Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
Hey, Infact movie is good me and my friends enjoied it...here we are just talking about the song sequence and stuff...that cld have been done better.The BGM as always too good, especially the pappu cant dance variants...and the scene when hero is in jail...i njoied those...Kahin to bits was goin good with the movie scenes.inshort i njoied the movie...Boss's touch is there in every scenes... ~Arun - Original Message From: ramya varma <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, July 7, 2008 4:02:58 PM Subject: Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing. Hey , I wouldnt call it disaapointing . It is an ok movie.Its a simple story. Has its moments. The high point wud be the character of Genelia's broher and Of course ARR 's music. Its wonderful. Frankly I saw the movie for the songs. Love Them. --- On Mon, 7/7/08, Gomzy wrote: From: Gomzy Subject: Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing. To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, 7 July, 2008, 11:13 AM I second Durba here. The director didnt know when to use the songs. Whats more surprising is , he himself was the lyricist. Strange ! Sometimes i just wish ARR composes for the yashs, karan johars, and the bhansalis. Agreed their movies usually suck, but they handle music so well. On Mon, Jul 7, 2008 at 10:54 AM, durba bhattacharjee wrote: I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, we are note gone to see Chitrahar. But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very well was RDB. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "siva_arr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two more > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am happy > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were just > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > public as well. > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a young > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such directors > for too long. > > Siva > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Dhruv Shenoy > wrote: > > > > Hi friends, > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell out > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get to > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. But > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the director > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > Bring your gang together. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! Group.
[arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
I completely agree, the songs were very poorly placed, especially the Tu Bole coming just in few minutes after Kabhi Kabhi, what a stupid placement. And the biggest disappointment was that Runa's version was completley missing. It could have been the highlight of the storyline. Next, instead of highlighting the two versions of Jaane Tu the director was more interested in the old Jaane Tu song. Kahin To was wasted and though Pappu Cant Dance was completley picturised, it would have been more interesting if Pappu was a real character which they mock at with the song. Loved the movie though. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "durba bhattacharjee" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The > movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that > the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just > wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene > after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then > why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes > with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same > fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of > the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first > para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of > Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite > obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, > we are note gone to see Chitrahar. > > But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats > with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in > almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and > dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are > full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, > TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences > too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good > songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension > by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never > happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very > well was RDB. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "siva_arr" wrote: > > > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two > more > > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am > happy > > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were > just > > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > > public as well. > > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a > young > > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such > directors > > for too long. > > > > Siva > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Dhruv Shenoy > > wrote: > > > > > > Hi friends, > > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell > out > > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get > to > > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. > But > > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the > director > > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > > > >
Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
Hey , I wouldnt call it disaapointing . It is an ok movie.Its a simple story. Has its moments. The high point wud be the character of Genelia's broher and Of course ARR 's music. Its wonderful. Frankly I saw the movie for the songs. Love Them. --- On Mon, 7/7/08, Gomzy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Gomzy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing. To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, 7 July, 2008, 11:13 AM I second Durba here. The director didnt know when to use the songs. Whats more surprising is , he himself was the lyricist. Strange ! Sometimes i just wish ARR composes for the yashs, karan johars, and the bhansalis. Agreed their movies usually suck, but they handle music so well. On Mon, Jul 7, 2008 at 10:54 AM, durba bhattacharjee wrote: I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, we are note gone to see Chitrahar. But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very well was RDB. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "siva_arr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two more > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am happy > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were just > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > public as well. > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a young > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such directors > for too long. > > Siva > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Dhruv Shenoy > wrote: > > > > Hi friends, > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell out > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get to > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. But > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the director > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > Bring your gang together. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! group at http://in.promos.yahoo.com/groups/
Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
Nobody is denying that Kabhi kabhi is a hit or not. None of the songs were according to the situation including kabhi kabhi. Maybe pappu cant dance was. On 7/7/08, shanavas.chemmamkuzhi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Sad to see this messages about JTYJN. I think "Aditi" is one of AR's > biggest hit in Hindi and no body can deny Abbas Tyrewala's > contribution to that song. > > Between ..JTYJN is a good romantic comedy and i hope it will work in > Boxoffice. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > Gomzy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > > I second Durba here. The director didnt know when to use the songs. > > Whats more surprising is , he himself was the lyricist. Strange ! > > Sometimes i just wish ARR composes for the yashs, karan johars, > and the > > bhansalis. > > Agreed their movies usually suck, but they handle music so well. > > > > On Mon, Jul 7, 2008 at 10:54 AM, durba bhattacharjee < > > [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. > The > > > movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear > that > > > the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He > just > > > wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next > scene > > > after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? > Then > > > why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole > comes > > > with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The > same > > > fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The > situation of > > > the song arrives at the middle of another song After the > first > > > para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music > of > > > Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was > quite > > > obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple > reason, > > > we are note gone to see Chitrahar. > > > > > > But one thing I really don't understand why this same story > repeats > > > with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in > > > almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and > > > dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked > are > > > full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like > JWM, > > > TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song > sequences > > > too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good > > > songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different > dimension > > > by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never > > > happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very > > > well was RDB. > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > > > 40yahoogroups.com>, > > > "siva_arr" wrote: > > > > > > > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we > shud be > > > > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in > movie. I > > > > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and > two > > > more > > > > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am > > > happy > > > > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they > were > > > just > > > > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't > reach > > > > public as well. > > > > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def > Abbas > > > > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a > > > young > > > > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such > > > directors > > > > for too long. > > > > > > > > Siva > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > > > > 40yahoogroups.com>, > > > Dhruv Shenoy > > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hi friends, > > > > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > > > > disappointment. The way they treated each song also > disappointed me. > > > > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made > hell > > > out > > > > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont > get > > > to > > > > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know > that > > > > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually > need > > > > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there > for ARR > > > > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of > music. > > > But > > > > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the > > > director > > > > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I > think ARR > > > > should not work with those people who does not understand his > music. > > > > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it > was only > > > > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i > would > > > > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
[arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
Sad to see this messages about JTYJN. I think "Aditi" is one of AR's biggest hit in Hindi and no body can deny Abbas Tyrewala's contribution to that song. Between ..JTYJN is a good romantic comedy and i hope it will work in Boxoffice. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Gomzy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I second Durba here. The director didnt know when to use the songs. > Whats more surprising is , he himself was the lyricist. Strange ! > Sometimes i just wish ARR composes for the yashs, karan johars, and the > bhansalis. > Agreed their movies usually suck, but they handle music so well. > > On Mon, Jul 7, 2008 at 10:54 AM, durba bhattacharjee < > [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The > > movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that > > the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just > > wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene > > after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then > > why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes > > with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same > > fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of > > the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first > > para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of > > Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite > > obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, > > we are note gone to see Chitrahar. > > > > But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats > > with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in > > almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and > > dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are > > full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, > > TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences > > too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good > > songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension > > by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never > > happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very > > well was RDB. > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > > "siva_arr" wrote: > > > > > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > > > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > > > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two > > more > > > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am > > happy > > > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were > > just > > > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > > > public as well. > > > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > > > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a > > young > > > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such > > directors > > > for too long. > > > > > > Siva > > > > > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > > Dhruv Shenoy > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > Hi friends, > > > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > > > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > > > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell > > out > > > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get > > to > > > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > > > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > > > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > > > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. > > But > > > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the > > director > > > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > > > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > > > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > > > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > > > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
lets hope Ghajini movie would do full justice to ARRs songs.. tamil version had 5 tracks in five different plots.. out of which we've already heard/read news about three songs and picturizations.. (2 numbers in various exotic locations and the other one is a low-waist dance by Aamir :).. it should be the songs in plots 2, 4 and 5 respectively. whenever ARR is being interviewed regarding his timeless album, the albums that strike the interviewers mind are roja rangeela dilse taal lagaan i wish ghajini joins this priceless list.. with an actor who has the caliber to promote his movie to the core and a strong script in place, ARRs music shall depend on this platform to scale new heights, to make Ghajini as the album of the decade.. i mean it!! On Sun, Jul 6, 2008 at 10:24 PM, durba bhattacharjee < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The > movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that > the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just > wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene > after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then > why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes > with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same > fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of > the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first > para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of > Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite > obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, > we are note gone to see Chitrahar. > > But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats > with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in > almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and > dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are > full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, > TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences > too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good > songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension > by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never > happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very > well was RDB. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > "siva_arr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two > more > > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am > happy > > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were > just > > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > > public as well. > > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a > young > > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such > directors > > for too long. > > > > Siva > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > Dhruv Shenoy > > wrote: > > > > > > Hi friends, > > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell > out > > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get > to > > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. > But > > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the > director > > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > > > > > >
Re: [arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
I second Durba here. The director didnt know when to use the songs. Whats more surprising is , he himself was the lyricist. Strange ! Sometimes i just wish ARR composes for the yashs, karan johars, and the bhansalis. Agreed their movies usually suck, but they handle music so well. On Mon, Jul 7, 2008 at 10:54 AM, durba bhattacharjee < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The > movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that > the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just > wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene > after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then > why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes > with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same > fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of > the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first > para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of > Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite > obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, > we are note gone to see Chitrahar. > > But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats > with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in > almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and > dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are > full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, > TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences > too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good > songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension > by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never > happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very > well was RDB. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > "siva_arr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two > more > > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am > happy > > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were > just > > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > > public as well. > > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a > young > > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such > directors > > for too long. > > > > Siva > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , > Dhruv Shenoy > > wrote: > > > > > > Hi friends, > > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell > out > > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get > to > > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. > But > > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the > director > > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > > > > > > >
[arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
I beg to differ. I think JTYJN was a big time disappoinment. The movie was ok with some good hilarious scenes but it was clear that the director has no understanding of making a song sequence. He just wasted the songs. For example, Tu Bole starts at the very next scene after Aditi song ends. We havnt gone to see Chitrahar, right? Then why two songs in two consecutive scenes? So naturally, Tu Bole comes with the fate of being chopped off after 30 seconds or so. The same fate with Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version). The situation of the song arrives at the middle of another song After the first para of Kahin To (the most ill traeted song), the opening music of Jane Tu Meri Kya Thi (Sukhwinder version) starts!!! And it was quite obvious that this song would never take off, for that simple reason, we are note gone to see Chitrahar. But one thing I really don't understand why this same story repeats with ARR again and again? Why his songs being treated so badly in almost every film? Hindi film is always identified with music and dance. In last two years whatever movies I have seen and liked are full with songs. Except Aamir and Sarkar Raj, the movies like JWM, TZP, Omkara, Metro, etc all has good music and good song sequences too. The directors of these movies not only succeeded to get good songs from their MDs but also gave their movies a different dimension by using the songs the most beautiful way. Then why this never happens with ARR? The last time I saw ARR's music being used very well was RDB. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "siva_arr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be > realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I > thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two more > full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am happy > that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were just > meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach > public as well. > I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas > is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a young > director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such directors > for too long. > > Siva > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Dhruv Shenoy > wrote: > > > > Hi friends, > > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete > disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. > Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell out > of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get to > hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that > situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need > background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR > and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. But > director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the director > has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR > should not work with those people who does not understand his music. > My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only > ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would > have straight away moved out of cinema hall. > > >
[arr] Re: JTYJN very disappointing.
While I can appreciate the concern as ARR's fan, I think we shud be realistic in our expectations about treatment of songs in movie. I thought Jaane tu felt like bit stretched in terms of time and two more full songs wud have made considerable damage to the movie. I am happy that Abbas got two nice songs from Rahman( even though they were just meant to be background) and it is not that those songs didn't reach public as well. I am looking forward for future movies from same combo and def Abbas is here to stay as a director. And yes ARR has probably found a young director who makes cool movies and he has been missing such directors for too long. Siva --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Dhruv Shenoy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi friends, > Just watched JTYJN The film was complete disappointment. The way they treated each song also disappointed me. Poor choreography for Pappu Cant Dance The director made hell out of the beautiful song Kahin To And one more thing you wont get to hear much from ARR in terms of background music. But i know that situation was like that in the film where you dont actually need background music. But who wants to see the film i went there for ARR and i am happy that ARR has done brilliant job in terms of music. But director had done injustice to his music. And more thing the director has also edited Jaane Tu Meri Kya Hai from the film. I think ARR should not work with those people who does not understand his music. My rating to this movie is 2/5. ARR's music 5/5. Because it was only ARR's music who made me sit and watch that film. Otherwise i would have straight away moved out of cinema hall. >
