Re: Br!n. Cyrano de Bergerac's "Thrust home." (Hoo-ha!) ::rimshot::

2006-05-30 Thread Medievalbk
 
In a message dated 5/30/2006 6:57:20 PM US Mountain Standard Time,  
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

I'm not  clear on what a "scorpion attack to the foot"
would be.  Or is it my  French?



Why I need stick figures.
 
Probably with two weapons. Attacker pins both arms/
weapons to the outside, with body horizontal. One 
hooked leg becomes the center of balance. One
leg curls up over the attacker's head to toehook 
opponent's throatsac.
 
Sort of what you could do with a karate crane
attack with an extra leg part, starting backwards.
 
A heck of a lot better balance than the average 
human. Which, IIRC, the hoon have.
 
An attack to use in a tall narrow hallway?
 
Vilyehm
___
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l


Re: Br!n. Cyrano de Bergerac's "Thrust home." (Hoo-ha!) ::rimshot::

2006-05-30 Thread David Hobby

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:


I believe  that 'fencing' is the stylized one with
lots of silly rules.  Maybe  you mean 'sword fighting'?

...

Yup. Anything involved with staying alive aint fencing.



It's not clear to me that having more flexible  arms
would make much difference to sword fighting  style.
If one wants to really cut the other, one  tends to
have the arm extended, meaning it's  straight.


...

My thoughts were: The more types of attacts, the more
one has to learn defence, so becoming a master swords-
man would be that much more difficult, and to a human 
audience, that much more impressive.


Well, attacks that WORK.  Humans already have a lot
of showy moves which aren't that useful.  : )

Sc’ le pied.  L'assaut de scorpion par le pied.  


William--

I'm not clear on what a "scorpion attack to the foot"
would be.  Or is it my French?

Overhead attack.of toehook to  face or throatsac. 
By blocking or locking opponent's  sword arm. 
Having that extra length and  joint might make 
a deadly attact of stepping past  your opponent's  
blade to thrust with your sword  behind your own  
back. 


Maybe.  Not all of these are sword moves?  (Sword moves
tend to be done from further away?)  It's not clear
to me that a "grab" with an extra-jointed arm is a
great improvement on a grab with a hand.  I'd go so
far as to argue that grabbing a more flexible arm is
LESS useful than grabbing a human arm, so that grabs
would tend to be used less than they are in human
martial arts.  (Where they are not used much in
sword fighting, in the first place.)

Now the ability to bring the sword all the way around
the body might be something.  One can do it more
rapidly than whirling around, which is showy but
not too useful for humans.  So it might be worth
something...  One problem is that one loses a lot
of reach in the process.

Weekend's over. Br!n now in  subject line. 


Oops!  Sorry I didn't catch that.

---David

___
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l


Re: Br!n. Cyrano de Bergerac's "Thrust home." (Hoo-ha!) ::rimshot::

2006-05-30 Thread Medievalbk
 
In a message dated 5/30/2006 6:05:16 PM US Mountain Standard Time,  
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

William--

I believe  that 'fencing' is the stylized one with
lots of silly rules.  Maybe  you mean 'sword fighting'?



Yup. Anything involved with staying alive aint fencing.
 
 
It's not clear to me that having more flexible  arms
would make much difference to sword fighting  style.
If one wants to really cut the other, one  tends to
have the arm extended, meaning it's  straight.
 
My thoughts were: The more types of attacts, the more
one has to learn defence, so becoming a master swords-
man would be that much more difficult, and to a human 
audience, that much more impressive.
 
 
Sc’ le pied.  L'assaut de scorpion par le pied.  
Overhead attack.of toehook to  face or throatsac. 
By blocking or locking opponent's  sword arm. 
Having that extra length and  joint might make 
a deadly attact of stepping past  your opponent's  
blade to thrust with your sword  behind your own  
back. 
I think I need a lot of  play-dough and pipe 
cleaners. 
Weekend's over. Br!n now in  subject line. 
with 



William  Taylor
-
Good words on page I do forebare
Not  pulled out from my derriere.
Blest be the man who says, "writes well"
And  curst be he who makes me spell.
___
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l