Re: os-prober slow, grub-mount results in very slow file transfers
Thank you, I shall ask the os-prober maintainers instead, it sounds like regular mount (or something else) would be better to use for that purpose after perhaps testing it's available, I'd guess grub-mount might have been designed to use in the minimal early boot environment with the limited resources available at that point. May 13, 2024, 21:59 by phco...@gmail.com: > We don't maintain os-prober. As for grub-mount it was never meant to be fast > and certainly isn't > > Le lun. 13 mai 2024, 22:47, stratus--- via Bug reports for the GRand Unified > Bootloader <> bug-grub@gnu.org> > a écrit : > >> Dear Grub maintainers, myself and others on the Artix forum have experienced >> problems with os-prober running very slowly. The issue seems to occur in >> other distros as well, and the same subject has come up before in the past: >> >> https://forum.artixlinux.org/index.php/topic,6818.msg41493 >> It appears that grub-mount uses a FUSE mount which requires a specific >> implementation for different filesystems. When the partitions are mounted >> with grub-mount, file reading operations are vastly slower than when mounted >> by the normal mount command. This is even worse on BTRFS than with EXT4, and >> it looks like NTFS is probably very slow too. This can be easily tested by >> using grub-mount to mount a partition then seeing how long it takes to copy >> some files over compared with a normal mount. And to further obscure the >> issue, it also appears to depend on how much searching os-prober has to do >> before finding out the information it needs, some distros like Devuan seem >> to yield this quickly so there still isn't any real delay, but Arch takes >> much longer and probably Windows too it appears. >> I sometimes use gvfs-gphoto2 to transfer pictures and videos (some of which >> may be several GB in size) from my camera which uses a FUSE implementation >> and that doesn't have especially slow transfer speeds. >> I wonder if you might be able to fix this sometime, or if you think the >> issue lies outside of grub, provide advice on who to "bug" about this >> instead. >> Best wishes! >>
Re: os-prober slow, grub-mount results in very slow file transfers
We don't maintain os-prober. As for grub-mount it was never meant to be fast and certainly isn't Le lun. 13 mai 2024, 22:47, stratus--- via Bug reports for the GRand Unified Bootloader a écrit : > Dear Grub maintainers, myself and others on the Artix forum have > experienced problems with os-prober running very slowly. The issue seems to > occur in other distros as well, and the same subject has come up before in > the past: > https://forum.artixlinux.org/index.php/topic,6818.msg41493 > It appears that grub-mount uses a FUSE mount which requires a specific > implementation for different filesystems. When the partitions are mounted > with grub-mount, file reading operations are vastly slower than when > mounted by the normal mount command. This is even worse on BTRFS than with > EXT4, and it looks like NTFS is probably very slow too. This can be easily > tested by using grub-mount to mount a partition then seeing how long it > takes to copy some files over compared with a normal mount. And to further > obscure the issue, it also appears to depend on how much searching > os-prober has to do before finding out the information it needs, some > distros like Devuan seem to yield this quickly so there still isn't any > real delay, but Arch takes much longer and probably Windows too it appears. > I sometimes use gvfs-gphoto2 to transfer pictures and videos (some of > which may be several GB in size) from my camera which uses a FUSE > implementation and that doesn't have especially slow transfer speeds. > I wonder if you might be able to fix this sometime, or if you think the > issue lies outside of grub, provide advice on who to "bug" about this > instead. > Best wishes! > >
os-prober slow, grub-mount results in very slow file transfers
Dear Grub maintainers, myself and others on the Artix forum have experienced problems with os-prober running very slowly. The issue seems to occur in other distros as well, and the same subject has come up before in the past: https://forum.artixlinux.org/index.php/topic,6818.msg41493 It appears that grub-mount uses a FUSE mount which requires a specific implementation for different filesystems. When the partitions are mounted with grub-mount, file reading operations are vastly slower than when mounted by the normal mount command. This is even worse on BTRFS than with EXT4, and it looks like NTFS is probably very slow too. This can be easily tested by using grub-mount to mount a partition then seeing how long it takes to copy some files over compared with a normal mount. And to further obscure the issue, it also appears to depend on how much searching os-prober has to do before finding out the information it needs, some distros like Devuan seem to yield this quickly so there still isn't any real delay, but Arch takes much longer and probably Windows too it appears. I sometimes use gvfs-gphoto2 to transfer pictures and videos (some of which may be several GB in size) from my camera which uses a FUSE implementation and that doesn't have especially slow transfer speeds. I wonder if you might be able to fix this sometime, or if you think the issue lies outside of grub, provide advice on who to "bug" about this instead. Best wishes!
