Re: Keynes in China

2001-02-06 Thread Carl Close

Several years ago, if I recall correctly, I read in AEI's newsletter 
that Gottfried Harberler's _Propserity and Depression_ was being used 
as a text in China.

Carl Close
The Independent Institute

but being in china for 2 summers. as i can see that as time goes on, 
they're becoming a bit more liberal on things

At 06:20 PM 2/4/01 -0800, you wrote:

On Sun, 4 Feb 2001, fabio guillermo rojas wrote:


  A new graduate student in my department told me that at Beijing
  University, econ undergraduates are not taught Keynesian economics -
  they get a good dose of Marxism and then they get hooked up with
  monetarism!!

  Can anybody else verify this? Is China liberalized enough so that
  students are allowed to openly be taught free market economics?


I have some Chinese grad student friends and I get the impression that
what you say is correct.

But at the beginning of every one of these free-market economics books,
my friends tell me that the government prints a short "caveat emptor".
This basically states that the free-market ideas in the book are all
wrong, and that the students are being taught about these ideas so they
can see (i) how wrong these ideas really are, and (ii) how great Marx
is in comparison.

Alex Robson
UC Irvine




Re: Keynes in China

2001-02-05 Thread markjohn®


but being in china for 2 summers. as i can see that as time goes on, 
they're becoming a bit more liberal on things

At 06:20 PM 2/4/01 -0800, you wrote:

On Sun, 4 Feb 2001, fabio guillermo rojas wrote:

 
  A new graduate student in my department told me that at Beijing
  University, econ undergraduates are not taught Keynesian economics -
  they get a good dose of Marxism and then they get hooked up with
  monetarism!!
 
  Can anybody else verify this? Is China liberalized enough so that
  students are allowed to openly be taught free market economics?
 

I have some Chinese grad student friends and I get the impression that
what you say is correct.

But at the beginning of every one of these free-market economics books,
my friends tell me that the government prints a short "caveat emptor".
This basically states that the free-market ideas in the book are all
wrong, and that the students are being taught about these ideas so they
can see (i) how wrong these ideas really are, and (ii) how great Marx
is in comparison.

Alex Robson
UC Irvine




Keynes in China

2001-02-04 Thread fabio guillermo rojas


A new graduate student in my department told me that at Beijing
University, econ undergraduates are not taught Keynesian economics -
they get a good dose of Marxism and then they get hooked up with
monetarism!!

Can anybody else verify this? Is China liberalized enough so that
students are allowed to openly be taught free market economics?

-fabio




Re: Keynes in China

2001-02-04 Thread Alexander Robert William Robson


On Sun, 4 Feb 2001, fabio guillermo rojas wrote:


 A new graduate student in my department told me that at Beijing
 University, econ undergraduates are not taught Keynesian economics -
 they get a good dose of Marxism and then they get hooked up with
 monetarism!!

 Can anybody else verify this? Is China liberalized enough so that
 students are allowed to openly be taught free market economics?


I have some Chinese grad student friends and I get the impression that
what you say is correct.

But at the beginning of every one of these free-market economics books,
my friends tell me that the government prints a short "caveat emptor".
This basically states that the free-market ideas in the book are all
wrong, and that the students are being taught about these ideas so they
can see (i) how wrong these ideas really are, and (ii) how great Marx
is in comparison.

Alex Robson
UC Irvine