[Assam] If We Do the Math
The math is incorrect -- 20% of 28,054 crore CANNOT BE 56,108 crore. That is 200% of 28,054 crore. About your question -- You should ask to those who publish the corruption index -- like Nicholas Charron, The University of Gothenburg, Sweden OR Transparency International. They might want to change their method based on your suggestion. *** The following from ToI: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/events-tournaments/commonwealth-games/top-stories/Rs-28054-crore-spent-on-Commonwealth-Games-Reddy/articleshow/6282261.cms Now if we do the math, assuming ONLY 20/80 ( as opposed to the usual 60/40, stolen/used ratio), then 20% of Rs. 280,540,000,000 is Rs. 56,108 crores, likely stolen. If it is only 10/90, even then it would be a staggering Rs. 28,054 crores. Now then, if we compare the total ANNUAL corruption loss in Assam and the total ONE TIME loss in the Corruptwealth Games ( you heard it here first) undertaken by the Center, it should tell us where the WORST corruption takes place. Or would it? cm Rs 28,054 crore spent on Commonwealth Games: Reddy PTI, Aug 9, 2010, 05.57pm IST NEW DELHI: Seeking cooperation from all quarters for making the Commonwealth Games a success, Urban Development Minister S Jaipal Reddy on Monday said a total of Rs 28,054 crore have been spent on the games out of which Rs 16,560 crore was given to the Delhi Government for upgrading the capital infrastructure and building of various stadia. Making an intervention during a debate in the Lok Sabha on the Commonwealth Games, Reddy said of the total of money given to the Delhi Government, only Rs 670 crore has been spent directly on the games -- on building stadia. "The rest of the money has been spent on infrastructure development of the capital, which is not directly linked to the games," he said. Giving a break-up of the money spent, the minister said, the Delhi Government has spent on various projects which includes Rs 650 crore for street scraping, Rs 900 crore for development bus depots, Rs 3,000 crore for extension of Metro, Rs 18,000 crore for augmenting DTC bus services and Rs 3,700 crore on flyovers and bridges. Of the Rs 11,494 crore spent by the centre, Rs 2.934 crore was spent on sports infrastructure and Rs 678 crore on training of teams, while Rs 182 crore has been given to MTNL, Rs 827.85 crore to the Ministry of Urban Development, Rs 487.57 to Information and Broadcasting Ministry and Rs 747 crore to Health Ministry. Reddy said the government has also given Rs 2,394 crore as loan to the organising committee, which is to be returned by them after the games. Defending the huge amount of money spent, he said most of the money has been spent of infrastructure development which will remain as the country's legacy long after the games are over. "If you furnish and paint your house before your daughter's wedding, then the money spent on that cannot be said to be part of the dowry," he said. Appealing to all parties to come together and make the games a success, he said, "All of us, cutting across party lines, should rise to make the games successful and spectacular." Asserting that Government will ensure that the corrupt are pursued to the "end of the earth", Reddy said, "we all know that the CVC and other constitutional bodies do their job, but if every primary observation is blown up to a scam, then we cannot function". "I don't say that corruption has not taken place. No one can say that. All irregularities will be inquired into exhaustively," he said. "I therefore say with confidence that we will be staging the best Commonwealth Games in history. Some people took the position that a country like India, which has a lot of poverty, should not have hosted the Commonwealth Games," the minister said, adding that though he begged to differ he respected their ideological position. "But with only a month left, this should not be raised," he said. Replying to BJP member Kirti Azad comparing him with Mahabharata epic character "Bhishm Pitamaha", Reddy said as of now he would like to be focused like Arjun. Reassuring the House that the projects will be ready before the games, he said, "the event can be organised even now". The Delhi Government has also spent Rs 400 crore on parking facilities, Rs 200 crore on communications and IT and Rs 2,000 crore on power plants, he said. Reddy said most of the projects will be completed by August 31, barring the Barapullah Nallah project which would be over only by September. ___ assam mailing list assam@assamnet.org http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
[Assam] If We Do the Math/ From ToI
The following from ToI: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/events-tournaments/commonwealth-games/top-stories/Rs-28054-crore-spent-on-Commonwealth-Games-Reddy/articleshow/6282261.cms Now if we do the math, assuming ONLY 20/80 ( as opposed to the usual 60/40, stolen/used ratio), then 20% of Rs. 280,540,000,000 is Rs. 56,108 crores, likely stolen. If it is only 10/90, even then it would be a staggering Rs. 28,054 crores. Now then, if we compare the total ANNUAL corruption loss in Assam and the total ONE TIME loss in the Corruptwealth Games ( you heard it here first) undertaken by the Center, it should tell us where the WORST corruption takes place. Or would it? cm Rs 28,054 crore spent on Commonwealth Games: Reddy PTI, Aug 9, 2010, 05.57pm IST NEW DELHI: Seeking cooperation from all quarters for making the Commonwealth Games a success, Urban Development Minister S Jaipal Reddy on Monday said a total of Rs 28,054 crore have been spent on the games out of which Rs 16,560 crore was given to the Delhi Government for upgrading the capital infrastructure and building of various stadia. Making an intervention during a debate in the Lok Sabha on the Commonwealth Games, Reddy said of the total of money given to the Delhi Government, only Rs 670 crore has been spent directly on the games -- on building stadia. "The rest of the money has been spent on infrastructure development of the capital, which is not directly linked to the games," he said. Giving a break-up of the money spent, the minister said, the Delhi Government has spent on various projects which includes Rs 650 crore for street scraping, Rs 900 crore for development bus depots, Rs 3,000 crore for extension of Metro, Rs 18,000 crore for augmenting DTC bus services and Rs 3,700 crore on flyovers and bridges. Of the Rs 11,494 crore spent by the centre, Rs 2.934 crore was spent on sports infrastructure and Rs 678 crore on training of teams, while Rs 182 crore has been given to MTNL, Rs 827.85 crore to the Ministry of Urban Development, Rs 487.57 to Information and Broadcasting Ministry and Rs 747 crore to Health Ministry. Reddy said the government has also given Rs 2,394 crore as loan to the organising committee, which is to be returned by them after the games. Defending the huge amount of money spent, he said most of the money has been spent of infrastructure development which will remain as the country's legacy long after the games are over. "If you furnish and paint your house before your daughter's wedding, then the money spent on that cannot be said to be part of the dowry," he said. Appealing to all parties to come together and make the games a success, he said, "All of us, cutting across party lines, should rise to make the games successful and spectacular." Asserting that Government will ensure that the corrupt are pursued to the "end of the earth", Reddy said, "we all know that the CVC and other constitutional bodies do their job, but if every primary observation is blown up to a scam, then we cannot function". "I don't say that corruption has not taken place. No one can say that. All irregularities will be inquired into exhaustively," he said. "I therefore say with confidence that we will be staging the best Commonwealth Games in history. Some people took the position that a country like India, which has a lot of poverty, should not have hosted the Commonwealth Games," the minister said, adding that though he begged to differ he respected their ideological position. "But with only a month left, this should not be raised," he said. Replying to BJP member Kirti Azad comparing him with Mahabharata epic character "Bhishm Pitamaha", Reddy said as of now he would like to be focused like Arjun. Reassuring the House that the projects will be ready before the games, he said, "the event can be organised even now". The Delhi Government has also spent Rs 400 crore on parking facilities, Rs 200 crore on communications and IT and Rs 2,000 crore on power plants, he said. Reddy said most of the projects will be completed by August 31, barring the Barapullah Nallah project which would be over only by September. Read more: Rs 28,054 crore spent on Commonwealth Games: Reddy - Top Stories - Commonwealth Games - Events & Tournaments - Sports - The Times of India http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/events-tournaments/commonwealth-games/top-stories/Rs-28054-crore-spent-on-Commonwealth-Games-Reddy/articleshow/6282261.cms#ixzz0w7knBieD ___ assam mailing list assam@assamnet.org http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
