RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9049-9051
=================================

ID    Title                          Result 
--------------------------------------------
9049  Registration restrictions      ADOPTED
9050  Self-ratification limitations  ADOPTED
9051  A Mossy Cabinet                ADOPTED

I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.

The quorum for all below decisions was 5.

VOTING STRENGTHS
================

Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
#: player has voting strength 3
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6

PROPOSALS
=========

PROPOSAL 9049 (Registration restrictions)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (2): juan, snail
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 9/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.600
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Janet: Endorsement of ais523
]

PROPOSAL 9050 (Self-ratification limitations)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (2): juan, snail
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 9/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.600
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Janet: Endorsement of ais523
]

PROPOSAL 9051 (A Mossy Cabinet)
AUTHOR: snail
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (1): snail^
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (4): Janet^, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 6/0 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.200
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: Janet is the Stonemason: Endorsement of Janet
]

The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9049
Title: Registration restrictions
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors: Aris, ais523


Amend Rule 869 by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Replacing the text "No person can be a player if e is part of another
player or another player is part of em." with "Rules to the contrary
notwithstanding, two or more persons CANNOT become Registered
simultaneously.".

* Inserting the following paragraph after the paragraph beginning "An
Unregistered person CAN":

{

The basis of a person is the set of all persons that are (recursively)
part of em, in addition to emself. Rules to the contrary
notwithstanding, a person CANNOT become Registered if eir basis overlaps
with that of any current player.

}


[

This fixes a bug where two group persons [A B] and [B C] could be both
be players, since neither is a part of the other.

In order to let this work, this also prohibits simultaneous
registrations. This is done now because simultaneous registrations would
break the check for overlapping persons (if [A B] and [B C] could
register simultaneously, neither would overlap with any existing player,
even if they overlapped with each other). As a more general matter,
simultaneous registrations seem likely to result in bugs, and
registration order has been used as a tiebreak before (e.g. for Spaaace).

]

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9050
Title: Self-ratification limitations
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors: 


Amend Rule 2201 ("Self-Ratification") by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Replacing "When a public document is continuously undoubted for one
week after publication" with "When a public document published less than
180 days ago is first continuously undoubted for one week after publication"

* Replacing the text "identifying a document and explaining" with
"identifying a public document published less than 180 days ago and
explaining".

[First, prevent self-ratifying documents from ratifying more than once
if they go from undoubted to doubted to undoubted. Next, add a
(generous) time limit on self-ratification and doubts to prevent very
old documents from surprisingly being ratified or imposing a requirement
on their publishers to respond. Also, only allow claims of error on
published documents (which later parts of the rule assume anyway).]


Amend Rule 2201 ("Self-Ratification") by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Inserting the following paragraph before the paragraph beginning "Any
person CAN": "The definition of documents as self-ratifying and the
definition of documents as self-ratifying attestations are secured at
power 3."

* Appending the following paragraph to the Rule:

{

The issuance of a doubt on a documents, the denial of a claim of error,
and the ceasing of a doubt on a document to be a doubt are secured at
power 3.

}

[Prevent low-power dictatorships from making random things
self-ratifying and from automatically making or denying claims of error.
All self-ratifying things (assets, Proposal Pool, switches, Festivity,
decision initiation/termination) are already defined at power >= 3.]

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9051
Title: A Mossy Cabinet
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: snail
Co-authors: 


Amend Rule 2451 (Executive Orders) by appending the following Cabinet Order:

{
      - Growth (Stonemason): The Prime Minister increases the mossiness of
a specified stone by 2.
}

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

Reply via email to