dear ....
"ST" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
plese dont needlessly carry a topic beyond elastic limits ( u said "...try to keep it short...").......it disgusts.....and moreso ...please indulge in somethign more mature and fruitful for ur time rather than fighting ur mind off for something that has no absolutes ,thru endlessly long mails.......and please ARr is no God....he just another giftted human ( who has his misgivings too...does falter and does fail rediculously bad sometimes......but its all in the game ( smile) .....fans love him for his honesty to accept his failures and to move on .........) who is doing his duty ( as all should do !!!!) of spreading peace and harmony thru music....( smile) .........
"ST" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:-
"ST" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: Re: sick of "the music could have been better" (pls MUST READ
for fans)
I'll try to make this short, but lets see how it goes..
When I said you picked zubeidaa songs to make your point I agreed that
zubeidaa songs cont carry hard traits of the time ans can be replaced
into others.
Whereas laagaan, bose, rising are more irreplaceable. Partly because
of the lyrics and accounts of history ingrained into the song, but
partly also because of its sounds.
> Aren't other replacement possible from pukar to 1947 earth, zubaida,
lagaan
Yes some will be possible, many not possible.
Waltz of romance.. possible in other situations demanding waltz in an
british presence, but clearly not otherwise.. so couldnt have been
placed even in bose, or 1947 unless the director made changes to his
view. And that is an unfair comparison.
Chale chalo. sure could have replaced kadam karam badhae ja. Whereas
the contrary is not a good choice because kadam kadam was a unique
theme of Subhash's army. Still does that mean chale chalo is not
unique to lagaan. It conveys every possible concept it needs to. The
anger toward british rule, persevierence to beat the opponent,
confronting in together in a team etc etc. It just so happens that
Bose and lagaan had situations very similar and the song could be
replaced. But that wont go into pukaar or swades.
Oo palanhare and ek tuu hii bharosaa, sure. Context is pretty much ..................................
Subject: Re: sick of "the music could have been better" (pls MUST READ
for fans)
I'll try to make this short, but lets see how it goes..
When I said you picked zubeidaa songs to make your point I agreed that
zubeidaa songs cont carry hard traits of the time ans can be replaced
into others.
Whereas laagaan, bose, rising are more irreplaceable. Partly because
of the lyrics and accounts of history ingrained into the song, but
partly also because of its sounds.
> Aren't other replacement possible from pukar to 1947 earth, zubaida,
lagaan
Yes some will be possible, many not possible.
Waltz of romance.. possible in other situations demanding waltz in an
british presence, but clearly not otherwise.. so couldnt have been
placed even in bose, or 1947 unless the director made changes to his
view. And that is an unfair comparison.
Chale chalo. sure could have replaced kadam karam badhae ja. Whereas
the contrary is not a good choice because kadam kadam was a unique
theme of Subhash's army. Still does that mean chale chalo is not
unique to lagaan. It conveys every possible concept it needs to. The
anger toward british rule, persevierence to beat the opponent,
confronting in together in a team etc etc. It just so happens that
Bose and lagaan had situations very similar and the song could be
replaced. But that wont go into pukaar or swades.
Oo palanhare and ek tuu hii bharosaa, sure. Context is pretty much ..................................
whatever!!!
M a k e a D i f f e r e n c e !!!
Free antispam, antivirus and 1GB to save all your messages
Only in Yahoo! Mail: http://in.mail.yahoo.com
This August, Discover the Birth of Your Independence
and The Magic of A.R.Rahman's Music in
Mangal Pandey - The Rising
http://www.risingthefilm.com
http://www.mangalpandeythefilm.com
Music released: Jul 14, 2005 Movie releases: Aug 12, 2005
Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic.
Only at arrahmanfans - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community.
Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com
Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS
- Visit your group "arrahmanfans" on the web.
- To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
