OFF: [Treasuror] Targeting the Buoys 378

[secretsnail9 via agora-official]

I flip the Buoyancy Target to the total number of coins given in the
Treasuror's report of 30 Oct 2022, that number being:

Buoyancy Target: 92281
--
snail

OFF: [Treasuror] [Weekly Report] Forbes 378

[secretsnail9 via agora-official]

   FORBES THREE HUNDRED SEVENTY-EIGHT
   or   
   TREASUROR'S WEEKLY REPORT



Reports available online at: 

DATES OF PUBLICATION  (contains no data)


(all times and dates in UTC)

Date of previous original report: 23 Oct 2022
Date of first report this week:   30 Oct 2022


NOTES ON REPORT   (contains no data)


* Find my report drafts on Discord or IRC.
* As always, please check the general accuracy of this report.


BUOYANCY


Total Buoyancy:72326
Buoyancy Target:   89671
Unit of Flotation: 29.


ASSET BALANCES


   Player(+a)  cn
 ==  ==
 Aced   [0] 290
 ais[1]1641
 Astra  [2] 290
 banana [3]1866
 Capn   [4] 700
 G.2546
 Gaelan1925
 Jason24797
 juan  1813
 Murphy4504
 nix   1450
 orb290
 owl[5] 290
 Pilgore838
 R. Lee2009
 snail19401
 Vitor  700
 ziproot   1850

0. Aced7
1. ais523
2. Astrally Forged
3. cuddlybanana
4. Cap'n
5. shy owl

   Player(-a)  cn
 ==  ==
 Create [0] 559
 duck   741
 omd603
 Trigon3959

0. CreateSource

  Contract(00) cn
 ==  ==
 AspenX [0]1030
 ATMStash   [1]1703
 D. Corp.   [2] 315
 G.ravity 9
 Hoard  [3] 491
 IBTWWBG[4]   5
 Lever  [5]   0
 Nim  5
 PlunderPS  [6]  10
 SEAMSTRESS [7]  24
 SPRINT [8]   0

0. Aspen's Executor
1. ATMunn's Stash
2. Dragon Corporation
3. Dragon's Hoard
4. I Bet This Was Written By G.
5. The Useless Lever
6. Plunder Partnership
7. Signature Enthusiast Allows Modification of Signature Through
   Rigorous Exchanging of Signature Suggestions
8. Scissors Paper Rock in Nomic Tournament

  Contract(25) cn
 ==  ==
 Press  [0]1204

0. Agoran Press

 Entitycn
 ==  ==
 Agora0
 L Dept.14423


ASSET INDEX   (does not self-ratify)


* Tracked by the Treasuror (this report)
* Coins (cn)

* Tracked by the Referee
* Blots

* Tracked by the Notary
* Promises

* Tracked by the Stonemason
* Stones

* Tracked by the Collector
* Stamps, one class for each person.

* Tracked by the Horsened
* Horses
* Dollaries
* Hooves


RECENT HISTORY


*** Sun 30 October 2022
[20:00] snail:  +145cn (Reward: Dreamor monthly)
[20:00] Jason:  +435cn (Reward: Assessed proposal)
[20:00] nix:+290cn (Reward: Herald weekly)
[20:00] nix:+145cn (Reward: Collector weekly)
[20:00] G.: +290cn (Reward: Arbitor weekly)
[20:00] juan:   +145cn (Reward: Registrar weekly)
[20:00] snail:  +435cn (Reward: Treasuror weekly)
[20:00] snail:  +290cn (Reward: Notary weekly)
[20:00] Murphy: +145cn (Reward: ADoP weekly)
[13:19] Murphy: +145cn (CFJ 4000)
[13:19] ais:+145cn (CFJ 3999)

*** Sun 23 October 2022
[23:58]   Buoyancy target set to 89671
[23:48]   WEEKLY REPORT
[20:40] nix: +290cn (Reward: Herald monthly)
[20:40] ziproot: +290cn (Reward: Referee weekly)
[20:40] snail:   +435cn (Reward: Proposal Pool)
[20:40] nix: +145cn (Reward: Collector weekly)
[20:40] G.:  +290cn (Reward: Arbitor weekly)
[20:40] nix: +290cn (Reward: Herald weekly)
[20:40] juan:+145cn (Reward: Registrar weekly)
[20:40] Jason:   +145cn (Reward: Stonemason weekly)
[20:40] Jason:   +435cn (Reward: Short Logical Ruleset)
[20:40] Jason:   +145cn (Reward: Mad Engineer weekly)
[20:40] snail:   +145cn (Reward: Horsened weekly)
[20:40] snail:   +290cn (Reward: Notary weekly)
[20:40] Murphy:  +145cn (Reward: ADoP weekly)

*** Wed 19 October 2022
[17:55] Aced: +290cn (Welcome Package)

*** Mon 17 October 2022
[11:45] Astra: +290cn (Welcome Package)
[03:00] snail: -122cn (Recursion Stone Auction)
[03:00] snail: -122cn (Jockey Stone Auction)

*** Sun 16 October 2022
[21:58] Jason:   +435cn (Reward: Assessed proposal)
[21:58] snail:   +435cn (Reward: Proposal Pool)
[21:58] G.:  +290cn (Reward: Arbitor weekly)
[21:58] snail:   +435cn (Reward: Treasuror weekly)
[21:58] ziproot: +290cn (Reward: 

OFF: [Horsened] The Horses Rundown (30 Oct 2022)

[secretsnail9 via agora-official]

The Horsened's Weekly Report
The Horses Rundown
30 Oct 2022

DOLLARIES AND HOOVES (self-ratifies)
==
Entity DollariesHooves
   ---
ais523  44 9
cuddlybanana 0 9
G.   0 9
Gaelan   4 9
Jason   40 9
juan12 9
Murphy   3 8
R. Lee   0 9
snail0 8
Vitor0 9
Pilgore  4 8
Cap'n0 8
ziproot  8 5
orb  0 3
Shy Owl  0 3
nix  0 3
Astra0 2
Aced70 1

CreateSource 0 8
duck 0 8
omd  0 8
Trigon   0 8

Lost & Found Dept.   815


HORSES   (self-ratifies)
==
Horse  OwnerRace Position   Race Place
   --   -   --
Alexia snail3   none
Baxter Agora7   none
Cannon snail7   none
Destructor Agora3   none
Fargo  snail   10   none
Nacho  Agora3   none
Rubert Pilgore  0   none
Sugar  Agora1   none


HORSE PULLS(does not ratify)
==
Horse   Pulls
-   --
Alexia  Nacho
Baxter  Fargo
Cannon  Alexia
Destructor  Baxter
Fargo   Alexia, Destructor
Nacho   Baxter, Cannon
Rubert  Alexia, Cannon
Sugar   Baxter, Destructor, Sugar


HELMETS AND JERSEYS(does not ratify)
==
Player HELMETSJERSEYS
   -  -
Murphy Sugar  Sugar
snail  Fargo  (none)

All players not in the above list have gotten no helmets or jerseys
for a horse since the race last started anew.


BETS, IN DOLLARIES, SINCE RACE STARTED ANEW(does not ratify)
==
Murphy: 2 on Fargo, 3 on Destructor, 4 on Rubert
snail: 2 on Fargo


RECENT HISTORY (does not ratify)
==
D: gained 4 dollaries as a weekly action
H: got a helmet for
J: got a jersey for

29 Oct 2022: Murphy bet 3 dollaries on Rubert
24 Oct 2022: ziproot D
24 Oct 2022: Jason D
24 Oct 2022: ais523 D

Nacho moved forward 1, pulling Baxter and Cannon 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

23 Oct 2022: snail used Cannon's power to move Cannon forward 1
23 Oct 2022: snail used Fargo, H and bet 2 on Fargo (via Alexia)
23 Oct 2022: snail bought Alexia for 10 dollaries
19 Oct 2022: Aced7 registered
17 Oct 2022: Jason D
17 Oct 2022: ais523 D
17 Oct 2022: ziproot D

Baxter moved forward 1, pulling Fargo 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

16 Oct 2022: Murphy J Sugar, adding Sugar to Sugar's pulls.
15 Oct 2022: Astra registered
11 Oct 2022: Jason D
10 Oct 2022: ais523 D
10 Oct 2022: snail bought Fargo for 6 dollaries

Fargo moved forward 3, pulling Alexia and Destructor 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

09 Oct 2022: Murphy H Sugar
09 Oct 2022: nix registered
07 Oct 2022: Shy Owl registered
05 Oct 2022: orb registered
05 Oct 2022: Jason D
03 Oct 2022: ais523 D
03 Oct 2022: secretsnail D

Horses weren't motivated this week.

02 Oct 2022: Murphy bet 1 dollary on Rubert
29 Sep 2022: Jason D
28 Sep 2022: ais523 D

Horses weren't motivated this week.

25 Sep 2022: Murphy bet 3 dollaries on Destructor
20 Sep 2022: Jason D
19 Sep 2022: ais523 D

Fargo moved forward 3, pulling Alexia and Destructor 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

18 Sep 2022: secretsnail D
18 Sep 2022: Jason D
18 Sep 2022: ais523 D

Baxter moved forward 1, pulling Fargo 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

11 Sep 2022: secretsnail used Cannon's power to move Cannon forward 1
11 Sep 2022: secretsnail D
11 Sep 2022: 4st deregistered, Sugar transferred to Agora
10 Sep 2022: Madrid deregistered
06 Sep 2022: Jason D
06 Sep 2022: ais523 D
06 Sep 2022: 4st used Sugar's power on Sugar (helmet and move 1)
06 Sep 2022: Murphy D
05 Sep 2022: juan D

Baxter moved forward 3, pulling Fargo 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

04 Sep 2022: secretsnail D

Nacho moved forward 2, pulling Baxter and Cannon 1.
+1 Hooves to all players.

28 Aug 2022: Murphy bet 2 dollaries on Fargo
28 Aug 2022: Jason D
28 

OFF: [Notary] The Notes (Contracts, Pledges, and Promises) (30 Oct 2022)

[secretsnail9 via agora-official]

   ██   ██ ███   ███   ██  █   ███  ██
 ████   ██ ██  ██ ██   ██████  ██
 █████ █ ██ ██ ██ ██   ██████
 ████   ██ ████   ██   ██████   ██
 ████   ██ ███   ██   ███  █ █████ ██



 -~= Notary's weekly report =~-



 ~~ shreds and pledges oh my ~~

All times and dates in this report are given in Coordinated Universal
Time (UTC).

Date of last report: 23 Oct 2022
Date of this report: 30 Oct 2022


If any contract(s) have no name currently, I assign it/them the name(s)
displayed in this report.


=== SHORT LIST OF CONTRACTS 

Contracts marked with an asterisk (*) are charities.

 Title   Parties
"The Dragon Corporation"Aspen, Jason
"TPP"[1]   Madrid, G., Aspen
"LoAFER"[2]Trigon, Jason, ATMunn
"SEAMSTRESS"[3]Trigon, Jason
"The Platonic Parrot"omd, Madrid
"I bet that was written by G."   omd, ATMunn
* "Agoran Press"   Murphy, Telna, Jason, secretsnail
"The Splat Market"Gaelan
"Humble Agoran Farming"  Madrid, Gaelan, ... [4]
"The Orchard"   Madrid, Jason, Gaelan, Murphy, Lucidiot, ... [5]
"FIAA"[6]Jason, nix, secretsnail
"Boatloans"   Gaelan
"Dragon's Hoard"Telna, Jason
"The Useless Lever"  Shy Owl, secretsnail, Jason
"Nim"secretsnail
"The Duck Fund" duck
"ATMunn's Stash"  ATMunn
"NOTA"[7]nix
"G.ravity"G.
"Vote Proxies"nix, Madrid, Jason
"Private Enforcement" ais523
"Stamp Servitude"secretsnail, Madrid
"Aspen's Executor"  Aspen, Jason
"SPRINT"[8]4st, ais523, secretsnail
"Betrayer's Guild"   4st
"The Agoran Philatelic Society"  shy owl


[1] The Plunder Partnership
[2] League of Agorans Facilitating Effective Recordkeeping
[3] Signature Enthusiast Allows Modification of Signature Through
Rigorous Exchanging of Signature Suggestions
[4] also Aspen, Murphy, Lucidiot, secretsnail
[5] also G., Telna, cuddlybanana, secretsnail
[6] Food Industry Association of Agora
[7] NOTA: A Unique Contract Transferring Interesting Objects Nicely
[8] SPRINT: Scissors Paper Rock In Nomic Tournament




 COMBINED HISTORY OF CONTRACTS =


23 Oct 2022: Jason shredded "Cuddlebeam's Locker"
-- time of last report --
-- 2 reports ago --
09 Oct 2022: shy owl created "The Agoran Philatelic Society"




== FULL TEXT AND HISTORY OF CONTRACTS ==


All contracts which do not have a Donation Level stated currently have a
Donation Level of 0.

The following 26 contracts exist:


"The Dragon Corporation" (revision 4)
Parties: Aspen, Jason

--

## Bylaw 1: Definition

This contract is named "the Dragon Corporation". The purpose of the
Dragon Corporation is to earn as much money as possible for its
shareholders.

All other provisions of this contract notwithstanding, this contract
does not permit any entity to act on behalf of any other entity.

Shares of Dragon stock (also known as "shares of DRGN", or, in this
contract, "shares") are a currency whose purpose is to represent
ownership of the Dragon Corporation. An entity which owns at least 

OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposals 8863-8865

[secretsnail9 via agora-official]

PROMOTOR'S REPORT AS OF RIGHT NOW

If you vote on a proposal, please edit this spreadsheet with your votes:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iR93pLq3uiiDTXI5nb0nQn_M-ySDJ7jhb3tiMw7ec5M/edit?usp=sharing

I hereby distribute each listed proposal, initiating a referendum on it,
and removing it from the proposal pool. For this decision, the vote
collector
is the Assessor, the quorum is 3, the voting method is AI-majority, and the
valid options are FOR and AGAINST (PRESENT is also a valid vote, as are
conditional votes).


ID  Author(s)   AITitle
---
8863~   Jason   2.0   Exiting REM
8864~   ziproot 1.0   Pronoun Correction
8865~   nix, G[1]   2.0   Stone Fixes




[1] nix, G., ais523, Ja-"the cat"-son, ziproot



The proposal pool contains the following proposals:

ID  Author(s)   AITitle
---
Currently empty.



Legend: * : Democratic proposal.
~ : Ordinary proposal.

The full text of the aforementioned proposal(s) is included below. Where
the information shown below differs from the information shown above,
the information shown above shall control.

//
ID: 8863
Title: Exiting REM
Adoption Index: 2.0
Author: Jason
Co-Author(s):


Amend Rule 2675 by replacing with "Eir Voting Strength is 2 greater."
with "Eir voting strength is increased by 2 for referenda on ordinary
proposals."

//
ID: 8864
Title: Pronoun Correction
Adoption Index: 1.0
Author: ziproot
Co-Author(s):

Amend Rule 2672 by replacing "Each player CAN take one of the following
actions (weekly race actions) if they have not already taken one this
week" with "Each player CAN take one of the following actions (weekly
race actions) if e has not already taken one this week"

//
ID: 8865
Title: Stone Fixes
Adoption Index: 2.0
Author: nix
Co-Author(s): G., ais523, Ja-"the cat"-son, ziproot

Amend R2645, The Stones, by

removing the bullet point that includes "Tasty Stone";

and removing the bullet point that includes "Wealth Stone";

and replacing:

 A specified player (defaulting to the wielder if not specified)
 hereby Buys Strength 3 times.

with:

 A specified player (defaulting to the wielder if not specified) is
 Power Stoned; Power Stoning is secured. A player's voting strength
 on a referendum on an ordinary proposal is increased by 3 for each
 time that e was Power Stoned during the referendum's voting period.

and adding, to the end of the rule:

 - Score Stone (Weekly, 3): A specified player's (defaulting to the
   wielder if not specified) Score is increased by 3.

//
--
snail

OFF: [Rulekeepor] ACORN - 30 Oct 2022

[Jason Cobb via agora-official]

THE AGORA NOMIC CODE OF REGULATIONS

These ACORNs are also online at http://agoranomic.org/ruleset/

Date of this ACORN: 30 Oct 2022



Table of Contents:

Auction Regulations
   * Regulation  AM0: Generalized Auction
   * Regulation  AM1: Forward Auctions
   * Regulation  AM2: Sealed-bid Auctions
   * Regulation  AM3: Second-price Auctions
   * Regulation  AM4: Nonwinning-price Auctions
   * Regulation  AM5: Selective-bid Auctions
Administrative Regulations
   * Regulation  PA0: Certification
   * Regulation  PA1: Proposal Style Guide
   * Regulation  RA1: Tardiness
   * Regulation  RA2: Guidelines to Referees for Compiling Weekly Reports
   * Regulation  RA3: Holiday Rule Reminder Practice





Auction Regulations
   This section has the regulations, written by the Treasuror, governing
   how auctions proceed.

Regulation AM0/5
Generalized Auction

  Generalized auctions exist to give context to the form of other
  types of auctions. They CANNOT be held directly. Other auction
  methods that use this type of auction as a starting point can
  override attributes of generalized auctions except when it is
  explicitly stated that that attribute is not able to be
  overridden.
  
  INITIATION: When a person CAN begin an auction by this or any
  derivative method, e CAN only do so by specifying the type of
  auction method to be held, a list of lots to be auctioned off, and
  the currency for the auction in a public message (henceforth the
  "initiation message"). The bidding period starts at this point.
  
  BIDDING: Players CAN place a bid on an auction in its bidding
  period by creating a public message (henceforth a "bid message")
  specifying an amount of that auction's currency. Players CAN
  withdraw from an open auction by announcement.
  
  EXCLUSIVITY: Bids in an auction are grouped into classes of that
  auction. Unless otherwise specified, all bids in a given auction
  are in a single class. A bid CANNOT be made if, in the class it
  would be in, another bid already exists with the bid amount of the
  hypothetical bid.
  
  TERMINATION: The bidding period ends four days after the final
  instance of any of the following events' occurance:
* the auction begins
* a bid is placed
* a player withdraws from the auction
  
  AWARDING: For each auction, there are a number of awardees equal
  to the number of lots. The Nth lot of an auction goes to the Nth
  awardee of that auction. If the identity of an awardee is
  undecidable, then that lot cannot be given away. Auction methods
  specify how awardees are picked for auctions using that method.
  
  PAYMENT AMOUNT: The amount that an awardee in an auction is
  required to pay for eir lot is, unless otherwise specified, the
  amount of the auction's curency specified in eir highest bid on
  that auction.
  
  FUNDED PLAYERS: Derivative auction methods should ensure that only
  players who, at the end of an auction's bidding period, have at
  least as much of that auction's currency as the amount that e is
  required to pay in that auction (hereafter "funded players") can
  be selected as awardees for auctions using that auction method.
  
  DISTRIBUTION: To distribute lots in an auction is to:
* publish a reasonably accurate full history of bids on the
  auction and withdrawals from the auction, and
* for each awardee in that auction, revoke the amount to be paid
  from that awardee and transfer to that player (or grant em if
  the item is new) the set of assets associated with the lot e
  won.
  
  The Auctioneer for an auction CAN, by announcement within fourteen
  days after the bidding period for an auction ends, and SHALL, in a
  timely fashion after that same point, distribute lots. The message
  in which e does so is the "resolution message" for that auction.
  
  ACTIVE BIDS: The set of active bids for an auction is the set of
  all funded, non-withdrawn players' highest bids on that auction.

History:

Enacted by Trigon, 08 Aug 2020
Amended(1) by Trigon, 28 Mar 2021
Amended(2) by Trigon, 05 May 2021
Amended(3) by Trigon, 02 Aug 2021
Amended(4) by Trigon, 30 Aug 2021
Amended(5) by Trigon, 05 Mar 2022

Annotations:


Regulation AM1/1
Forward Auctions

  Forward auctions function like generalized auctions except:
  
  * The Nth awardee for a forward auction is the player who
submitted the 

OFF: [Mad Engineer] Experiment 00058 - Intent to Invent

[Jason Cobb via agora-official]

MAD ENGINEER'S WEEKLY REPORT

The Device is off.


EXPERIMENT 00057 INTENT TO INVENT

I intend, with Agoran consent, to cause Rule 2655 to amend the Rule "The
Device" by appending the following a a list item to the "When the device
is off:" list:

{

  When a device is open and assigned to a judge, that judge CAN assign
  a valid judgement to it by announcement, and SHALL do so in a
  timely fashion after this becomes possible.

}

OFF: [Stonemason] Billboard Rock Chart - 30 Oct 2022

[Jason Cobb via agora-official]

THE BILLBOARD ROCK CHART (STONEMASON'S WEEKLY REPORT)

Stone  OwnerLast Wielded  Immune?
-  ---    ---
Power  Jason2022-10-02
Wealth Agora2022-10-02Agora
Soul   Agora2021-02-14Agora
Sabotage   Agora2022-09-25Agora
Protection G.   2021-10-02
Recursion  snail2022-07-24
Hot Potato Agora2022-09-03Agora
Blank  Trigon
AlchemyAgora2022-03-27Agora
Tasty  Agora2022-08-14Agora
Jockey snail

Summary of stone functions:

Power  a specified player's strength is increased by 3 on a
   specified Agoran decision. Escape risk: 40%.

Wealth a specified player earns 5 boatloads of coins. Escape
   risk: 50%.

Soul   a specified non-immune stone is stolen by the
   wielder, then the Soul Stone is transferred to the
   robbed player. Escape risk: 50%.

Sabotage   the AI of a specified AI-majority decision is
   increased by 1. Escape risk: 80%.

Protection a specified stone becomes immune (until the next
   Collection Notice). Escape risk: 70%.

Recursion  can be wielded as any other stone. Escape risk: 70%.

Hot Potato gain 8 boatloads of coins if transferred to a player who
   has not owned the stone since the last time Agora owned
   it.  Escape risk: immune if wielded 3 or more times since
   the last collection notice, else 100%.

Blank  does nothing. Escape risk: 5%.

Alchemypay four of your own cards to gain 7 products of
   your choice. Escape risk: 70%.

Tasty  transfer a bird to yourself. Escape risk: 70%.

Jockey a specified Running horse's Race Position is increased by
   1. Escape Risk: 60%.

History:
===
2022-10-17 03:00:08  Recursion Stone is transferred to snail from Agora in 
auction resolution.
2022-10-17 03:00:08  Jockey Stone is transferred to snail from Agora in auction 
resolution.
2022-10-05 03:58:08  Protection Stone ceases being immune after collection 
notice.
2022-10-05 03:58:08  Tasty Stone is transferred from Jason to snail per 
collection notice.
2022-10-05 03:58:08  Sabotage Stone is transferred from Jason to Agora per 
collection notice.
2022-10-05 03:58:08  Wealth Stone is transferred from Jason to Agora per 
collection notice.
2022-10-02 23:07:35  G. wields Protection Stone, specifying Protection Stone.
2022-10-02 22:39:35  Jason wields Power Stone, specifying self.
2022-10-02 22:39:35  Jason wields Wealth Stone, specifying self.
2022-09-25 05:56:52  Jason wields the Sabotage Stone, specifying referendum on 
Proposal 8557.
2022-09-25 05:56:52  Jason wields the Wealth Stone, specifying self.
2022-09-25 05:56:52  Jason wields the Power Stone, specifying self.
2022-09-18 18:22:29  Jason wields Wealth Stone, specifying self.
2022-09-11 22:19:33  Jason wields Wealth Stone, specifying self.
2022-09-11 21:54:00  Sabotage Stone is transferred to Jason from Agora in 
auction resolution.
2022-09-11 21:54:00  Wealth Stone is transferred to Jason from Agora in auction 
resolution.
2022-09-03 21:01:34  Protection Stone ceases being immune after collection 
notice.
2022-09-03 21:01:34  Hot Potato Stone is transferred from snail to Agora per 
collection notice.
2022-09-03 21:01:34  Recursion Stone is transferred from Murphy to Agora per 
collection notice.
2022-09-03 08:16:43  Hot Potato Stone is transferred to snail from Agora due to 
Bowerbird.
2022-09-03 08:16:43  snail transfers Hot Potato Stone to juan.
2022-09-03 08:16:43  snail wields Hot Potato Stone.
2022-09-01 00:31:19  G. wields Protection Stone, specifying Protection Stone.
2022-08-31 22:39:35  Jason wields Power Stone, specifying self.
2022-08-30 03:44:33  Jockey Stone created by Proposal 8842.
2022-08-30 03:44:33  Concentration Stone destroyed by Proposal 8842.
2022-08-14 23:07:49  snail wields Tasty Stone, specifying Raven.
2022-08-14 19:41:57  Hot Potato Stone is transferred to snail from Agora in 
auction resolution.
2022-08-14 19:41:57  Tasty Stone is transferred to snail from Agora in auction 
resolution.
2022-08-07 20:02:46  Recursion Stone ceases being immune after collection 
notice.
2022-08-07 20:02:46  Protection Stone ceases being immune after collection 
notice.
2022-08-07 20:02:46  Sabotage Stone is transferred from Murphy to Agora per 
collection notice.
2022-08-01 01;11:33  G. wields Protection Stone, specifying Protection Stone.
2022-07-31 20:54:55  Jason wields Power Stone, specifying self.
2022-07-24 21:28:57  Murphy wields Recursion Stone, specifying Power Stone, 
specifying Recursion Stone.
2022-07-19 03:19:30  Sabotage Stone is transferred to Murphy from Agora in 
auction resolution.
2022-07-19 03:19:30  Recursion Stone is transferred to Murphy from Agora in 

OFF: [ADoP] Metareport

[Edward Murphy via agora-official]

=Metareport=
You can find an up-to-date version of this report at 
http://zenith.homelinux.net/adop/report.php


Date of last report: 2022-10-23
Date of this report: 2022-10-30


MISCELLANEOUS INFO


Filled offices: 18/20 (90.00%)
Total officers: 7
Consolidation[1]: 2.57
Late reports: 1/16 (6.25%)

[1] This is the number of filled offices divided by the number of
officers. At 1, this means that all offices are filled by different
players; if it reached the number of filled offices, that would mean
that all offices are filled by one player.


OFFICES

Office   Holder[1]Since Last Election Complexity

ADoP Murphy   2020-07-032022-10-091
Arbitor *G.   2022-10-092022-05-162
Assessor Jason2019-07-092022-07-243
Collector   *nix  2022-10-23(never)   1
Distributor  omd  2018-06-15(never)[3]0
Dreamor  snail2022-08-14(never)   1
Herald  *nix  2022-10-172022-07-242
Horsened snail2022-08-14(never)   1
Mad Engineer Jason2022-06-172022-06-261
Notary   snail2022-03-142022-05-082
Prime Minister ~ Murphy   2022-06-122022-07-310
Promotor snail2022-05-012022-05-083
Referee *(vacant) 2022-09-11[2] (ongoing) 2
Registrarjuan 2022-08-292022-10-021
Rulekeepor   Jason2019-12-062022-10-093
Speaker  G.   2022-07-172019-11-05 [3]0
Stonemason   Jason2020-11-11(never)   1
Tailor   Murphy   2021-02-282022-10-091
Treasurorsnail2022-06-202022-07-033
Webmastor   *(vacant) 2022-08-29[2] 2022-08-141

[1] * = Interim office (vacant or holder not elected)
~ = Term limited (held for 180+ days, 90+ for Prime Minister)
[2] Vacant since this date
[3] Currently imposed


WEEKLY REPORTS

Office   ReportLast Published Late[1]

ADoP Offices   2022-10-23[2]
Arbitor  Judicial matters  2022-10-30
CollectorStamps2022-10-30
Herald   Scores2022-10-30
Horsened Horses2022-10-23
Mad Engineer The Device2022-10-23
Notary   Contracts 2022-10-23
Promotor Proposal pool 2022-10-23
Referee  Rule violations   2022-10-23 (vacant)
RegistrarPlayers, Fora 2022-10-24
Rulekeepor   Short Logical Ruleset 2022-10-23
Stonemason   Stones2022-10-23
TreasurorCoins, other currencies   2022-10-23

[1] ! = 1 period missed, !! = 2, !!! = 3+
  (does not take succumbing into account)
[2] Not including this report

MONTHLY REPORTS

Office   ReportLast Published Late

Dreamor  Dreams2022-10-24
Herald   Patent titles 2022-10-17
RegistrarPlayer history2022-10-03
Rulekeepor   Full Logical Ruleset  2022-10-01
Tailor   Ribbons, Laudability  2022-10-02
WebmastorWeb resources 2022-04-30 (vacant)



ELECTIONS

Office   Initiated   Phase   Candidates

Referee  2022-10-29  Nominating  (none)


UPCOMING ELECTIONS[1]

Office   Days Until  Last Election

Notary   00 Days 2022-05-08
Promotor 00 Days 2022-05-08
Arbitor  00 Days 2022-05-16
Mad Engineer 00 Days 2022-06-26
Treasuror00 Days 2022-07-03

[1] Anyone can start an election (with 2 support and also becoming a
candidate) 90 days after the previous one (or if it's interim and no
election is 

OFF: [ADoP] Floating salaries (attn Treasuror)

[Edward Murphy via agora-official]

I grant boatloads of coins to players as follows:

(weekly)

 5 BoC - Sun, Oct 23 2022 (20:41:23) - Murphy published the ADoP's 
weekly report
10 BoC - Sun, Oct 23 2022 (21:13:11) - snail published the Notary's 
weekly report
15 BoC - Sun, Oct 23 2022 (23:47:49) - snail published the Treasuror's 
weekly report
 5 BoC - Mon, Oct 24 2022 (12:30:45) - juan published the Registrar's 
weekly report
10 BoC - Sun, Oct 30 2022 (13:19:32) - G. published the Arbitor's weekly 
report
 5 BoC - Sun, Oct 30 2022 (18:09:23) - nix published the Collector's 
weekly report
10 BoC - Sun, Oct 30 2022 (18:26:34) - nix published the Herald's weekly 
report


15 BoC - Sun, Oct 23 2022 (23:27:46) - Jason assessed Proposal 8860

(monthly)

 5 BoC - Mon, Oct 24 2022 (00:53:17) - snail published the Dreamor's 
monthly report



(The following is unofficial. If the Treasuror's report disagrees, then
the Treasuror's report is probably correct.)

The Unit of Flotation is currently 29, thus these expand to:
  *  5 boatloads of coins -> 145 coins
  * 10 boatloads of coins -> 290 coins
  * 15 boatloads of coins -> 435 coins

OFF: [Herald] HIGH SCORES (Herald's Weekly [Pt. 2/2] 30 Oct 2022)

[nix via agora-official]

Scores (points) as of 30 Oct 2022.

PLACE  NAME [0]  SCORE  CHANGE [1]
-    -  --
1stJSN   028
2ndG.012
2ndSNL   012
4thMUR   009
5thCRS   005
5thRLE   005
5thTRI   005
5thVTR   005
5thCBN   005
5thDCK   005
5thJWN   005
12thAIS   003
13thGLN   002
14thASP   001


All other scores are zero.

[0] Aspen = ASP; CreateSource = CRS; G. = G. ; Gaelan = GLN; Jason =
JSN; Murphy = MUR; R. Lee = RLE; Trigon = TRI; Vitor Gonçalves = VTR;
ais523 = AIS; cuddlybanana = CBN; duck = DCK; juan = JWN; snail = SNL

[1] Since last official report.

If you'd like to change your three letter name, please let the Herald
know.

Events Since Last Report



--
nix
Herald, Collector

OFF: [Herald] HONOR (Herald's Weekly, Pt 1 30 Oct 2022)

[nix via agora-official]

30 Oct 2022

These are the current non-zero Karma values:

   1 Jason
   1 Agora
- 1 nix
- 1 4st

A player CAN publish a Notice of Honour. For a Notice of Honour to be
valid, it must:

 1. Be clear that it is a Notice of Honour, and be the first valid
Notice of Honour that player has published in the current week;

 2. Specify any other active player or Agora to gain karma, and
provide a reason for specifying that player; and

 3. Specify any active player or Agora to lose karma, and provide a
reason for specifying that player.

 4. Not result in Agora's karma moving farther away from 0.

History
---
30 Oct 22
 nix:
 +1 Jason (maintaining much of the game, including the currently
   largely-neglected device)
 -1 nix (not updating Karma last week)
01 Oct 22 [Beginning of Quarter 3]
 All players' karma halved, rounded towards 0.
 Agora's karma set to 0 minus the total karma of all players [1]
22 Aug 22
 juan:
 +1 nix (e proposed the creation of the rule)
 -1 4st (e tried to be naughty and gain many points)
28 Aug 22
 nix:
 +1 juan (using a notice already)
 -1 4st (making so many stamps)
01 Sep 22
 Murphy:
 +1 snail (for reminding me to award points for ribbons)
 -1 Murphy (for needing to be reminded)

--
nix
Herald, Collector

OFF: Fwd: [Arbitor] Court Gazette

[Kerim Aydin via agora-official]

Agoran Court Gazette (Arbitor's Weekly Report)
Sun 30 Oct 2022


DEADLINES (details below)
---
[none]


INTERESTED JUDGES AND THEIR MOST RECENT CASE
---
3995 G.
3997 snail
3998 Jason
3999 ais523
4000 Murphy

OPEN CASES
---
[none]


RECENTLY-JUDGED CASES
---
4000 Judged FALSE by Murphy [Sun 23 Oct 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?4000
 It is round 2,098.

3999 Judged TRUE by ais523 [Tue 25 Oct 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3999
 Rule 2139 does not define the contents of the Registrar's monthly
 report to contain all dates such that a person has registered or
 deregistered.

3998 Judged DISMISS by Jason [Sat 15 Oct 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3998
 In a message timestamped Tue Oct 11 23:12:43 UTC 2022 entitled
 "Exhibit A", Shy Owl attempted to perform at least 1 game action.

3997 Judged FALSE by snail [Sun 09 Oct 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3997
 Jason's wielding of the Power Stone on or about 25 Sep 2022
 increased eir voting strength on the Registrar election in
 progress at that time.

3996 Judged FALSE by snail [Sun 09 Oct 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3996
 Jason's wielding of the Power Stone on or about 25 Sep 2022
 increased eir voting strength on at least one decision.

3995 Judged FALSE by G. [Thu 29 Sep 2022]
 https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3995
 Within the past 24 hours, Murphy won the game.

OFF: [CotC] CFJ 4000 Judged FALSE by Murphy

[Kerim Aydin via agora-official]

status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#4000
(This document is informational only and contains no game actions).

===  CFJ 4000  ===

  It is round 2,098.

==

Caller:nix

Judge: Murphy
Judgement: FALSE

==

History:

Called by nix:20 Oct 2022 17:20:44
Assigned to Murphy:   20 Oct 2022 18:37:10
Judged FALSE by Murphy:   23 Oct 2022 20:32:13

==

Caller's Arguments:

Rounds are defined in R1023 alongside pivots:

  A pivot is either the instant at which Agora Nomic began
   (June 30, 1993, 00:04:30 GMT +1200) or an instant at which
   at least one person won the game. When used as a period of
   time, a "Round" (historical syn: "game") is the period of
   time between a pivot and the next pivot.

FOR:
By my calculations, there have been 2,097 wins. If each win is a pivot
that starts a new round, then this is round 2,098.

AGAINST:
However, rounds are defined as "the period of time between a pivot and
the next pivot". Many wins have happened in the same message (notably
Jason won 1000 times in one message). Messages are considered to happen
instantaneously but sequentially. Arguably, there is no "period of time"
between these wins, and no rounds occurred between them. If this is the
case, then we are closer to round 599.

--

Judge Murphy's Arguments:

As the caller notes, there can be multiple events occurring at the same
instant. The pivot is defined as the instant, not the individual events.

The most recent Herald's report lists (by my count) 1714 distinct wins,
including Jason x1000 (which I believe were indeed simultaneous) and D.
Margaux x501 (likewise). Whatever the exact number of rounds currently
is, it clearly isn't nearly as high as 2098.

I judge FALSE.

==

OFF: [CotC] CFJ 3999 Judged TRUE by ais523

[Kerim Aydin via agora-official]

status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3999
(This document is informational only and contains no game actions).

===  CFJ 3999  ===

  Rule 2139 does not define the contents of the Registrar's monthly
  report to contain all dates such that a person has registered or
  deregistered.

==

Caller:Juan

Judge: ais523
Judgement: TRUE

==

History:

Called by Juan:   13 Oct 2022 20:31:16
Assigned to ais523:   20 Oct 2022 18:35:20
Judged TRUE by ais523:25 Oct 2022 18:50:49

==

Caller's Arguments:

Arguments for TRUE:

Rule 2139 mandates the Registrar's monthly report to include “For each
former player for which the information is reasonably available, the
dates on which e registered and deregistered.” Now, a player is defined
as simply “a registered person”, which would indicate a “former player”
to refer to a person which at some point was registered. Other readings
include that it refers to the entity that was a player and ceased to
exist when that player was deregistered – this is not supported by
evidence. Indeed, the next paragraph of Rule 869 states that “[i]f e
does so [deregister], e CANNOT register or be registered for 30 days”,
which indicates the entity which is the player continues to exist after
deregistration. That is: playerhood is a state, and “former player”
should be understood as an entity which at some point in the past was
registered, but is no longer.

Now, back to the rule in question. It refers to “the dates on which e [a
former player] registered and deregistered”. The qualification “on which
e registered and deregistered” obviously refer to a pair of dates, and
not one date in which the player did both actions. That is not in
question and shall not be discussed further. But the point is that the
plural “dates” now refers to that pair of dates, and the definitive
article “the” makes the whole subject phrase have reference ONLY IF
there is a single entity that satisfies the condition.

Therefore, for people that became players more than once, the phrase has
no referent, and so is confusing and/or ambiguous. So is the whole as
well.

Note, if the rule said “the dates on which e registered OR
deregistered”, there would be a reasonable interpretation, more in tune
with the game's traditions, that the plural refers to all such dates in
which that particular player has either registered, deregistered, or
both. It is not so, however.

There remains only a single question: is there a more suitable
interpretation that makes it so the text is in accordance with (what I
suppose is) the intent of the rule? I'd say NOT, for if the plural in
“dates” accomodates a multitude of possible entities satisfying the
condition that follows, that condition would be “on which e registered
and deregistered” – which is much more rare than what has historically
appeared in Registrars' Monthly Reports.

Arguments for FALSE:

This is proposterous, nitpicking, and must not be indulged.


Caller's Evidence:

> 
> Rule 2139/17 (Power=2)
> The Registrar
>
>   The Registrar is an office; its holder is responsible for keeping
>   track of players.
>
>   The Registrar's weekly report includes:
>
>   1. A list of all players, including information sufficient to
>  identify and contact each player.
>
>   2. The date on which each player most recently became a player.
>
>   3. For each forum with non-Foreign publicity, sufficient
>  instructions for players to receive messages there.
>
>   The Registrar's monthly report includes:
>
>   1. For each former player for which the information is reasonably
>  available, the dates on which e registered and deregistered.
>
> 

--

Judge ais523's Arguments:

> Now, back to the rule in question. It refers to “the dates on which e [a
> former player] registered and deregistered”. The qualification “on which
> e registered and deregistered” obviously refer to a pair of dates, and
> not one date in which the player did both actions. That is not in
> question and shall not be discussed further. But the point is that the
> plural “dates” now refers to that pair of dates, and the definitive
> article “the” makes the whole subject phrase have reference ONLY IF
> there is a single entity that satisfies the condition.

The caller's argument falls down at this point. "dates on