[Arbitor] CFJ 4078 Called and Assigned to snail [Re: OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 9073-9086]

[nix via agora-official]

On 4/7/24 02:25, Janet Cobb via agora-official wrote:
> Retitle R2642 (Gathering Stones) to "Stone Cost" and then amend R2642 to
> read in full:
> 
> Stone Cost is a Stone switch with values of non-negative integers
> and a default of 10. Stone Cost is tracked by the Stonemason.
> 
> Any player CAN pay a fee of X Spendies to transfer a specified stone
> to emself, where X is the current Stone Cost of the specified stone.
> 
> When a stone is transferred, its Stone Cost is set to the default.
> At the beginning of every week, the Stone Cost for each stone is
> reduced by 1, to a minimum of 0.
> 
> Repeal R2642 (Gathering Stones).

I CFJ: Rule 2642 has been repealed.

Evidence:

{
As quoted above, proposal 9079 attempted to retitle, amend, and then
repeal 2642. This was an authorial accident, as the repeal should've
been 2643.

What makes this an unclear case is that the repeal specifies a name for
the rule. Because of the re-titling, that name is incorrect. I kindly
request that the judge weigh in on whether specifying an incorrect rule
name has any effect on this change, and whether that incorrect rule name
being parenthetical matters.
}

I number this CFJ 4078. I assign CFJ 4078 to snail.

-- 
nix
Arbitor

OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 9073-9086

[Janet Cobb via agora-official]

RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9073-9086
=

IDTitle  Result  
-
9073  In case of unexpected nonplayerhoodADOPTED 
9074  Close enough   ADOPTED 
9075  No Hidden Ownership Restrictions   ADOPTED 
9076  FUNgibilityADOPTED 
9077  Less Fragile Crystals  ADOPTED 
9078  Empire fixes   ADOPTED 
9079  Spendies v1.1  ADOPTED 
9080  One from the archives  ADOPTED 
9081  Don't humiliate the recently departed  ADOPTED 
9082  yes, yes, I got the memo   ADOPTED 
9083  SLR ratification 2023-12-31ADOPTED 
9084  Oneironauts in the Ocean   REJECTED
9085  Fix truthfulness loophole  ADOPTED 
9086  Trimming the most useless rule in the ruleset  REJECTED

I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.

The quorum for all below decisions was 5.

VOTING STRENGTHS


Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
#: player has voting strength 3
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6

PROPOSALS
=

PROPOSAL 9073 (In case of unexpected nonplayerhood)
AUTHOR: Kate
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (7): Janet^, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$, kiako, nix%, snail^
AGAINST (1): R. Lee$
PRESENT (1): Gaelan
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 34/4 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.667
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of non-voter Kate: Inextricable
]

PROPOSAL 9074 (Close enough)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (6): Janet, Murphy, juan, kiako, nix, snail
AGAINST (2): R. Lee, ais523
PRESENT (1): Gaelan
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 18/6 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.444
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: Janet is the Rulekeepor: Endorsement of Janet
juan: Endorsement of snail
kiako: Janet is the Rulekeepor: Endorsement of Janet
]

PROPOSAL 9075 (No Hidden Ownership Restrictions)
AUTHOR: nix
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (8): Gaelan, Janet, Murphy, ais523, juan, kiako, nix, snail
AGAINST (1): R. Lee
PRESENT (0): 
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 24/3 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.778
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of nix
]

PROPOSAL 9076 (FUNgibility)
AUTHOR: nix
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (8): Gaelan, Janet, R. Lee, ais523, juan, kiako, nix, snail
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (1): Murphy
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 24/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.889
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of nix
ais523: Conditional resolved: ais523 was not endorsed
]

PROPOSAL 9077 (Less Fragile Crystals)
AUTHOR: snail
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (6): Gaelan, Murphy%, R. Lee$, juan$, kiako, snail^
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (3): Janet^, ais523%, nix%
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 25/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.667
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of snail
Murphy: R. Lee is the Geologist: Endorsement of R. Lee
]

PROPOSAL 9078 (Empire fixes)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (7): Gaelan, Janet^, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$, kiako, snail^
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (2): R. Lee$, nix%
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 32/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.778
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of Janet
]

PROPOSAL 9079 (Spendies v1.1)
AUTHOR: nix
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (9): Gaelan, Janet^, Murphy%, R. Lee$, ais523%, juan$, kiako, nix%, snail^
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (0): 
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 41/0 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 1.000
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: nix did not vote AGAINST: Endorsement of snail
kiako: Endorsement of nix
]

PROPOSAL 9080 (One from the archives)
AUTHOR: Gaelan
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (8): Gaelan, Janet^, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$, kiako, nix%, snail^
AGAINST (1): R. Lee$
PRESENT (0): 
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 37/4 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.778
OUTCOME: ADOPTED

PROPOSAL 9081 (Don't humiliate the recently departed)
AUTHOR: Gaelan
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (5): Gaelan, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$, snail^
AGAINST (1): R. Lee$
PRESENT (3): Janet^, kiako, nix%
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 23/4 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.444
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
kiako: Janet is the Assessor: Endorsement of Janet
]

PROPOSAL 9082 (yes, yes, I got the memo)
AUTHOR: Gaelan
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (4): Janet^, Murphy%, R. Lee$, ais523%
AGAINST (2): kiako, snail^
PRESENT (3): Gaelan, juan$, nix%
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 20/9 (AI=1.7)
POPULARITY: 0.222
OUTCOME: ADOPTED

PROPOSAL 9083 (SLR ratification 2023-12-31)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (4): Murphy, ais523, juan, nix
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (5): Gaelan, Janet, R. Lee, kiako, snail
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 12/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.444
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of Janet
kiako: Janet is the Rulekeepor: Endorsement of Janet
snail: Endorsement of Janet
]

PROPOSAL 9084 (Oneironauts in the Ocean)
AUTHOR: kiako
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (3): Gaelan, kiako, nix%
AGAINST (2): Janet^, R. Lee$
PRESENT (4): Murphy%, ais523%, juan$, snail^
BALLOTS: 9
AI (F/A): 11/10 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.111
OUTCOME: REJECTED
[