Re: can HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false negatives get backported to branch-1?

[Suresh Srinivas]

This change in merged into branch-1 and will be available in release 1.1.

On Mon, May 7, 2012 at 6:40 PM, Jim Donofrio donofrio...@gmail.com wrote:

 Can someone backport HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false negatives
 to branch-1 for the next 1+ release?

 Without this fix BloomMapFile is somewhat useless because having no false
 negatives is a core feature of BloomFilters. I am surprised that both
 hadoop 1.0.2 and cdh3u3 do not have this fix from over 2 years ago.

can HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false negatives get backported to branch-1?

[Jim Donofrio]

Can someone backport HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false 
negatives to branch-1 for the next 1+ release?


Without this fix BloomMapFile is somewhat useless because having no 
false negatives is a core feature of BloomFilters. I am surprised that 
both hadoop 1.0.2 and cdh3u3 do not have this fix from over 2 years ago.

Re: can HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false negatives get backported to branch-1?

[Suresh Srinivas]

I have marked it for 1.1. I will follow up on promoting the path.

Regards,
Suresh

On May 7, 2012, at 6:40 PM, Jim Donofrio donofrio...@gmail.com wrote:

 Can someone backport HADOOP-6546: BloomMapFile can return false negatives to 
 branch-1 for the next 1+ release?
 
 Without this fix BloomMapFile is somewhat useless because having no false 
 negatives is a core feature of BloomFilters. I am surprised that both hadoop 
 1.0.2 and cdh3u3 do not have this fix from over 2 years ago.