[Asterisk-Users] ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls with MGCP RSIP

2005-05-16 Thread Ben Dugdale
I've got a ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls.  My packet
capture indicates that the phone may be trying to renew its registration
with *, but reports Restart Method of Disconnected (frame 2), then *
seems to take that as a sign that it has lost the connection and closes
things down.  The phone, meanwhile, seems to think it can continue the
conversation until a few ICMP port unreachable packets set it straight.

I am able to duplicate this on a fairly regular basis and it appears
that the call is always dropped similarly.  Everything is groovy until
the first MGCP RSIP during a call.  The phone seems to send these MGCP
RSIPs (perhaps on a schedule, looks like every 120 seconds) even when
there is no call taking place.

Is my diagnosis correct?  What can I do about it?

...Normal RTP, then one final RTP packet and the following...

  1   0.00  192.168.0.5 5004 192.168.1.137 5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
  2   0.007970 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP RSIP 14831
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  3   0.008096  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP 200 14831 OK
  4   0.008150  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 7
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  5   0.008186  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP AUEP 8
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  6   0.008267  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP DLCX 9
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  7   0.009226  192.168.0.5 4569 192.168.1.135 4569 IAX2 IAX, source
call# 2, timestamp 61056ms HANGUP
  8   0.012188 192.168.1.135 4569 192.168.0.5  4569 IAX2 IAX, source
call# 10281, timestamp 61056ms ACK
  9   0.015216 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 10   0.015265  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 11   0.029923 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 7 OK
 12   0.030090  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 10
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
 13   0.035268 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 14   0.035306  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 15   0.050434 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 8 OK
 16   0.055251 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 17   0.055282  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 18   0.077638 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 250 9
Connection was deleted
 19   0.100808 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 10 OK

rtp.conf:

[general]
rtpstart=5004
rtpend=5005

mgcp.conf:

[general]
port = 2727
bindaddr = 0.0.0.0

[192.168.1.137]
host= 192.168.1.137
context = home
callerid= ShoreTel 4368
dtmfmode= inband
accountcode = 1000
amaflags= billing
callwaiting = no
callreturn  = no
cancallforward  = no
canreinvite = no
transfer= no
line = SHOR_001049007E83

-- 
Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]




mgcp.dmp
Description: Binary data
___
Asterisk-Users mailing list
Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
   http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users

Re: [Asterisk-Users] ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls with MGCP RSIP

2005-05-16 Thread Duane Cox
RSIP = Restart in Progress.  This message is sent from and endpoint to the 
call-agent when the line is being disabled/reenabled,
and at startup.

I would think that * should tear down any active calls that is going on when a 
RSIP comes in, so from what I am reading this is
correct.  The bigger question is, why is your phone sending RSIP during a call? 
 Maybe your phone isn't 100% setup yet, but enough
to get calls up.

See if you can capture an mgcp debug from the * CLI.

Duane


- Original Message - 
From: Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: asterisk-users@lists.digium.com
Sent: Monday, May 16, 2005 12:39 PM
Subject: [Asterisk-Users] ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls with MGCP RSIP


 I've got a ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls.  My packet
 capture indicates that the phone may be trying to renew its registration
 with *, but reports Restart Method of Disconnected (frame 2), then *
 seems to take that as a sign that it has lost the connection and closes
 things down.  The phone, meanwhile, seems to think it can continue the
 conversation until a few ICMP port unreachable packets set it straight.

 I am able to duplicate this on a fairly regular basis and it appears
 that the call is always dropped similarly.  Everything is groovy until
 the first MGCP RSIP during a call.  The phone seems to send these MGCP
 RSIPs (perhaps on a schedule, looks like every 120 seconds) even when
 there is no call taking place.

 Is my diagnosis correct?  What can I do about it?

 ...Normal RTP, then one final RTP packet and the following...

   1   0.00  192.168.0.5 5004 192.168.1.137 5004 UDP Source port:
 5004  Destination port: 5004
   2   0.007970 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP RSIP 14831
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
   3   0.008096  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP 200 14831 OK
   4   0.008150  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 7
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
   5   0.008186  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP AUEP 8
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
   6   0.008267  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP DLCX 9
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
   7   0.009226  192.168.0.5 4569 192.168.1.135 4569 IAX2 IAX, source
 call# 2, timestamp 61056ms HANGUP
   8   0.012188 192.168.1.135 4569 192.168.0.5  4569 IAX2 IAX, source
 call# 10281, timestamp 61056ms ACK
   9   0.015216 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
 5004  Destination port: 5004
  10   0.015265  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
 (Port unreachable)
  11   0.029923 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 7 OK
  12   0.030090  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 10
 [EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  13   0.035268 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
 5004  Destination port: 5004
  14   0.035306  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
 (Port unreachable)
  15   0.050434 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 8 OK
  16   0.055251 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
 5004  Destination port: 5004
  17   0.055282  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
 (Port unreachable)
  18   0.077638 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 250 9
 Connection was deleted
  19   0.100808 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 10 OK

 rtp.conf:

 [general]
 rtpstart=5004
 rtpend=5005

 mgcp.conf:

 [general]
 port = 2727
 bindaddr = 0.0.0.0

 [192.168.1.137]
 host= 192.168.1.137
 context = home
 callerid= ShoreTel 4368
 dtmfmode= inband
 accountcode = 1000
 amaflags= billing
 callwaiting = no
 callreturn  = no
 cancallforward  = no
 canreinvite = no
 transfer= no
 line = SHOR_001049007E83

 -- 
 Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]








 ___
 Asterisk-Users mailing list
 Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
 http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
 To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users

___
Asterisk-Users mailing list
Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
   http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users


Re: [Asterisk-Users] ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls with MGCP RSIP

2005-05-16 Thread Ben Dugdale
,
 and at startup.
 
 I would think that * should tear down any active calls that is going on when 
 a RSIP comes in, so from what I am reading this is
 correct.  The bigger question is, why is your phone sending RSIP during a 
 call?  Maybe your phone isn't 100% setup yet, but enough
 to get calls up.
 
 See if you can capture an mgcp debug from the * CLI.
 
 Duane
 
 
 - Original Message - 
 From: Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 To: asterisk-users@lists.digium.com
 Sent: Monday, May 16, 2005 12:39 PM
 Subject: [Asterisk-Users] ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls with MGCP RSIP
 
 
 
I've got a ShoreTel 210 MGCP phone drops calls.  My packet
capture indicates that the phone may be trying to renew its registration
with *, but reports Restart Method of Disconnected (frame 2), then *
seems to take that as a sign that it has lost the connection and closes
things down.  The phone, meanwhile, seems to think it can continue the
conversation until a few ICMP port unreachable packets set it straight.

I am able to duplicate this on a fairly regular basis and it appears
that the call is always dropped similarly.  Everything is groovy until
the first MGCP RSIP during a call.  The phone seems to send these MGCP
RSIPs (perhaps on a schedule, looks like every 120 seconds) even when
there is no call taking place.

Is my diagnosis correct?  What can I do about it?

...Normal RTP, then one final RTP packet and the following...

  1   0.00  192.168.0.5 5004 192.168.1.137 5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
  2   0.007970 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP RSIP 14831
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  3   0.008096  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP 200 14831 OK
  4   0.008150  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 7
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  5   0.008186  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP AUEP 8
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  6   0.008267  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP DLCX 9
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
  7   0.009226  192.168.0.5 4569 192.168.1.135 4569 IAX2 IAX, source
call# 2, timestamp 61056ms HANGUP
  8   0.012188 192.168.1.135 4569 192.168.0.5  4569 IAX2 IAX, source
call# 10281, timestamp 61056ms ACK
  9   0.015216 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 10   0.015265  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 11   0.029923 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 7 OK
 12   0.030090  192.168.0.5 2727 192.168.1.137 2427 MGCP RQNT 10
[EMAIL PROTECTED] MGCP 1.0
 13   0.035268 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 14   0.035306  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 15   0.050434 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 8 OK
 16   0.055251 192.168.1.137 5004 192.168.0.5  5004 UDP Source port:
5004  Destination port: 5004
 17   0.055282  192.168.0.5  192.168.1.137  ICMP Destination unreachable
(Port unreachable)
 18   0.077638 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 250 9
Connection was deleted
 19   0.100808 192.168.1.137 2427 192.168.0.5  2727 MGCP 200 10 OK

rtp.conf:

[general]
rtpstart=5004
rtpend=5005

mgcp.conf:

[general]
port = 2727
bindaddr = 0.0.0.0

[192.168.1.137]
host= 192.168.1.137
context = home
callerid= ShoreTel 4368
dtmfmode= inband
accountcode = 1000
amaflags= billing
callwaiting = no
callreturn  = no
cancallforward  = no
canreinvite = no
transfer= no
line = SHOR_001049007E83

-- 
Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]



 
 
 
 
 
 
___
Asterisk-Users mailing list
Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
   http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
 
 
 ___
 Asterisk-Users mailing list
 Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
 http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
 To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
 [Scanned for viruses]
 
 [Scanned for viruses]
 
 

-- 
Ben Dugdale [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Network Administrator
Apache County Schools Business Consortium www.acsbc.net
Apache County Arizona www.co.apache.az.us
(928) 337-7507
___
Asterisk-Users mailing list
Asterisk-Users@lists.digium.com
http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
   http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users