Re: RFR 8186539 [testlibrary] : TestSocketFactory should allow triggers before match/replace

2017-08-25 Thread Stuart Marks



On 8/21/17 2:08 PM, Roger Riggs wrote:

Please review a rmi testlibrary enhancement to allow a trigger byte sequence 
before
the match and replace. It improves the ease with which stream contents can be
identified
when streams contain IP addresses and sequence numbers that change from run to 
run.

Webrev:
http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~rriggs/webrev-socketfactory-trigger-8186539/


Hi Roger,

Overall looks fine, just a couple nitpicky comments.

There are two definitions of EMPTY_BYTE_ARRAY; one in the TestSocketFactory 
class and the second in the nested class MatchReplaceOutputStream. It doesn't 
really matter, though I did find it a bit confusing.


 233  * The trigger, match, and replacements are propagated to all 
existing sockets.


This is in InterposeSocket, which has no sockets to propagate this state to 
(unlike the other cases). Maybe this means that this state is propagated to any 
existing OutputStream.


It would be helpful to have a brief comment that describes exactly how the 
triggering mechanism. I think that if triggerBytes has nonzero length, then the 
MatchReplaceOutputStream waits until it sees the triggerBytes, after which one 
match/replace is enabled; further match/replace operations don't occur until 
after triggerBytes is seen again. Also, if triggerBytes is zero length, then 
match/replace is always done. Is that correct?


This is mostly just changes to comments, so I don't think I need to see another 
webrev.


s'marks


RFR 8186539 [testlibrary] : TestSocketFactory should allow triggers before match/replace

2017-08-21 Thread Roger Riggs
Please review a rmi testlibrary enhancement to allow a trigger byte 
sequence before
the match and replace. It improves the ease with which stream contents 
can be identified
when streams contain IP addresses and sequence numbers that change from 
run to run.


Webrev:
http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~rriggs/webrev-socketfactory-trigger-8186539/

Thanks, Roger