collecting an Enigma? [was: Antiques man guilty of Enigma charge

2001-09-27 Thread Pat Farrell

At 10:39 AM 9/27/2001 +0200, Hadmut Danisch wrote:
There are many versions and variatons of the Enigma,

I know that many versions of the Enigma were sold commercially.
They were not rare, at least some of the versions that Hadmut
lists.

Since I worked professionally writing software ciphers, I have
thought over the years that owning an Enigma sample would be cool.
Assuming that private collectors can own one, and that the price
is less than that of a small house. Sort of like buying one
of the Beatles' guitars.

Does anyone know if there is a legal collector's market for Enigma 
machines?

thanks
pat




Pat Farrell [EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pfarrell.com




-
The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending unsubscribe cryptography to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: collecting an Enigma? [was: Antiques man guilty of Enigma charge

2001-09-27 Thread Hadmut Danisch

On Thu, Sep 27, 2001 at 10:37:23AM -0400, Pat Farrell wrote:

 Does anyone know if there is a legal collector's market for Enigma 
 machines?
 

Some years ago, when I was at the university, the institute
had one enigma, which was bought at an auction. If I remember
well, it had cost about DM 15.000,- (about 7,100 US$).
The machine was in a very good condition, everything worked
well (of course, the original battery was removed), even
most of the light bulbs were still working. It was, however,
a very simple version (three wheels, no separate wheels, no
plug board) and I think, it was a commercial version. The
box was obviously modified after WWII to remove the signs
and labels of the Nazis, but except from that also in a good
shape.

A friend of mine collects old mechanical calculation
machines and therefore used to visit auctions. There are
special auctions for these machines and the catalogues usually
contained about 1-2 pages of old encryption machines as well
(mostly Enigma or Hagelin), but it's about 4 years ago that
I've seen such a catalogue. Prices may have increased meanwhile.

However, there is definitly a huge market for legal (and probably
also stolen ones) calculation machines, including encryption machines.


regards
Hadmut






-
The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending unsubscribe cryptography to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: collecting an Enigma? [was: Antiques man guilty of Enigma charge

2001-09-27 Thread Jon Callas

At 10:37 AM -0400 9/27/01, Pat Farrell wrote:

Since I worked professionally writing software ciphers, I have
thought over the years that owning an Enigma sample would be cool.
Assuming that private collectors can own one, and that the price
is less than that of a small house. Sort of like buying one
of the Beatles' guitars.

Does anyone know if there is a legal collector's market for Enigma
machines?

Yes. They show up from time to time in various places, and a few times a
year on eBay, even.

A civilian Enigma like a NEMA should run between US$2K-3K. A military
Enigma should run around $5K-7K, less if it isn't in working condition or
is missing rotors, more if it has some interesting provenance.

You can get Hagelin M209 machines in the US$1500-2000 for ones in really
spiffy condition. There's a M209 canvas case up for auction now on eBay.

Jon



-
The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending unsubscribe cryptography to [EMAIL PROTECTED]