Hi!

I think 2 weeks are definitively not enough time to costumize Cocoon to fit
your needs. There is no reason to use Cocoon with all its features (XSP) as
it is.
I found out that many different ways are possible to find your goal. JSP is
not an alternative to cocoon, its just another different technology.
To crack some JSPs together is not recomended for profesional development.
If you believe in XML and the tecnology to deal with XML in
webapplications, then
you must find solutions for that. Some times an open source project is able
to cover some requirements, but its necessary to develope your own solution
inside a framework.
The intention of a framework is to help you handling some basic circular
functionatity, but a framework never will prevent you from implementing
your own business logic - in
the best case in a generic "framework-like" way.

cheers
Manfred





[EMAIL PROTECTED] am 30.01.2003 12:21:55

Bitte antworten an [EMAIL PROTECTED]@inet

An:      [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Kopie:
Thema:   Time to go back to JSP. Cocoon just isnt ready.



I have reluctantly come to the conclusion that  cocoon is not ready for
professional development. Unlike tomcat, or Ant, this  product has serious
things blocking its use in production systems. I personally  am completely
and utterly stopped by the classpath bug indicated here:
http://nagoya.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=16580.  Just another
symptom of a product that needs more work to be used in  professional
products. That coupled with the lack of documentation makes the  package
difficult at best. I will possibly be back in a year or so when this
technology has gone somewhere. This is assuming it is still alive by then.
I  have seen a plethora of new people come on this list and then just
vanish. That  doesn't bode well for its reputation. I don't want to take
this step and throw  away two weeks of work but the fact is that I also
don't have time to wait for  such massive bugs to be fixed and to spend
another two weeks swimming through  poor debugging tools. Its a massive
bummer to me but in order to be true to  myself I cant see alternatives.
The fact is that however flawed JSPs are, I can  crack together JSP pagers
40 times faster than cocoon pages. When it comes to  deadlines, major bugs
like this just stop a product cold. Anyway, Ill stop  rambling now.

Comments are invited.

-- Robert








---------------------------------------------------------------------
Please check that your question  has not already been answered in the
FAQ before posting.     <http://xml.apache.org/cocoon/faq/index.html>

To unsubscribe, e-mail:     <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail:   <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to