I too find that this thread is interesting and agree with most of what has been said
about breeding and guarantees. When I sell a pup, I try not to make it sound like a
good deal in that if the pup turns up dysplastic requiring surgery or euthanasia the
pup price will be refunded in full. I go on further and let them know that while it
may sound like a great deal, the price of the pup is only approximately 1/2 the price
of the surgery. I also explain that I would be happy to take the pup back, but by that
time the family is usually too attached to let them go, but I let them know it is an
option should they choose it.
I do have a comment on clearances though..one that can tend to get different opinions.
What about Grade 1 elbows? I think that this clearance rating is VERY subjective,
unlike hip clearances. Too many vets have way too many opinions on Grade 1's and I am
not so sure I would throw the baby out with the bath water here. I refer you to the
article listed at the BMD Health Links page (compiled by our wonderful Robin Camken)
There is an article there titled, ELBOW DYSPLASIA: CLINICAL SIGNS VERSUS RADIOGRAPHIC
EVIDENCE by Dean R. Gahring, D.V.M., Diplomate. I have copied the last few sentences
of this article:
>>>Grading elbows that are dysplastic may be helpful to breeders because it has been
>shown that breeding parents with higher grades of elbow dysplasia result in a higher
>incidence of dysplasia in the progeny. By only breeding normal or Grade I parents,
>significant progress in Scandinavia and the UK has been made in reducing the
>incidence of elbow dysplasia in Rottweilers and Bernese Mountain Dogs. <<<
I simply do not feel there is enoough info out there about grade 1 elbows. I feel
VERY differently about grade 2 elbows.
I hope I didn't open a can of worms here. But I would love to hear others opinions.
But please..no flames...just shared opinions.
Darcy Babb
Tijeras, NM