OFF: [Rulekeepor] Notes on Application of Proposals 9073-9086

2024-04-10 Thread Janet Cobb via agora-official
In Proposal 9079:

> Retitle R2642 (Gathering Stones) to "Stone Cost" and then amend R2642 to
> read in full:
>
> Stone Cost is a Stone switch with values of non-negative integers
> and a default of 10. Stone Cost is tracked by the Stonemason.
>
> Any player CAN pay a fee of X Spendies to transfer a specified stone
> to emself, where X is the current Stone Cost of the specified stone.
>
> When a stone is transferred, its Stone Cost is set to the default.
> At the beginning of every week, the Stone Cost for each stone is
> reduced by 1, to a minimum of 0.
>
> Repeal R2642 (Gathering Stones).


The repeal is likely not what was meant. However, it attempts to repeal
Rule 2642 using the wrong (just-changed) title.

The effectiveness of this is CFJ 4078.

-- 
Janet Cobb

Assessor, Rulekeepor, S​tonemason



OFF: [Rulekeepor] ACORN - April 2024

2024-04-10 Thread Janet Cobb via agora-official
THE AGORA NOMIC CODE OF REGULATIONS

These ACORNs are also online at http://agoranomic.org/ruleset/

Date of this ACORN: 11 Apr 2024

No regulations exist.


[Arbitor] CFJ 4078 Called and Assigned to snail [Re: OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 9073-9086]

2024-04-10 Thread nix via agora-official
On 4/7/24 02:25, Janet Cobb via agora-official wrote:
> Retitle R2642 (Gathering Stones) to "Stone Cost" and then amend R2642 to
> read in full:
> 
> Stone Cost is a Stone switch with values of non-negative integers
> and a default of 10. Stone Cost is tracked by the Stonemason.
> 
> Any player CAN pay a fee of X Spendies to transfer a specified stone
> to emself, where X is the current Stone Cost of the specified stone.
> 
> When a stone is transferred, its Stone Cost is set to the default.
> At the beginning of every week, the Stone Cost for each stone is
> reduced by 1, to a minimum of 0.
> 
> Repeal R2642 (Gathering Stones).

I CFJ: Rule 2642 has been repealed.

Evidence:

{
As quoted above, proposal 9079 attempted to retitle, amend, and then
repeal 2642. This was an authorial accident, as the repeal should've
been 2643.

What makes this an unclear case is that the repeal specifies a name for
the rule. Because of the re-titling, that name is incorrect. I kindly
request that the judge weigh in on whether specifying an incorrect rule
name has any effect on this change, and whether that incorrect rule name
being parenthetical matters.
}

I number this CFJ 4078. I assign CFJ 4078 to snail.

-- 
nix
Arbitor



OFF: [Geologist] Weekly Report

2024-04-10 Thread Sarah S. via agora-official
This is the Geologist's weekly report of the 10th of April, 2024.
Last report (which self-ratified) was March 25th.

All instability switches are 0 except where otherwise noted. Crystal
 followed by a number is shorthand for a crystal with identity of that
 number

 =Snail=
 Total size of crystals: 21
 Snail owns Crystal 2463 with size 2
 Snail owns Crystal 2659 with size 10 and instability 9.
 Snail owns Crystal 2451 with size 2
 Snail owns Crystal 2685 with size 2
 Snail owns Crystal 2645 with size 2
 Snail owns Crystal 2438 with size 3

 =Murphy=
Murphy owns Crystal 2642 with size 4 and instability 3.

 =Aris=
 Aris owns Crystal 105 with size 6 and instability 3.

 =kiako=
 Kiako owns Crystal 2640 with size 4 and instability 1.

 =Janet=
 Total size of crystals: 10
Janet owns Crystal 869, with size 3
Janet owns Crystal 2201, with size 3
Janet owns Crystal 1681 with size 3.
Janet owns Crystal 2688 with size 1.

=Kate=
Kate owns Crystal 2492 with size 1.

=nix=
Total size of crystals: 15
Nix owns Crystal 2576 with size 3.
Nix owns Crystal  2578 with size 3.
Nix owns Crystal  2555 with size 3.
Nix owns Crystal 2675 with size 2.
Nix owns Crystal 2641 with size 2.
Nix owns Crystal 2656 with size 2.

=Gaelan=
Total size of crystals: 4.
Gaelan owns Crystal 2581 with size 1.
Gaelan owns Crystal 2168 with size 2.
Gaelan owns Crystal 2478 with size 1.

=ais523=
ais523 owns Crystal 2471 with size 1.

===Events===
March 3: Proposal 9058 adopted, granting Aris Crystal 105 with size 3
March 11: Proposal 9062 adopted, granting Kiako Crystal 2640 with size 2
March 15: 4st deregisters, destroying all crystals e owned
March 18: Proposal 9069 adopted granting snail Crystal 2685 with size 1.
March 23: Proposal 9071 adopted, granting snail Crystal 2645 with size 2.
March 23: Proposal 9072 adopted, granting snail Crystal 2438 with size 3
April 7: Proposal 2492 adopted, granting Kate Crystal 2492 with size 1.
April 7: Proposal 9074 adopted, granting Janet Crystal 1681 with size 3.
Crystal 105, owned by Aris, increases in size to 6. As Aris was not a
coauthor or author of this proposal, Crystal 105 increases in instability
to 3.
April 7: Proposal 9075 adopted, granting nix Crystal 2576 with size 3.
Crystal 2659, owned by snail, increases in size by 3 to 5. As snail was not
a coauthor or author of this proposal, Crystal 2659 increases in
instability to 3.
April 7: Proposal 9076 adopted, granting nix Crystal 2578 with size 3 and
Crystal 2555 with size 3. Crystal 2659, owned by snail, increases in size
by 3 to 8. As snail was not a coauthor or author of this proposal, Crystal
2659 increases in instability to 6.
April 7: Proposal 9077 adopted, increasing the size of Crystal 2685, owned
by snail, to 2. Snail wrote this proposal so the instability does not
increase.
April 7: Proposal 9078 adopted, granting Janet Crystal 2688 with size 1.
April 7: Proposal 9079 adopted. The proposal amended the rule Spendies but
that rule did not yet get assigned an ID number. nix was granted Crystal
2675 with size 2 via repeal. Crystal 2640, owned by kiako, gains in size by
2 to 4. As kiako is a coauthor, it increases in instability by 1. Nix is
granted Crystal 2641 with size 2. Crystal 2642 owned by Murphy increases in
size by 2 to 4 and as Murphy is not an author or coauthor, it increases in
instability to 3. Crystal 2659, owned by snail, increases in size by 2 to
10. As snail is not a coauthor or author, it increases in instability by 3
to 9. Nix is granted Crystal 2656 with size 2.
April 7: Proposal 9080 adopted, granting Gaelan Crystal 2581 with size 1.
April 7: Proposal 9081 adopted, granting Gaelan Crystal 2168 with size 2.
April 7: Proposal 9082 adopted, granting Gaelan Crystal 2478 with size 1
(rounded down from AI 1.7).
April 7: Proposal 9085 adopted, granting ais523 Crystal 2471 with size 1.
--
R. Lee