Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
But Mahima, this is still not an excuse. Thats why I wish ARR composes for only Mani, Shankar or Menon now for that matter. These debutants are a pain and i feel they do not deserve his music. look what happened to ATM and now sakarakatti. On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 9:45 AM, Mahima Sengupta [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On *Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED]* wrote: From: sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. *Hope Vithur understand my view too*. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ ... wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far because of that. Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad, they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM. I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first show. The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their respective storylines. Can you guys please throw in some movies name that bombed at the box office even though they had beautiful music by ARR. I remember the following: Kangalal Kaithu Sei Kadhal Virus Boys (to an extent) ATM Baba Duet E20U18 En Swasa kaatre SOK Paarthale Paravasam Rhythm Tajmahal Udhaya Uyire If you see the above list, it even includes the big stalwarts like Maniratnam, Shankar, Kathir, Bharathiraja. I have mentioned only the tamil movies, there is a big list in HINDI too. Please throw in some
RE: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
dear friends, i had a doubt from the atrting of the movie itself whether this movie will also become another e20u18 and it happened when some of my arr fans said their review immediately after the first say first show. everyone of us disappointed on movies result as anna is doing few movies and if it is not becoming a hit the songs wont reach the mass becaue of the result. it is common to all the md's. it is natural that we hope that all movies of anna should becmoe a hit but we should take anything lightly, think for a while how arranna might felt bad that his hardwork and beautiful score for the film will get reduced once the review is not good. My views on the movie sakkarakkatti 1.every fan of arr should watch this movie for his deadly re-recording (songs not to mention as we already known about the quality) 2.thought they might have used taxi song as title song,and anna changed my thought form the second bit itself,beautiful title music and a perfect score for every scenes in the first half including two english songs as bgm in the movie(vithur my friend u r having a big job in filtering the movies bgm and sending it) 3.only songs are the highlight in the second half,since there is no story how the songs will get click. 4.songs picturisation,dance in taxi song and photography are other area to be congraulated oher than music. 5.my question to Dhaanu sir,how he was very confident that the storyline and screenplay will attract the people and how he agreed for the movie? anna we are all with u and keep up ur good work,we enjoyed ur music in every scene of the movie and expecting the same in evry movie. our small reques u have the capability to do more movies but u wont,please sonsider from our point of view,if a movie fails also we wont felt bad that another of ur movie will make it,when u are not doing much movies like one tamil in a yr and if it fails we feel very sad. please look over it. friends in this community close to anna,do convey this to him. past is past and i am sure that not only his music and songs will be a hit in cassette sales but also the movie. Chennaiyil oru Malaikalam will cure the wound that caused to us by sakkarakkati. Regards, Murali.G Coimbatore To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Sat, 27 Sep 2008 21:15:13 -0700Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED]Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatiiTo: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. Hope Vithur understand my view too. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath,I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been.In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
Gomzy, The advantage of working with these young directors is that rahman is given complete freedom...He can experiment a lot.. Do you expect rahman to give songs like taxi taxi, i miss u da , elay elay in one single album when he works with mani or shankar...and oh ya..considering the subjects that these directors are dealing in at presentwe could only dream of these kind of songs.. --- On Sat, 9/27/08, Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 10:56 PM But Mahima, this is still not an excuse. Thats why I wish ARR composes for only Mani, Shankar or Menon now for that matter. These debutants are a pain and i feel they do not deserve his music. look what happened to ATM and now sakarakatti. On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 9:45 AM, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com wrote: From: sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. Hope Vithur understand my view too. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ ... wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far because of that. Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad, they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM. I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first show. The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their respective
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
Another flop film is added to ARR's long list of Flop films (even tho the music, BGM, ARR's efforts were excellent) in Tamil. This again shows ARR's selection of movies being bad or not good movies being given to him. We all know that Kalipuli dhanu pressurised ARR to do this film even tho we all knew that this wont click. ARR should do movies which are good, appealing to heart (irrespective of Director, producer, Budget), and not just for BIG banners, BIG Directors, BIG Producers. ARR has crossed that stage of doing movies for selective Directors. There are lot of Tamil Directors with huge abundance of talent ready to work with ARR. I second Director Ameer's statement made during Saroja Audio launch - Original Message From: murali ramakrishnan [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2008 11:58:47 AM Subject: RE: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii dear friends, i had a doubt from the atrting of the movie itself whether this movie will also become another e20u18 and it happened when some of my arr fans said their review immediately after the first say first show. everyone of us disappointed on movies result as anna is doing few movies and if it is not becoming a hit the songs wont reach the mass becaue of the result. it is common to all the md's. it is natural that we hope that all movies of anna should becmoe a hit but we should take anything lightly, think for a while how arranna might felt bad that his hardwork and beautiful score for the film will get reduced once the review is not good. My views on the movie sakkarakkatti 1.every fan of arr should watch this movie for his deadly re-recording (songs not to mention as we already known about the quality) 2.thought they might have used taxi song as title song,and anna changed my thought form the second bit itself,beautiful title music and a perfect score for every scenes in the first half including two english songs as bgm in the movie(vithur my friend u r having a big job in filtering the movies bgm and sending it) 3.only songs are the highlight in the second half,since there is no story how the songs will get click. 4.songs picturisation, dance in taxi song and photography are other area to be congraulated oher than music. 5.my question to Dhaanu sir,how he was very confident that the storyline and screenplay will attract the people and how he agreed for the movie? anna we are all with u and keep up ur good work,we enjoyed ur music in every scene of the movie and expecting the same in evry movie. our small reques u have the capability to do more movies but u wont,please sonsider from our point of view,if a movie fails also we wont felt bad that another of ur movie will make it,when u are not doing much movies like one tamil in a yr and if it fails we feel very sad. please look over it. friends in this community close to anna,do convey this to him. past is past and i am sure that not only his music and songs will be a hit in cassette sales but also the movie. Chennaiyil oru Malaikalam will cure the wound that caused to us by sakkarakkati. Regards, Murali.G Coimbatore To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com From: mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] com Date: Sat, 27 Sep 2008 21:15:13 -0700 Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com wrote: From: sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly.. i didnt mean anyother way. Hope Vithur understand my view too. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
Well isnt it better if he experiments all alone by himself( an album or something) than composing for these fools who end up screwing all the songs? Have you seen Kisna movie? Guys who watched that movie and who arent great arr fans hate the song hum issa pal yaha simply cuz of the treatment of that song in the movie. On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 12:27 PM, $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED]wrote: Gomzy, The advantage of working with these young directors is that rahman is given complete freedom...He can experiment a lot.. Do you expect rahman to give songs like taxi taxi, i miss u da , elay elay in one single album when he works with mani or shankar...and oh ya..considering the subjects that these directors are dealing in at presentwe could only dream of these kind of songs.. --- On *Sat, 9/27/08, Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED]* wrote: From: Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 10:56 PM But Mahima, this is still not an excuse. Thats why I wish ARR composes for only Mani, Shankar or Menon now for that matter. These debutants are a pain and i feel they do not deserve his music. look what happened to ATM and now sakarakatti. On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 9:45 AM, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] com [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On *Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com[EMAIL PROTECTED] * wrote: From: sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. *Hope Vithur understand my view too*. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ ... wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
Kalaipuli Dhanu's son is an amateurish Director. Lets forgive him ... Enjoy the BGMs, and the songs... Many more Tamil Hits on the way like ROBOT, MARMAYOGI... On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 3:09 PM, Sathya Sundaram [EMAIL PROTECTED]wrote: Another flop film is added to ARR's long list of Flop films (even tho the music, BGM, ARR's efforts were excellent) in Tamil. This again shows ARR's selection of movies being bad or not good movies being given to him. We all know that Kalipuli dhanu pressurised ARR to do this film even tho we all knew that this wont click. ARR should do movies which are good, appealing to heart (irrespective of Director, producer, Budget), and not just for BIG banners, BIG Directors, BIG Producers. ARR has crossed that stage of doing movies for selective Directors. There are lot of Tamil Directors with huge abundance of talent ready to work with ARR. I second Director Ameer's statement made during Saroja Audio launch - Original Message From: murali ramakrishnan [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2008 11:58:47 AM Subject: RE: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii dear friends, i had a doubt from the atrting of the movie itself whether this movie will also become another e20u18 and it happened when some of my arr fans said their review immediately after the first say first show. everyone of us disappointed on movies result as anna is doing few movies and if it is not becoming a hit the songs wont reach the mass becaue of the result. it is common to all the md's. it is natural that we hope that all movies of anna should becmoe a hit but we should take anything lightly, think for a while how arranna might felt bad that his hardwork and beautiful score for the film will get reduced once the review is not good. My views on the movie sakkarakkatti 1.every fan of arr should watch this movie for his deadly re-recording (songs not to mention as we already known about the quality) 2.thought they might have used taxi song as title song,and anna changed my thought form the second bit itself,beautiful title music and a perfect score for every scenes in the first half including two english songs as bgm in the movie(vithur my friend u r having a big job in filtering the movies bgm and sending it) 3.only songs are the highlight in the second half,since there is no story how the songs will get click. 4.songs picturisation, dance in taxi song and photography are other area to be congraulated oher than music. 5.my question to Dhaanu sir,how he was very confident that the storyline and screenplay will attract the people and how he agreed for the movie? anna we are all with u and keep up ur good work,we enjoyed ur music in every scene of the movie and expecting the same in evry movie. our small reques u have the capability to do more movies but u wont,please sonsider from our point of view,if a movie fails also we wont felt bad that another of ur movie will make it,when u are not doing much movies like one tamil in a yr and if it fails we feel very sad. please look over it. friends in this community close to anna,do convey this to him. past is past and i am sure that not only his music and songs will be a hit in cassette sales but also the movie. Chennaiyil oru Malaikalam will cure the wound that caused to us by sakkarakkati. Regards, Murali.G Coimbatore -- To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com From: mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] com Date: Sat, 27 Sep 2008 21:15:13 -0700 Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On *Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com* wrote: From: sath.murthy sath.murthy@ yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. *Hope Vithur understand my view too*. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
sakkarakkati is the worst movie i've seen in recent times. vl write in detail sometime later... On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 8:38 AM, sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mahima, i was wondering how come ARR praised kalaprabu's ability even after seeing his whole product. I also remember that ARR mentioned that Kalaprabu has done the songs picturisation in par with shankar, from the reviews i dont think that is the case. everyone seems to agree that the SK songs are not picturised properly. We are disappointed not becoz it happens sometimes but it happening more often nowadays. Soundarya's Ocher studios did a bad job in Ah Aah and now in SK. They seems to have just only one pattern that the hero, heroine or other dancers will be dancing in front and there will be lot bigrise buildings behind them or something will be flying behind them. No wonder shankar used her only for the titles and some cartoon work in sivaji and not in any of the songs. Hope she does a better job in Sultan. Vithur, Everytime a failure of a movie happens where ARR is in it, we all ARR fans immediately think about his future projects of him will become big blockbusters in BO and console ourselves, but nowadays it is not happening a lot:(:(:( Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, Mahima Sengupta [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In one of his interviews I think ARR was full of praise for Kalaipulli Dhanu's son. Sometimes failures do happen so lets let it go. As for ARR doing only big banner I beg to differ. He has done ADA which is not a big banner. In our moment of disappointment I think one should not lose his/her cool.. :) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, Vithur [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Vithur [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 10:44 AM Kalaipuli Dhanu's son is an amateurish Director. Lets forgive him ... Enjoy the BGMs, and the songs... Many more Tamil Hits on the way like ROBOT, MARMAYOGI... On Sun, Sep 28, 2008 at 3:09 PM, Sathya Sundaram [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: Another flop film is added to ARR's long list of Flop films (even tho the music, BGM, ARR's efforts were excellent) in Tamil. This again shows ARR's selection of movies being bad or not good movies being given to him. We all know that Kalipuli dhanu pressurised ARR to do this film even tho we all knew that this wont click. ARR should do movies which are good, appealing to heart (irrespective of Director, producer, Budget), and not just for BIG banners, BIG Directors, BIG Producers. ARR has crossed that stage of doing movies for selective Directors. There are lot of Tamil Directors with huge abundance of talent ready to work with ARR. I second Director Ameer's statement made during Saroja Audio launch - Original Message From: murali ramakrishnan dippythejammy@ hotmail.com To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2008 11:58:47 AM Subject: RE: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii dear friends, i had a doubt from the atrting of the movie itself whether this movie will also become another e20u18 and it happened when some of my arr fans said their review immediately after the first say first show. everyone of us disappointed on movies result as anna is doing few movies and if it is not becoming a hit the songs wont reach the mass becaue of the result. it is common to all the md's. it is natural that we hope that all movies of anna should becmoe a hit but we should take anything lightly, think for a while how arranna might felt bad that his hardwork and beautiful score for the film will get reduced once the review is not good. My views on the movie sakkarakkatti 1.every fan of arr should watch this movie for his deadly re-recording (songs not to mention as we already known about the quality) 2.thought they might have used taxi song as title song,and anna changed my thought form the second bit itself,beautiful title music and a perfect score for every scenes in the first half including two english songs as bgm in the movie(vithur my friend u r having a big job in filtering the movies bgm and sending it) 3.only songs are the highlight in the second half,since there is no story how the songs will get click. 4.songs picturisation, dance in taxi song and photography are other area to be congraulated oher than music. 5.my question to Dhaanu sir,how he was very confident that the storyline and screenplay will attract the people and how he agreed for the movie? anna we are all with u and keep up ur good work,we enjoyed ur music in every scene of the movie and expecting the same in evry movie. our small reques u have the capability to do more movies but u wont
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
None of ARR 's work goes wasted Each and every piece of his BGM is a treasure. For that matter, I am still searching for films like Super Police, Gangster, Monalisa or Kabhi Na Kabhi for ripping BGMs. On Sat, Sep 27, 2008 at 10:54 AM, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far because of that. Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad, they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM. I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first show. The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their respective storylines. Can you guys please throw in some movies name that bombed at the box office even though they had beautiful music by ARR. I remember the following: Kangalal Kaithu Sei Kadhal Virus Boys (to an extent) ATM Baba Duet E20U18 En Swasa kaatre SOK Paarthale Paravasam Rhythm Tajmahal Udhaya Uyire If you see the above list, it even includes the big stalwarts like Maniratnam, Shankar, Kathir, Bharathiraja. I have mentioned only the tamil movies, there is a big list in HINDI too. Please throw in some names that matches the above category. Whenever ARR music release i am so happy and when i come to know that film bombed at the BO because of the story or screenplay, it makes me so sick. I couldnt find proper words to let out my disappointment. Thanks Sath -- regards, Vithur ARR in my Heart; His Music in my Blood;
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ ... wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far because of that. Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad, they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM. I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first show. The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their respective storylines. Can you guys please throw in some movies name that bombed at the box office even though they had beautiful music by ARR. I remember the following: Kangalal Kaithu Sei Kadhal Virus Boys (to an extent) ATM Baba Duet E20U18 En Swasa kaatre SOK Paarthale Paravasam Rhythm Tajmahal Udhaya Uyire If you see the above list, it even includes the big stalwarts like Maniratnam, Shankar, Kathir, Bharathiraja. I have mentioned only the tamil movies, there is a big list in HINDI too. Please throw in some names that matches the above category. Whenever ARR music release i am so happy and when i come to know that film bombed at the BO because of the story or screenplay, it makes me so sick. I couldnt find proper words to let out my disappointment. Thanks Sath
Re: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
My belief is that ...ARR fans or not if one is musically inclined he/she will be able to catch the waft of music whether the movie is a hit or bombs in the box office. Arr's music is such that it can attract all music lovers. :) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: sath.murthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 12:11 AM Vithur / Mahima i understand your point, when i mentioned that ARR's hard work wasted i meant that it got wasted by the director kalaprabu or other directors, by not using it properly. i didnt mean anyother way. Hope Vithur understand my view too. If the dir used it, then he would have had a great feature and got films from other producers too. now he has to rely on his Dad Dhanu again. Even Uyire and SOK won filmfare awards to ARR, in future those movies will always be remembered as one of those flop movies. Whenever the movie with ARR releases, i eagerly wait for the first review of the movie and i will go directly to the last part (conclusion) or the rating, and when i find its gonna bomb or fail at BO, i feel totally disappointed and i feel this been happening a lot lately with ARR related movies. As fans of ARR we will always treasure his songs and BGM's all our life, but the other normal people (Non ARR fans) will remember the songs only if the movies becomes a hit or blocbuster. Sath. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mahima Sengupta mahiya_is_mind_ [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking! --- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: rivjot [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM Sath, I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should have been. In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK, Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there, people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance. Consequently, I would not say ARR's hard work is wasted if movie doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got supporters/fans like you guys :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, sath.murthy sath.murthy@ ... wrote: This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it. ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far because of that. Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad, they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM. I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first show. The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their respective storylines. Can you guys please throw in some movies name that bombed at the box office even though they had beautiful music by ARR. I remember the following: Kangalal Kaithu Sei Kadhal Virus Boys (to an extent) ATM Baba Duet E20U18 En Swasa kaatre SOK Paarthale Paravasam Rhythm Tajmahal Udhaya Uyire If you see the above list, it even includes the big stalwarts like Maniratnam, Shankar, Kathir, Bharathiraja. I have mentioned only the tamil movies, there is a big list in HINDI too. Please throw in some names that matches the above category. Whenever ARR music release i am so happy and when i come to know that film bombed at the BO because of the story or screenplay, it makes me so sick. I couldnt find proper words to let out my disappointment. Thanks Sath
