RE: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-08 Thread David Schlesinger
>I am sure Jobs and company are not blind to 
>the strength of open source software and the 
>boon it would provide if they made a freely 
>available dev kit for the phone.

As someone who worked at Apple for ten years, I can assure you that, for
the most part, "Jobs and company" haven't got the slightest interest in
open source software, other than a minimal amount of stuff available
under a BSD-like license, allowing them to take it, do what they want
with it, and then keep it to themselves.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread Tim Newsom

AhI see. /shrug.

--Tim

On 6/5/07, David Schlesinger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:


>I am sure Jobs and company are not blind to
>the strength of open source software and the
>boon it would provide if they made a freely
>available dev kit for the phone.

As someone who worked at Apple for ten years, I can assure you that, for
the most part, "Jobs and company" haven't got the slightest interest in
open source software, other than a minimal amount of stuff available
under a BSD-like license, allowing them to take it, do what they want
with it, and then keep it to themselves.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread Tim Newsom
OK.. We can't have it both ways guys Half the time we are talking 
about getting to the point where openmoko and neo1973 can get the phone 
companies to take notice and possibly bundle the phone with their 
service.. And the other half we're talking about how Apple could not 
have done the same thing.  The fact is we don't know other than some 
vague comments at the moment.


On the one hand, supposedly the iphone is based on osx (true or false?) 
which is based on BSD (true or false?).  BSD is a unix flavor right? So 
are they porting BSD to the phone similar to linux with openmoko?  If 
so... Why can't they just use a similar development environment to 
openmoko... I.e. Gcc for BSD?  Which flavor of BSD is it based on?


I am sure Jobs and company are not blind to the strength of open source 
software and the boon it would provide if they made a freely available 
dev kit for the phone.


Maybe its time to start thinking about other things that differentiate 
us from them... If they are open now (I.e. Not talking about being able 
to replace the os with a customized version though that may be one 
thing...), then it will be content, variety, availability and ease of 
use which drive consumer adoption... (From my point of view anyway).


--Tim

On Tue, 5 Jun 2007 17:35, kenneth marken wrote:

Todd W wrote:

From: "Tim Newsom" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

So apparently Jobs decided to allow 3rd party software on the phone 
after all... Interesting development.

Yes, but how are they going to _support_ it?



or for that matter, how many hoops do you have to jump thru to get your 
app onto the phone? i belive jobs at one time used the word "simple" to 
talk about the kind of apps one would be allowed to make (or move from 
osx to the phone iirc). so for all we know they are planing to make one 
able to create something similar to dashboard widgets but not much 
else.


i just cant shake the feeling that the iphone will be a highly 
controlled environment, with apple as the guardian.


hell, they have partnered up with AT&T. and isnt mobile operators in 
the US notorious for locking down what phones can or cant do? i recall 
reading about bluetooth file transfer being removed and similar so that 
one had to use their network to transfer data to and from the phone and 
similar.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread Steven Milburn

As of yet, AT&T hasn't disabled bluetooth like you mention.  I bought a
phone from Cingular/AT&T only a couple months ago.  (I chose them because I
wanted a GSM phone so I could play with the Neo when it's available).  I'm
able to transfer music, pics, and other files from my computer to the phone
without issue.  My brother has a chocolate phone from Verizon, and can't
move files from his computer to the phone via usb nor bluetooth.  I think
what you're saying may be true for Verizon and Sprint.

--Steve

On 6/5/07, kenneth marken <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:



hell, they have partnered up with AT&T. and isnt mobile operators in the
US notorious for locking down what phones can or cant do? i recall
reading about bluetooth file transfer being removed and similar so that
one had to use their network to transfer data to and from the phone and
similar.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread kenneth marken

Todd W wrote:


From: "Tim Newsom" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>


So apparently Jobs decided to allow 3rd party software on the phone 
after all... Interesting development.


Yes, but how are they going to _support_ it?



or for that matter, how many hoops do you have to jump thru to get your 
app onto the phone? i belive jobs at one time used the word "simple" to 
talk about the kind of apps one would be allowed to make (or move from 
osx to the phone iirc). so for all we know they are planing to make one 
able to create something similar to dashboard widgets but not much else.


i just cant shake the feeling that the iphone will be a highly 
controlled environment, with apple as the guardian.


hell, they have partnered up with AT&T. and isnt mobile operators in the 
US notorious for locking down what phones can or cant do? i recall 
reading about bluetooth file transfer being removed and similar so that 
one had to use their network to transfer data to and from the phone and 
similar.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread Todd W


From: "Tim Newsom" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>


So apparently Jobs decided to allow 3rd party software on the phone after 
all... Interesting development.


Yes, but how are they going to _support_ it?

People complain about how much windows development tools cost. For $299.00 
you can get a copy of VS.NET and develop moble apps that make your device do 
whatever you want.


Todd W.


___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Iphone 3rd party development allowed...

2007-06-05 Thread Tim Newsom
So apparently Jobs decided to allow 3rd party software on the phone 
after all... Interesting development.

--Tim

___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community