Re: OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposals 8388-8404

2020-05-25 Thread Reuben Staley via agora-official

I vote as follows:

On 2020-05-25 16:01, Aris Merchant via agora-official wrote:

ID Author(s)AITitle
---
8388f  nch  1.0   The Webmastor

FOR

8389f  G.   2.0   Just Impeach instead

FOR

8390*  R. Lee   3.0   Registror

AGAINST

8391*  R. Lee   3.0   Notory (Vote Labour)
AGAINST; the -or is fun, but I think it should only really stand in 
place of where -er is in regular words.

8392j  Jason2.0   Prior violations

FOR

8393f  Aris 2.0   Elections Aren't Over Till They End

FOR

8394f  Jason2.0   8228 retry

FOR

8395l  Jason1.1   Editorial what?
FOR, I guess. Based on Agora's reaction to all attempts to promulgate 
such regulations, it seems unlikely to me that anything will pass 
anytime soon.

8396e  grok, G. 1.0   Auction End Clarification

FOR

8397l  P.S.S.   2.0   Referral

FOR

8398*  Murphy, nch, G.  3.0   More conservative implicit announcements

AGAINST. Spelling it out makes us actually think about things.

8399j  R. Lee   1.0   E had two months!

FOR

8400l  R. Lee   1.0   Clinton v City of New York

FOR

8401j  Aris, P.S.S. 1.0   Defense Against the Dark Arts

FOR with an added note that the names of crimes in this are fantastic.

8402*  Aris, Falsifian  3.0   Promises

PRESENT. It's not a bad idea, but I'm not sure it's really necessary.

8403*  Trigon   4.0   1698 shortening

PRESENT

8404j  P.S.S., [1]  1.7   High Crimes and Treason

PRESENT for now.

--
Trigon


OFF: [Promotor] Distribution of Proposals 8388-8404

2020-05-25 Thread Aris Merchant via agora-official
I hereby distribute each listed proposal, initiating the Agoran
Decision of whether to adopt it, and removing it from the proposal
pool. For this decision, the vote collector is the Assessor, the
quorum is 8, the voting method is AI-majority, and the valid
options are FOR and AGAINST (PRESENT is also a valid vote, as are
conditional votes).

ID Author(s)AITitle
---
8388f  nch  1.0   The Webmastor
8389f  G.   2.0   Just Impeach instead
8390*  R. Lee   3.0   Registror
8391*  R. Lee   3.0   Notory (Vote Labour)
8392j  Jason2.0   Prior violations
8393f  Aris 2.0   Elections Aren't Over Till They End
8394f  Jason2.0   8228 retry
8395l  Jason1.1   Editorial what?
8396e  grok, G. 1.0   Auction End Clarification
8397l  P.S.S.   2.0   Referral
8398*  Murphy, nch, G.  3.0   More conservative implicit announcements
8399j  R. Lee   1.0   E had two months!
8400l  R. Lee   1.0   Clinton v City of New York
8401j  Aris, P.S.S. 1.0   Defense Against the Dark Arts
8402*  Aris, Falsifian  3.0   Promises
8403*  Trigon   4.0   1698 shortening
8404j  P.S.S., [1]  1.7   High Crimes and Treason

[1] Murphy, nch, G.


Proposal pool report: At the beginning of this week, the proposal
pool contained the following proposals, in addition to those listed above:

Author(s)AITitle
---
G., R. Lee   1.7   Mooting moots
G.   1.0   a Proposed Contract
Aris, [2]1.0   Backup Conservatism

[2] G., Jason, Murphy

Legend: * : Democratic proposal.
# : Ordinary proposal, unset chamber.
e : Economy ministry proposal.
f : Efficiency ministry proposal.
j : Justice ministry proposal.
l : Legislation ministry proposal.
p : Participation ministry proposal.


The full text of the aforementioned proposal(s) is included below.

//
ID: 8388
Title: The Webmastor
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: nch
Co-authors:


Enact a rule titled "The Webmastor" with Power=1 and the following text:

  The Webmastor is an office.

  The Webmastor's monthly report includes a Directory, a Changelog, a
  Warning Log, and an Error Log. The Directory lists notable
  currently maintained public resources. The Changelog lists notable
  changes to resources. The Warning Log lists notable potential
  issues, such as inaccurate or aging resources or unintended issues
  with a public resource. The Error Log lists notable losses of
  resources - where a resource has become inaccessible, unmaintained,
  or unusable. Where 'notable' is used in this rule its meaning is up
  to the Webmastor's discretion.

//
ID: 8389
Title: Just Impeach instead
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: G.
Co-authors:


Amend Rule 2531 by deleting:
  If the Referee attempts to levy three or more INEFFECTIVE fines
  in a week, any player CAN, with two support, issue a writ of
  Impartial Arbitration Restoration, immediately making the
  position of Referee vacant. When a writ of Impartial Arbitration
  Restoration is issued, the ADoP SHALL initiate an election for
  the Referee in a timely fashion.

[context:  When this was written, there were very few protections in this
rule, and general impeachment didn't exist.  Now with the full list of
protections the Referee is pretty constrained, and impeachment exists.]

//
ID: 8390
Title: Registror
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: R. Lee
Co-authors:


Retitle the rule 2139 "The Registrar" to "The Registror"
Amend each rule that contains the text "Registrar" by replacing that text
with "Registror"
(This informational segment in brackets has no legal effects. A list of
those rules as this proposal is written for your information is rules 869,
478, 2139, 1789, 2532, 2574, 1885, 2581)

//
ID: 8391
Title: Notory (Vote Labour)
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: R. Lee
Co-authors:


Retitle rule 2608 "The Notary" to "The Notory"
Amend rules 2608 and 2450, and also any other rule that contains the text
"Notary", by replacing the word "Notary" with "Notory"

//
ID: 8392
Title: Prior violations
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: Jason
Co-authors:


Amend Rule 2531 by changing the list item labeled (2) to read, in its
entirety:  "(2) it attempts to levy a fine for an action or inaction
which, at the time the inaction or action occurre