Bug#526229: [Pkg-samba-maint] Bug#526229: samba: Bug prevents Win2kSP4 clients to join domain
forwarded 526229 https://bugzilla.samba.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6301 thanks Quoting Mario Lipinski (l...@gymszbad.de): Package: samba Version: 2:3.3.3-1.1 Severity: normal See https://bugzilla.samba.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6301 Applying the patch solved the problem here. I experienced the problem with the current samba version in stable and testing. Well, OK. So, what is really the value added by reporting in Debian BTS a bug that has already been reported, analyzed and *fixed* upstream? In don't want to sound rude, but what you're just asking us is to make double work by hooking up on upstream BTS, check in what version this is fixedand wait for an upcoming version to fix the bug anyway. I'm not in favor of applying the patch. Diverging from upstream is pointless at this point of development. As they have a very regular upload schedule that guarantees us that the bug will be fixed in an upcoming 3.3.* version, there would be no point in applying this patch, imho. Really, please, this is a plea to all users of Samba in Debian: until we are getting close to the release of squeeze, please *don't* make double bug reports when issues are already dealt with and known by the Samba Teamunless you think that the bug makes the samba package completely unsuitable for release (ie is release critical). Many thanks for your care reporting, still. Again, I don't want to be rude but more try to save our scarce resources! signature.asc Description: Digital signature
Bug#526229: [Pkg-samba-maint] Bug#526229: samba: Bug prevents Win2kSP4 clients to join domain
Christian, Am 30.04.2009 7:00 Uhr, schrieb Christian Perrier: I'm not in favor of applying the patch. Diverging from upstream is pointless at this point of development. As they have a very regular upload schedule that guarantees us that the bug will be fixed in an upcoming 3.3.* version, there would be no point in applying this patch, imho. I can understand that for the version in testing. However, I also experienced it with the stable version. For that I think it is good to document here and maybe have it fixed (don't know how the rules are about this). Mario smime.p7s Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
Bug#526229: [Pkg-samba-maint] Bug#526229: samba: Bug prevents Win2kSP4 clients to join domain
tags 526229 lenny thanks Quoting Mario Lipinski (l...@gymszbad.de): Christian, Am 30.04.2009 7:00 Uhr, schrieb Christian Perrier: I'm not in favor of applying the patch. Diverging from upstream is pointless at this point of development. As they have a very regular upload schedule that guarantees us that the bug will be fixed in an upcoming 3.3.* version, there would be no point in applying this patch, imho. I can understand that for the version in testing. However, I also experienced it with the stable version. For that I think it is good to document here and maybe have it fixed (don't know how the rules are about this). Ah, I wasn't aware that the problem also happens in stable. Reading upstream bug report makes me think this bug should be corrected in lenny, yes. Preventing W2KSP4 clients from joining a Debian run by Samba controllers is definitely something we don't want for stable users. So, sorry for the rant: you were right reporting. I subscribed to upstream bug so that we notice when a patch is identified. signature.asc Description: Digital signature
