RE: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0
Unfortunately I don't think my ATA falls into any of these... We have an ATA made by Innomedia MTA-3328R -- it acts like a standard ATA but with MGCP / NCS 1.0... I was thinking that if I could sniff the connection to the gatekeeper - I could write a channel to support this? _ From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Michael Bielicki Sent: Fri 5/20/2005 7:34 PM To: asterisk-users@lists.digium.com Subject: Re: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0 Check this here: http://asterisk.urtho.net/tiki-index.php <http://asterisk.urtho.net/tiki-index.php> On 5/20/05, Duane Cox <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Right, your ATA (cable modem?) is using the NCS 1.0 profile of MGCP. > Asterisk does not currently support the NCS profile from cable labs. > > It would be very nice to see someday, as well as backwards support for MGCP 0.1 > > Duane Cox > > - Original Message - > From: "Huddleston, Robert" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: "'Asterisk Users Mailing List - Non-Commercial Discussion'" > Sent: Friday, May 20, 2005 2:52 PM > Subject: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0 > > > > I'm trying to use a 4 port ATA that was designed for use with MGCP 1.0 / NCS > > 1.0 -- is the channel_mgcp compat with NCS -- anything I can do to make it > > compat?? This is what happens - below > > > > *CLI> mgcp reload > > Reloading MGCP > > == Parsing '/etc/asterisk/mgcp.conf': Found > > > > Use EXIT or QUIT to exit the asterisk console > > == MGCP Listening on 10.1.22.39:2427 > > == Using TOS bits 0 > > mgcp show endpoints > > Gateway '001099008521' at 10.1.22.81 (Static) > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > > *CLI> mgcp > > audit debug no reload show > > *CLI> mgcp audit > > No such command 'mgcp audit' (type 'help' for help) > > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > > Usage: mgcp audit endpoint > >Lists the capabilities of an endpoint in the MGCP (Media Gateway > > Control Protocol) subsystem. > >mgcp debug MUST be on to see the results of this command. > > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint 1 > ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint aaln/1 > ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > > aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Posting Request: > > AUEP 9 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > F: A > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > MGCP read: > > 528 9 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '9', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > MGCP read: > > RSIP 1075 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 > > RM: disconnected > > RD: 338 > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1075', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', > > Version: 'MGCP 1.0' > > 3 headers, 0 lines > > Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Transmitting: > > 200 1075 OK > > > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: > > inactive > > Posting Request: > > RQNT 10 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > X: 3faf4f29 > > R: L/hd(N) > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Posting Request: > > AUEP 11 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > F: A > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > MGCP read: > > 528 10 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '10', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > MGCP read: > > 528 11 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '11', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 11. Ignoring... > > MGCP read: > > RSIP 1076 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0
Re: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0
Check this here: http://asterisk.urtho.net/tiki-index.php On 5/20/05, Duane Cox <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Right, your ATA (cable modem?) is using the NCS 1.0 profile of MGCP. > Asterisk does not currently support the NCS profile from cable labs. > > It would be very nice to see someday, as well as backwards support for MGCP > 0.1 > > Duane Cox > > - Original Message - > From: "Huddleston, Robert" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: "'Asterisk Users Mailing List - Non-Commercial Discussion'" > > Sent: Friday, May 20, 2005 2:52 PM > Subject: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0 > > > > I'm trying to use a 4 port ATA that was designed for use with MGCP 1.0 / NCS > > 1.0 -- is the channel_mgcp compat with NCS -- anything I can do to make it > > compat?? This is what happens - below > > > > *CLI> mgcp reload > > Reloading MGCP > > == Parsing '/etc/asterisk/mgcp.conf': Found > > > > Use EXIT or QUIT to exit the asterisk console > > == MGCP Listening on 10.1.22.39:2427 > > == Using TOS bits 0 > > mgcp show endpoints > > Gateway '001099008521' at 10.1.22.81 (Static) > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > > *CLI> mgcp > > audit debug no reload show > > *CLI> mgcp audit > > No such command 'mgcp audit' (type 'help' for help) > > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > > Usage: mgcp audit endpoint > >Lists the capabilities of an endpoint in the MGCP (Media Gateway > > Control Protocol) subsystem. > >mgcp debug MUST be on to see the results of this command. > > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint 1 > ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint aaln/1 > ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > > aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Posting Request: > > AUEP 9 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > F: A > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > MGCP read: > > 528 9 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '9', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > MGCP read: > > RSIP 1075 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 > > RM: disconnected > > RD: 338 > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1075', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', > > Version: 'MGCP 1.0' > > 3 headers, 0 lines > > Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Transmitting: > > 200 1075 OK > > > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: > > inactive > > Posting Request: > > RQNT 10 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > X: 3faf4f29 > > R: L/hd(N) > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Posting Request: > > AUEP 11 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > > F: A > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > MGCP read: > > 528 10 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '10', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > MGCP read: > > 528 11 Incompatible Protocol Version > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: '528', Identifier: '11', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > > Version' > > 1 headers, 0 lines > > -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 11. Ignoring... > > MGCP read: > > RSIP 1076 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 > > RM: disconnected > > RD: 354 > > > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > > Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1076', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', > > Version: 'MGCP 1.0' > > 3 headers, 0 lines > > Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Transmitting: > > 200 1076 OK > > > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > > -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: > > inactive > > Postin
Re: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0
Right, your ATA (cable modem?) is using the NCS 1.0 profile of MGCP. Asterisk does not currently support the NCS profile from cable labs. It would be very nice to see someday, as well as backwards support for MGCP 0.1 Duane Cox - Original Message - From: "Huddleston, Robert" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "'Asterisk Users Mailing List - Non-Commercial Discussion'" Sent: Friday, May 20, 2005 2:52 PM Subject: [Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0 > I'm trying to use a 4 port ATA that was designed for use with MGCP 1.0 / NCS > 1.0 -- is the channel_mgcp compat with NCS -- anything I can do to make it > compat?? This is what happens - below > > *CLI> mgcp reload > Reloading MGCP > == Parsing '/etc/asterisk/mgcp.conf': Found > > Use EXIT or QUIT to exit the asterisk console > == MGCP Listening on 10.1.22.39:2427 > == Using TOS bits 0 > mgcp show endpoints > Gateway '001099008521' at 10.1.22.81 (Static) >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle >-- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle > *CLI> mgcp > audit debug no reload show > *CLI> mgcp audit > No such command 'mgcp audit' (type 'help' for help) > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > Usage: mgcp audit endpoint >Lists the capabilities of an endpoint in the MGCP (Media Gateway > Control Protocol) subsystem. >mgcp debug MUST be on to see the results of this command. > *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint 1 ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint aaln/1 ><< Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint > aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Posting Request: > AUEP 9 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > F: A > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > MGCP read: > 528 9 Incompatible Protocol Version > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: '528', Identifier: '9', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > Version' > 1 headers, 0 lines > MGCP read: > RSIP 1075 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 > RM: disconnected > RD: 338 > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1075', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', > Version: 'MGCP 1.0' > 3 headers, 0 lines > Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Transmitting: > 200 1075 OK > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: > inactive > Posting Request: > RQNT 10 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > X: 3faf4f29 > R: L/hd(N) > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > Posting Request: > AUEP 11 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > F: A > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > MGCP read: > 528 10 Incompatible Protocol Version > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: '528', Identifier: '10', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > Version' > 1 headers, 0 lines > MGCP read: > 528 11 Incompatible Protocol Version > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: '528', Identifier: '11', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > Version' > 1 headers, 0 lines > -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 11. Ignoring... > MGCP read: > RSIP 1076 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 > RM: disconnected > RD: 354 > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1076', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', > Version: 'MGCP 1.0' > 3 headers, 0 lines > Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Transmitting: > 200 1076 OK > > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: > inactive > Posting Request: > RQNT 12 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > X: 696be0ea > R: L/hd(N) > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > Posting Request: > AUEP 13 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 > F: A > to 10.1.22.81:2427 > MGCP read: > 528 12 Incompatible Protocol Version > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: '528', Identifier: '12', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > Version' > 1 headers, 0 lines > MGCP read: > 528 13 Incompatible Protocol Version > > from 10.1.22.81:2427 > Verb: '528', Identifier: '13', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol > Version' > 1 headers, 0 lines > -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 13. Ignoring... > ___ > Asterisk-Users mailing list > Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com > http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users > To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: >http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users > ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
[Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0
I'm trying to use a 4 port ATA that was designed for use with MGCP 1.0 / NCS 1.0 -- is the channel_mgcp compat with NCS -- anything I can do to make it compat?? This is what happens - below *CLI> mgcp reload Reloading MGCP == Parsing '/etc/asterisk/mgcp.conf': Found Use EXIT or QUIT to exit the asterisk console == MGCP Listening on 10.1.22.39:2427 == Using TOS bits 0 mgcp show endpoints Gateway '001099008521' at 10.1.22.81 (Static) -- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle -- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle -- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle -- 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in 'default' is idle *CLI> mgcp audit debug no reload show *CLI> mgcp audit No such command 'mgcp audit' (type 'help' for help) *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint Usage: mgcp audit endpoint Lists the capabilities of an endpoint in the MGCP (Media Gateway Control Protocol) subsystem. mgcp debug MUST be on to see the results of this command. *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint 1 << Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint aaln/1 << Could not find endpoint >> *CLI> mgcp audit endpoint aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] Posting Request: AUEP 9 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 F: A to 10.1.22.81:2427 MGCP read: 528 9 Incompatible Protocol Version from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: '528', Identifier: '9', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol Version' 1 headers, 0 lines MGCP read: RSIP 1075 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 RM: disconnected RD: 338 from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1075', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', Version: 'MGCP 1.0' 3 headers, 0 lines Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] Transmitting: 200 1075 OK to 10.1.22.81:2427 -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: inactive Posting Request: RQNT 10 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 X: 3faf4f29 R: L/hd(N) to 10.1.22.81:2427 Posting Request: AUEP 11 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 F: A to 10.1.22.81:2427 MGCP read: 528 10 Incompatible Protocol Version from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: '528', Identifier: '10', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol Version' 1 headers, 0 lines MGCP read: 528 11 Incompatible Protocol Version from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: '528', Identifier: '11', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol Version' 1 headers, 0 lines -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 11. Ignoring... MGCP read: RSIP 1076 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 RM: disconnected RD: 354 from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: 'RSIP', Identifier: '1076', Endpoint: 'aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED]', Version: 'MGCP 1.0' 3 headers, 0 lines Handling request 'RSIP' on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] -- Resetting interface aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] Transmitting: 200 1076 OK to 10.1.22.81:2427 -- MGCP Asked to indicate tone: on aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] in cxmode: inactive Posting Request: RQNT 12 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 X: 696be0ea R: L/hd(N) to 10.1.22.81:2427 Posting Request: AUEP 13 aaln/[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0 F: A to 10.1.22.81:2427 MGCP read: 528 12 Incompatible Protocol Version from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: '528', Identifier: '12', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol Version' 1 headers, 0 lines MGCP read: 528 13 Incompatible Protocol Version from 10.1.22.81:2427 Verb: '528', Identifier: '13', Endpoint: 'Incompatible', Version: 'Protocol Version' 1 headers, 0 lines -- No command found on [001099008521] for transaction 13. Ignoring... ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
[Asterisk-Users] MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0 on a motorola SBV4200
Hello all, Anyone have any experience using the Motorola SBV4200 cable modem with *. At my first try the CM was complaining about Incorrect Version. The problem was that the chan_mgcp in * is version MGCP 1.0 and the endpoint expects MGCP 1.0 NCS 1.0. Now from what I understand this NCS 1.0 is a packetcable extension of the MGCP protocol and is somewhat different. Now my question is wether anyone knows of a channel driver fully compatible with this packetcable extension ( at first glance the * -s chan_mgcp is not the best for this ) or any ideea what the differences are between the two protocols ? Kiss Karoly ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
