Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-06 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
Package: udev
Version: 0.053-1
Severity: critical
Justification: breaks the whole system

After boot, udev creates all device nodes with owner and group root, and
permissions rw-rw, so noone can read nor write in any device. Thus
it is impossible to login to KDE (screen disappears and then KDM comes
back) and login in tty[1-6] is possible, but one see a bunch of errors
on trying to write to /dev/null (and then bash completion triggers
plenty of them).

I could use the system by stopping udev and use ./MAKEDEV generic to
restore a usable /dev.

I attach my local rules (they shouldn't be the source of the problem
since they didn't change for a long time).

-- Package-specific info:
-- /etc/udev/rules.d/:
/etc/udev/rules.d/:
total 1
-rw-r--r--  1 root root 277 2005-02-22 12:16 10local
lrwxrwxrwx  1 root root  13 2004-12-05 16:27 50udev -> ../udev.rules

-- /sys/:
/sys/block/dm-0/dev
/sys/block/dm-1/dev
/sys/block/dm-2/dev
/sys/block/dm-3/dev
/sys/block/dm-4/dev
/sys/block/dm-5/dev
/sys/block/fd0/dev
/sys/block/hda/dev
/sys/block/hdd/dev
/sys/block/hdd/hdd1/dev
/sys/block/hdd/hdd2/dev
/sys/block/hdd/hdd3/dev
/sys/block/ram0/dev
/sys/block/ram10/dev
/sys/block/ram11/dev
/sys/block/ram12/dev
/sys/block/ram13/dev
/sys/block/ram14/dev
/sys/block/ram15/dev
/sys/block/ram1/dev
/sys/block/ram2/dev
/sys/block/ram3/dev
/sys/block/ram4/dev
/sys/block/ram5/dev
/sys/block/ram6/dev
/sys/block/ram7/dev
/sys/block/ram8/dev
/sys/block/ram9/dev
/sys/block/sda/dev
/sys/block/sdb/dev
/sys/block/sdb/sdb1/dev
/sys/block/sdb/sdb2/dev
/sys/block/sdb/sdb3/dev
/sys/block/sr0/dev
/sys/class/drm/radeon/dev
/sys/class/input/event0/dev
/sys/class/input/event1/dev
/sys/class/input/event2/dev
/sys/class/input/event3/dev
/sys/class/input/event4/dev
/sys/class/input/event5/dev
/sys/class/input/mice/dev
/sys/class/input/mouse0/dev
/sys/class/input/mouse1/dev
/sys/class/input/ts0/dev
/sys/class/input/ts1/dev
/sys/class/misc/agpgart/dev
/sys/class/misc/device-mapper/dev
/sys/class/misc/psaux/dev
/sys/class/misc/rtc/dev
/sys/class/printer/lp0/dev
/sys/class/sound/adsp/dev
/sys/class/sound/audio/dev
/sys/class/sound/controlC0/dev
/sys/class/sound/dsp/dev
/sys/class/sound/mixer/dev
/sys/class/sound/pcmC0D0c/dev
/sys/class/sound/pcmC0D0p/dev
/sys/class/sound/pcmC0D1c/dev
/sys/class/sound/pcmC0D1p/dev
/sys/class/sound/timer/dev
/sys/class/usb/hiddev0/dev

-- Kernel configuration:


-- System Information:
Debian Release: 3.1
  APT prefers testing
  APT policy: (990, 'testing'), (500, 'unstable'), (1, 'experimental')
Architecture: i386 (i686)
Kernel: Linux 2.6.8-1-386
Locale: [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] (charmap=ISO-8859-15)

Versions of packages udev depends on:
ii  hotplug  0.0.20040329-17 Linux Hotplug Scripts
ii  initscripts  2.86.ds1-1  Standard scripts needed for bootin
ii  libc62.3.2.ds1-20GNU C Library: Shared libraries an
ii  makedev  2.3.1-75Creates device files in /dev
ii  sed  4.1.2-8 The GNU sed stream editor

-- debconf information excluded

-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A
BUS="ide", KERNEL="hda", NAME="dvdrom"
KERNEL="fd*", NAME="floppy%e"
BUS="scsi", SYSFS{model}="jaz 1GB*", KERNEL="sd*", NAME{all_partitions}="jaz"
BUS="scsi", SYSFS{model}="CD-W516EB*", NAME="cdrw"
BUS="usb", SYSFS{manufacturer}="M-Sys", SYSFS{product}="DiskOnKey", NAME="key"


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-06 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
reopen 298351
thanks

Please don't close bugs without even waiting to know if the solution you
give is helpful!

> mv /etc/udev/udev.rules.dpkg-dist /etc/udev/udev.rules

[EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ ls /etc/udev/udev.rules.dpkg-dist
ls: /etc/udev/udev.rules.dpkg-dist: No such file or directory

Quickly,
Nowhere man
-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-06 Thread Marco d'Itri 
On Mar 07, Pierre THIERRY <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> Please don't close bugs without even waiting to know if the solution you
> give is helpful!
It was a very good bet.
Please report the content of /etc/udev/udev.rules of the /etc/udev/
directory.

-- 
ciao,
Marco


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-06 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
> Please report the content of /etc/udev/udev.rules of the /etc/udev/
> directory.

I attach a bzipped tarball of /etc/udev.

Quickly,
Nowhere man
-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-06 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
> I attach a bzipped tarball of /etc/udev.

Better if I really attach it. :-/

Successfully,
Nowhere man
-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A
BZh91AY&SY:ˆE»ÿ°<@[EMAIL PROTECTED]@Q€ªƒ6ØÊ“M
[EMAIL PROTECTED]@¢€©
[EMAIL PROTECTED]@Ji
§±&ҏQê<[EMAIL PROTECTED]@[EMAIL PROTECTED]&§©ú“Ô{)[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]&¡ jÀ4 Ð2Ð
’€
SFši4žÒžSCSõL=P¡~‚èÌ5ØAý¬#KNG$’R"B¤aS†1A<¨(íQ°¥*o‚¨õÞ¯gNžÍ¶7ßZۍøÛog+àð(6¨‰’‰å¡SžÆ’8µh5çŒÖ£=î5Ó|ÍkEgQËne¾´€óa±4Ô#†‘aˆ†C*0Ž‚V
 %$v­$Ÿçû{»‘¸`˜¦ƒÁ&ÝÁDC¨óé¿¿åØDYaär’$ ™4f5LJÁ
HULASP˜8DDåÄR”UACSÙÕ­
$BA£9}³b{÷9ꏡü_íkd‹½Ô»Z“&¥Íí¬™¶)±£ùm›d™6686:Ù,£õ)eÔ§'2›·ï©¹u-l“6¦mÇýj›—Ù¯Z·Ú.çp}ô½cSbŸåÁ£v妥F½Z¾¶TŒ>™Ñ<Ré9(qÕO;›o·²fþÇ72û)Jh¥–²´¬½ö_[ô|ǃówúßÚò,ðâ¾ï·3'S/TþMm÷{ƒSbë)O{þ¬ÞÈþMë¿™Òæˆns¸¿Ãß_ÃýO}bø1Œu:š9ÜÓ±wnwµ)rš)JªR”(§™Ðþ—e•Mõå±ëºôËáÿ£à`ÐæQñ:”t/ìÏJ¤Ùu2f¦ÛdÍe¬¢ú3Íy·,Õ3
 ØÐú³DéÊC¤»“á  9CÝ/J'‘â09‘4ÛX¤K£µOä8â9Ž
£ä“A/[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]@D&Ó¶Œ0’$p” ˆh”¡ö©4pՖ®ß›w³Wì[¥½‡Èr^sXYwóo‘iWµ¦¥–’^Ë-Ì¥žVRæö3Ÿçòaž¹®uÖ­Šµ/‘{ÒeVt-¶³iÉ:J봃DÕq‡+Î[\{^¸u)0ɦwVö
êñÇv8îÊgSľ3Iàaýg»ù4P£*
å;Ç_jŒ/4Þà”;4Ÿ¥‡’¦iñ,‘“5ž¼K®‘bˆÎj¥ÕðԕÃ}­Œ›M™™9ö½Ms‚8pŽÃ°Ü¶'[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
™Eq¢éT„dÎë.òµF"”ò¾úŸû--s0|ïäÃE2gŒa…/’‰‘¥+%p0̃   ÁOýÙ¾–¦
ÙÖô¶“bK,äÃÔöC‚C'÷¹÷5±¬ã$ÿLYJZ
$ÞþÇÁº¶ìks>õ(°zDÁ ?X” û‚Ç©_iÖÿ!ÖXês'Ò³½" Ñ‰?ã=2è§ÌúÇòx3w¿“Säd虫
Åÿ<;_J§n߉íÏðxáì|gÖ%ÄûܙIŸ™ý{k¦êSG±KxÝ«6ÿCÒó¹á¡zh´ZF!‡DOõþË6ê?í£G²I—È*|Œ?ÿÇãOƒÛÜÈôøϲ£íSê~ˆ;žWoY^§¬¬¤ŽÁgsÑPoû^©eÿ;æ|ïbÅÔºë2¯–ùef¶O¾ja›5Ž….ºÇno±²6¾6’Ù
”hÏTàmpc&Sksjmg›„àɓ5j]u‹?'í§»'æ~7•’=3´”‰CÜ4™#:!r
ÁNáoò¼aJéqdßÔ͚(UU%+áƒ%0ÑLd”Š•H¦}šFx‡%ݔºHÒ¡¬¼SR¢yUþå>d9(ûÚãöJˆlƒ“Áe­rçª#ÚüÏ:×Ye:"§åq]ÿ'c©ÜÃÈÍ×ɦ}
ŸÉSSãk]M‹0ÎÝ
K1’¿¡k³Âî§Ú³áoSfmTá¶x˜yø¶,z\Ù3%›^IÁ½Ñät¶ZTÞü„³,2sÙÖòº§ïW;åömsÊ`ïùœž5<™pjÔì7\ÍFLÛ±›U2R埛[åÉüXÉö–m{ûìÞÍÖëSs²ÎÉL۟#È;ˆ™fÛ:W»îù餼ï+èºÊgg¹š^BÏT Ã.‡¢~æ¥;~•ÛSÎôæëš{vN÷rÍö¢û+Š|ØYµz]MŠõR͋2^ρö¶ÜêmšìÃ
nÓhf5»Zjx²^Óë!ØøTúW7³9šée7¹v
}Ç%ØhÊx/4fãŽIœ4ɒ™ó1~fo~&s%:’S«Ùô_áè]eÖrÑÓòñ]£+ûüí,ëkX×wJó\¾6캗9©x³rnl5._©Lòj³VMî…æLÖt¹ÿsVÝk6µM^êjqnqúVd¥ôd”½sd³FÅÚ:Ý̜
N‡¸ïdæg·Ë^8?ÜàäÚæmÕ·>+ŸÃ{ßåu/5kÊUÝ%Û³yٙ§èäé`w¹9Ö,¬§K°·'ûÙ_Ĭ½ÍÍG§  
–‹)®îO"ìš;Ý­moŽ¦¶Å›Vt$—Í~ÌØaäÓaÙk8µÛ†•Ë"ùt-…l´^Ë^w;Ølæ{Z?ÙmO[[tÃsÍۓ'à³poå"îfîySô*•Úi>'¾5£íy–u?aòI3~7šŸ•ÉõÉ0ës®àìîæµ­œ0ÒOÈ©J)ñ)ý/{ÎÁïy½ÙW}˜Ñ”ñÖX]Mž%½®µ½Ý_§õÖægÁÁbïÈ·£âdíu:”]2IµÕ5Ú®–.Wç¾Få?O‹Ê±Šªèzg¥‚ÕJSwEì¥Õ¢¢ê¨À<¦ç¨í9.æŠrwæa×­íAy–\æ:8p|¦ç?Ü¡å?K¬Ò½}Í¢v2ûz52³
fŸb—Y•-üoÒÞ;sdì÷670͓à¦L ôë³ð®î?9ÎÈÜûÝJPJ‰GÊ¡d²ÖP¥P ¢Dͱåxp{Ï;ŸÇåþeíähle§³kõ:šN¾û&w½­kÏ#õnpcR¤mÆ<÷Ď
,®e#Em½ŠÈæf¼ÙÚh¢÷³R“ðtt/–\8ÙzÛ¹n}9So#ÉëSzxÕæNXS›6×mÏÔ01G‰|pá9û·’^tqSŠ¦¦qª&ç㢚6îÞéÃZ·%KEDvݱ+%3Sò>÷„–ªz‹H,TI;ރÞõ±2T¥3Ybž7Qd’ê€BŒB±DªÄ#
€Á
«B‘ý¡ö…>R>ô|äH`®š“L$¦UK*¨µH©íî¿ÊŸ_{D>7KÆûڜϹò¬ìY:’ê(¥]oÑpîAÚ}3¹†¦lÑæafläXÃș&G&R”¥)UJs”£ië`†‘L.²R”¥)JjRÍ{T±zÉK73n»
2ar070—y¥JTD´bË3.j(³Sxõ2d͐Ò]-m   aeÌaúÄwùư߃ƒ 
ñ˜!¤XV‘~×hа‘‰P‘(BDÄPELMQ$A’˜.a„¸|sû³òCñ‘¸}xL¼?D‚¤ØYg­ROøÞÕÏSbÆ¢=®
ζ~¦æ©&§sÆ➕Ê,y$Š##±Û¹…Õ!¯5¤7Sîx‹OÞþ¥¦jŸKÎø®“Ù÷rçB(©%œçD'•­S—¯Ñ­Q4k6©C¤²Ê“©NMËF
w§a‡"6¾–Çáf:hwª}ÊxÏwÇÁ©´ý‡Ôï;”ï}Ϲ…ÙWa¿cÊû—h"„YÒêÍC™ˆó•7"#"özF`FØcŸ#Áy9)©órñck3IÐ×Qñ^
—çêç›kÃÛkŽ©”¿ÀŠ‚æfAM!wcjUmJ6¸ßò4gñ¦†þ"ë½ï¨æ{$„žyì|÷„IØ÷¿£¶+±G3žím,ÑwœÑ~iË~/í|Ÿz4>§Öªµ¾Y¹Æ.µ»1UJ•%›N1±…ðHéP̺¢Ñ²kfÁˆ‹o¦O2Žµ.ý?b»”˜6©fœ°µee¦_…½|[EMAIL
 
PROTECTED]<;J$–JÞ¨C³»ÁeBʜß)Ã{§*ÒlzÞU6´™'ÓöºÓ)­Tà)8Ýb—±e-~ëÆ®ó©vJg&#6|oVcÓN§àÙcÁ§†}|î9œlãÇUŠm¬·üYrËMZlâæüXƒ\lÛ·¦{ÞηN¥y®É&•*ìŽiÆÔ~¶qÇXÞê×Ó_~„É۹Αýߗé·ê½ûÍÀ~Èë9E)pؕßJá¹
9RÔZ¢ª[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
ól?çƒõý'VŽ6a™„CˆÄÌ:Ó[ã›üMõCÁÇN¬Ö<õ¬¹êÞßĦÊU©OwÂáô”à Q?hùŸkcø¦¥¥šjnݗL‰ÿkoÿçdzn¿<Ëc§H¬ià“«eêàv|»c¤ƒmÌ5Ó¦ÔbŒvZ:'ù*ÉýîÙ$ѹ‡?Ò²2P¥õoÝùËÃ{(WE¦ÝqßX•|ù±U†æã“rÇZœÎ&qøpÚãÇYâPÚþ÷ÒçÛ5Mwšùê.ܖ³Ë¿3iÀ™é®E³¢ÚéU®(²§F±N›¥Úcå͵˞‘É‹\žcϓ¶X6¡àxîO²u¡Ü]Jóç´ufEWQ¹×ËÎÙNÊÔ¬økìÇý7m¾ê“U/Z䕶¤_Y›w_Lk3B¼ˆT9†Úè6֌_âoèSŽN~‘
hhD‰SZ±8·×RlÆM™ã•µi+©©-ÏEóV53JàÝ$¾Zfƍ-ä  
)÷OÕތßìdö²˜¨º‹<Éërbœ³°À~Œ¬Ë7c‘"YjÌç3¶Â₝ٝtÕï³<3¥æLåc%Š.Æ#)x³:U2f³õŸ•Òë`ؤ!I¡ºñƒú´^h O¢Z ìÞÁ›¤}¨ù3Åãã]yɗûìšèà°ÙR.Ÿõý¯‰iîOø´u¾Gî{Tõ³AÝ\lƒü]©Úþ›<õ¿q6½ÔjU¤Š’P]Gês³{§±ìZˬ³­ÒÔX£óH þ{YýM$Ïû,;*QïhBšmO6VR¥~”n*5¬²Å’”ÝžH´²˜ÁII‚â1Ñ%!€fÅ š8DÀÂFæŽDp88IŒ
’Á!„¦Äh äf PÑɍ†Úq`цêè 
v6#øá&£k™ã{Œ)™Tü_æäô,ÁÁ„вË7º]J[,êK6íéÁ|”þNçê5¼¯îså)ô;´³ê?3™“[ѓʷÐü=OÌuºôŸQóý_#¾Éž‡€~TýÅÓ$ɦÿœ8oóI’~wä|gýMÑR}Bʔ¨¥I˜n7je>Àº—/L4Vl鱅—g,ÉvvY†¾Ulbé…0ÊëÅÙ2^sHžæi30Ø'ó?äõ¼¦çò+<Ï
vÂ|±v˜dE3‘rĹr¥)ږYKÂË,ùhÍ¢–gزìDX¢ŠQO22’f’0¥:1KE5E¡“Ä
^éÁHE÷lB˜ˆkú«¢lŸ½ïðyï#b˜F¹9žlz’N©ÌöQ5P§ë²>òDàÿ»Âéڎ  ¤z¸:Ñ
[EMAIL PROTECTED](I&F2™!A’BLA!–E#ER‡Rœ
ÎËÉêky$G–HŽä¨Úl:“Ùžk§4O‰“{^]Ê*žeE”ħíS÷Tñfæ¼ÑR#™%­T×á¾.Éæ–Rlb~ˆ*o龛îÙ֚Gñaµ[ÛAµ·ÃÚ~¤Ç€ž·
0aE11&3Âv‘‡ú‡Âl{ÃïÝÅá:ˆ„¦"Z¨©Bˆ”`•<ÐnA§ßÒ Øؑ;Û
R”)))èØØ¥3<Ä5ÔçuOj:DZ#°$0oÜܟφçg4ä>&OQԲňÿ:¦ªZTŽ¯”' Ðû©úAGY   
fŒtHº˜wG¹&ò†hĀ`‘cIl:×YLDCCЌ‚”)E)JS¢š¢‘ª#ÄYò®åÔ2TI2R9±ˆhéx´lIÙÞÈ=¤A…îÁ8„:*{¥2Hª‘OøPYPùÒ}¥‰ÑÕæˆês

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-07 Thread Marco d'Itri 
severity 298351 normal
tag 298351 unreproducible moreinfo
thanks

On Mar 07, Pierre THIERRY <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> > Please report the content of /etc/udev/udev.rules of the /etc/udev/
> > directory.
> I attach a bzipped tarball of /etc/udev.
Your configuration is correct, and I do not believe that it can cause
what you reported. Please test again udev.

-- 
ciao,
Marco


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-07 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
> Your configuration is correct, and I do not believe that it can cause
> what you reported. Please test again udev.

I did it. The exact problem appeared after the two last bootups. What
con I do to give you more details?

Reproducibly,
Nowhere man
-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-07 Thread Marco d'Itri 
On Mar 07, Pierre THIERRY <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> I did it. The exact problem appeared after the two last bootups. What
> con I do to give you more details?
Let's start from upgrading to 0.054-2.

-- 
ciao,
Marco


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-07 Thread Pierre THIERRY 
> Let's start from upgrading to 0.054-2.

Didn't correct anything. I started udev and it created nodes with the
same owner, group and perms as previously.

Quickly,
Nowhere man
-- 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP 0xD9D50D8A


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Bug#298351: udev: Bad permissions for all devices render system unusable or mostly so

2005-03-08 Thread Marco d'Itri 
On Mar 08, Pierre THIERRY <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> In developer's documentation, or in the users' one? I didn't find the
> info (and it should really be visible, as it can break everything).
In udev(8) and README.Debian, at least.

-- 
ciao,
Marco


signature.asc
Description: Digital signature