Re: When is iraq expected to fall.

2003-03-21 Thread James A. Donald
--
On 19 Mar 2003 at 22:55, Sarad AV wrote:
 how long does US analysts expect iraq to be completely 
 occupied by US and allied troops?

No definite plans, but Rumsfeld is thinking of an occupation 
force of 75 000 for several years.  Some want the kind of 
occupation where any time any Iraqi utters a racist slur, the 
marines take him away for sensitivity training, which would 
require about 200 000, whereas Rumsfeld has in mind an 
occupation more like Afghanistan, where so long as the rivers 
run with water, not blood, we pat ourselves on the back and 
count it a job well done.

Of course, all this assumes the war goes smoothly -- with a 
kill ratio of a thousand to one.   There is widespread failure 
to appreciate how remarkable such kill ratios are.  If it is 
merely one hundred to one, the war will be perceived as a 
defeat, and if it is merely ten to one, it actually will be a 
defeat. 

--digsig
 James A. Donald
 6YeGpsZR+nOTh/cGwvITnSR3TdzclVpR0+pr3YYQdkG
 pXZ8V7ZVSnZEJTIAOWVcd7RvKnGDxic8agd6TY6o
 453h7nDyLl5QIvUPrVvYm1kEJJ/vJpfXSwkzd8wbm



Re: When is iraq expected to fall.

2003-03-21 Thread James A. Donald
--
On 19 Mar 2003 at 22:55, Sarad AV wrote:
 how long does US analysts expect iraq to be completely 
 occupied by US and allied troops?

No definite plans, but Rumsfeld is thinking of an occupation 
force of 75 000 for several years.  Some want the kind of 
occupation where any time any Iraqi utters a racist slur, the 
marines take him away for sensitivity training, which would 
require about 200 000, whereas Rumsfeld has in mind an 
occupation more like Afghanistan, where so long as the rivers 
run with water, not blood, we pat ourselves on the back and 
count it a job well done.

Of course, all this assumes the war goes smoothly -- with a 
kill ratio of a thousand to one.   There is widespread failure 
to appreciate how remarkable such kill ratios are.  If it is 
merely one hundred to one, the war will be perceived as a 
defeat, and if it is merely ten to one, it actually will be a 
defeat. 

--digsig
 James A. Donald
 6YeGpsZR+nOTh/cGwvITnSR3TdzclVpR0+pr3YYQdkG
 pXZ8V7ZVSnZEJTIAOWVcd7RvKnGDxic8agd6TY6o
 453h7nDyLl5QIvUPrVvYm1kEJJ/vJpfXSwkzd8wbm