[Assam] ULFA reply to Kamal Deka

2007-10-15 Thread ulfa_ 1979April7
Hounorable Netters,
   
  By suggesting that the ULFA members are cave dwellers, Dr. Kamal Deka seems 
to have taken the opportunity to highlight  that he lives in Texas. His wording 
in the relevant mail is speaking that loud enough. 
  There is no doubt that he has the required qualification to work abroad and 
earning a lot of money. 
  As ULFA members home is Asom rather than Texas or New York, their lives are 
akin to cave dwellers as perceived by Kamal Deka. Therefore, he thinks that 
these cave dwellers are unable to understand and appreciate what is Sovereign 
independence. Consequently there is no point of having a plebiscite to end the 
Asom-India conflict peacefully. Asking for a plebiscite in his eyes is likened 
to a child demanding the moon! Hence, he has not offered any definitive idea 
for a solution. We do not think that he has an answer how to bring in the 
resolution to the conflict. But we would like to say that by bringing in the 
idea of autonomy he is skillfully diverting the focus from a true solution to a 
non-solution. During the freedom struggle against the imperialist British 
colonialists such educated class of people tried to derail the rise ups. He is 
an incarnation with the same mentality. 
  Members and visitors to the AssamNet must have noticed his disdain by 
commenting the ULFA as ‘Cave dwellers’ and in contrast raising his profile as 
an educated successful person. But he has not indicated of his contribution, if 
any, in resolving the national problem of Asom. Apart from making his life in 
America, if he has done anything for Asom and her people we do not know. It is 
not clear if he understands his servitude to America by offering his brain and 
skill for riches.   
   
  In our opinion he is a so-called educated person without social and political 
insight, wanting to be an arm-chair revolutionary. Dr. Deka perhaps has never 
read the poem ‘Soha aru pondit, r Sohoror odurot asil ejon soha nam tar jurmon 
Bara’.
   
  Despite his expressed unhelpful views, we would urge him to get involve 
within his limitations for the emancipation of the oppressed and exploited 
majority of Asom
  Rubi Bhuyan
   
  Central publicity member,ULFA
   
  Sat, 13 Oct 2007 21:00:41 -0500
  kamal deka [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
  assam@assamnet.org
   
  Rubi Bhuyan and the people of his/her ilk must be living in a cave,totally 
detached from the ground realities of Assam.They are merely prodding at the 
body of ' sovereignty' without knowing what it is all about---like children at 
a new toy in the market showroom.Rubi Bhuyan's point of view expressed in the 
Assam Net is of no consequence as far as I am concerned.
   
   
   
  I respectfully disagree with Mr.Nayanjyoti Medhi's opinion,voiced in this 
forum in regard to holding a plebiscite in Assam focusing solely on the 
sovereignty issue as demanded by the ULFA,who are itching to break-up a 
60-year-old kaleidoscopic federation.Why do we have to hold a 
referendum,buckling under the pressure of an outfit that has been outlawed by 
the Government ? Is Assam an exclusive preserve of the ULFA ? The right to 
self-determination,if allowed in Assam,would then be reduced to a series of 
voting exorcises,conducted every 10 years or so in order to meet the demand of 
the new generation,at whose whim the border of a country could be defined and 
redefined.It will not be very difficult to imagine the chaos,it would create in 
a polyglot,multi-ethnic and multi-religious state as Assam's,if such recipe 
were to be applied state-wide as a solution.
   
  Kamal J Deka
sugarland,Texas.


   
-
Nervous about who has your email address? Yahoo! Mail can help you win the war 
against spam.___
assam mailing list
assam@assamnet.org
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org


Re: [Assam] ULFA reply to Kamal Deka

2007-10-15 Thread kamal deka
It would have been complete tomfoolery on my part if I had expected a
meaningful reply from the ' mouth organ ' of an outlawed organisation who
even doesn't know  how to differentiate between figurative language and
literal meaning ( living in cave ).Anyone even with a modicum of brain would
understand that.

Yes,I live in Texas.That does not mean that I should not be allowed to care
for Assam---a state,I hold so dear. What constructive works have you all
done save carrying out gory pogrom in order to mow down innocent unarmed
civilians including children and women ? But then,I should not expect
anything good coming out of an outfit, whose credo has been to rule with
guns and rods,shutting out dissents by death.

KJD


On 10/15/07, ulfa_ 1979April7 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 Hounorable Netters,structive

 By suggesting that the ULFA members are cave dwellers, Dr. Kamal Deka
 seems to have taken the opportunity to highlight  that he lives in Texas.
 His wording in the relevant mail is speaking that loud enough.
 There is no doubt that he has the required qualification to work abroad
 and earning a lot of money.
 As ULFA members home is Asom rather than Texas or New York, their lives
 are akin to cave dwellers as perceived by Kamal Deka. Therefore, he thinks
 that these cave dwellers are unable to understand and appreciate what is
 Sovereign independence. Consequently there is no point of having a
 plebiscite to end the Asom-India conflict peacefully. Asking for a
 plebiscite in his eyes is likened to a child demanding the moon! Hence, he
 has not offered any definitive idea for a solution. We do not think that he
 has an answer how to bring in the resolution to the conflict. But we would
 like to say that by bringing in the idea of autonomy he is skillfully
 diverting the focus from a true solution to a non-solution. During the
 freedom struggle against the imperialist British colonialists such educated
 class of people tried to derail the rise ups. He is an incarnation with the
 same mentality.
 Members and visitors to the AssamNet must have noticed his disdain by
 commenting the ULFA as 'Cave dwellers' and in contrast raising his profile
 as an educated successful person. But he has not indicated of his
 contribution, if any, in resolving the national problem of Asom. Apart from
 making his life in America, if he has done anything for Asom and her
 people we do not know. It is not clear if he understands his servitude to
 America by offering his brain and skill for riches.

 In our opinion he is a so-called educated person without social and
 political insight, wanting to be an arm-chair revolutionary. Dr. Deka
 perhaps has never read the poem 'Soha aru pondit, r Sohoror odurot asil ejon
 soha nam tar jurmon Bara'.

 Despite his expressed unhelpful views, we would urge him to get involve
 within his limitations for the emancipation of the oppressed and exploited
 majority of Asom
 Rubi Bhuyan

 Central publicity member,ULFA

 Sat, 13 Oct 2007 21:00:41 -0500
 kamal deka [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 assam@assamnet.org

 Rubi Bhuyan and the people of his/her ilk must be living in a
 cave,totally detached from the ground realities of Assam.They are merely
 prodding at the body of ' *sovereignty'* without knowing what it is all
 about---like children at a new toy in the market showroom.Rubi Bhuyan's
 point of view expressed in the Assam Net is of no consequence as far as I am
 concerned.



 I respectfully disagree with Mr.Nayanjyoti Medhi's opinion,voiced in this
 forum in regard to holding a plebiscite in Assam focusing solely on the
 sovereignty issue as demanded by the ULFA,who are itching to break-up a
 60-year-old kaleidoscopic federation.Why do we have to hold a
 referendum,buckling under the pressure of an outfit that has been outlawed
 by the Government ? Is Assam an exclusive preserve of the ULFA ? The right
 to self-determination,if allowed in Assam,would then be reduced to a series
 of voting exorcises,conducted every 10 years or so in order to meet the
 demand of the new generation,at whose whim the border of a country could be
 defined and redefined.It will not be very difficult to imagine the
 chaos,it would create in a polyglot,multi-ethnic and multi-religious state
 as Assam's,if such recipe were to be applied state-wide as a solution.

 Kamal J Deka
 sugarland,Texas.

  --
 Nervous about who has your email address? Yahoo! 
 Mailhttp://us.rd.yahoo.com/mailuk/taglines/gmail/war_spam/*http://us.rd.yahoo.com/evt=48525/*http://uk.docs.yahoo.com/mail/addressguard2.htmlcan
  help you win the war against spam.


___
assam mailing list
assam@assamnet.org
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org