672 was EFFECTIVE." 3689 called by D. Margaux 12 November 2018, assigned to Murphy 14 November 2018: "D. Margaux’s attempt on 11 November 2018 to delete language from the Living Zombie contract was EFFECTIVE." Highest numbered case: 3689 Context/arguments/evidence are included at the bottom of this report. Recently-delivered verdicts and implications 3682 (formerly CFJ 3678), called by twg 31 October 2018, judged FALSE by Murphy 4 November 2018: "Gaelan transferred a coin to me today." Day Court Judge Recent -- D. Margaux 3675, 3668, 3669, 3652, 3672, 3685, 3686 [10/02 10/20 10/20 10/27 10/29 11/2 11/2] G. 3667, 3679, 3680, 3681, 3688 [10/20 11/2 11/2 10/29 11/11] Murphy 3652, 3676, 3682, 3678, 3687, 3689 [10/20 10/21 11/1 11/4 11/10 11/14] Trigon 3670, 3671, 3673, 3683, 3684 [10/20 10/20 10/20 11/1 11/1] Weekend Court Judge Recent (generally gets half as many cases) -- ATMunn 3665, 3666 [10/20 10/20] (These are informal designations. Requests to join/leave a given court will be noted. Individual requests to be assigned a specific case will generally be honored, even for non-court judges.) Context/arguments/evidence -- *** 3674 context: -- Forwarded message - From: Timon Walshe-Grey Date: Mon, Oct 15, 2018 at 8:18 PM Subject: Re: BUS: Re: OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposals 8105-8110 To: agora-busin...@agoranomic.org CFJ, barring G.: "In the quoted message, G. objected to at least one intent to perform a dependent action." Caller's arguments: According to the judgement issued by Maud in CFJ 1460, an action is only effective if "unreasonably excessive effort" is not required to determine what the action is. To determine exactly what actions G. took here, one would need to carefully read each of the messages sent to the public fora in the last 14 days, forming a list of the intents to perform dependent actions in those messages (including any and all inconspicuous or obfuscated such intents), and evaluate which of those meet the criteria listed in G.'s message. I believe this is "unreasonably excessive". -twg --- Original Message --- On Monday, October 15, 2018 11:43 PM, Kerim Aydin wrote: > > > On Mon, 15 Oct 2018, Timon Walshe-Grey wrote: > > > I vote AGAINST proposals 8105 and 8107. > > I vote FOR proposals 8106, 8108, 8109 and 8110. > > hmmm on 8107 vote there. > > I object to all intents to perform actions without N objections > (for all values of N) that have been announced by people other > than myself in the last 14 days. > > (I don't think this catches anything legit, but if so lmk and > I'll remove my objection). *** 3682 (formerly CFJ 3678) judge Murphy's judgement: D. Margaux wrote: > Fair enough. This is CFJ 3678. I assign it to Murphy. >>> On Sat, Oct 27, 2018 at 8:22 PM Gaelan Steele wrote: >>> I CFJ “By sending a message at 3:35 PM Pacific on October 27, G. >>> performed one or more regulated actions.” > ‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐ > On Saturday, October 27, 2018 10:32 PM, Kerim Aydin < ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote: > >> Interpreting the somewhat informal date/time spec as "on or about 3:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time (-0700) on October 27, 2018" (presumably caller's intent, and if not then e can submit another): The only public message from G. that meets this spec is the one quoted by the caller (archive link in evidence). To the best of my knowledge, it was genuinely an empty message (unregulated), and neither that message nor any non-public message e may have sent around the same time triggered any non-obvious recordkeeping duties or the like. As usual, if evidence to the contrary later emerges (e.g. a relevant encrypted contract is revealed), then this judgement should be appealed accordingly. FALSE. Evidence: https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2018-October/039429.html ***
