Bug#702062: [Pkg-xfce-devel] Bug#702062: [thunar] [thunar] Can freeze X session used together with xarchiver to open a file in a password protected archive

2013-03-03 Thread Lili-Anne Girard
2013/3/2 Manolo Díaz diaz.man...@gmail.com:
 Hi,

 Suppose that xarchiver is the default thunar action when clicking an
 archive file and that it's password protected (tested rar and zip
 archive types). If you double-click any file in the archiver tree view
 thunar will freeze the X session.

If you double-click a password protected archive in the archiver tree
view, what makes you think that this is Thunar and not xarchiver who
freeze the whole desktop ?

 You can still switch to a VT or
 terminate the X session with Ctl+Alt+Bksp, but nothing more. Unsaved
 changes will be lost. When xarchiver is launched standalone this
 doesn't happen.

I can easily reproduce it with xarchiver launched alone.

Start xarchiver, click on Open in the toolbar or Archive - Open in the
menubar and select your rar password protected archive and click on
Open. The desktop seems to freeze but what's happening here is that rar,
the command line tool used by xarchiver to extract your archive, waits
for a password to be entered somewhere but xarchiver doesn't provide any
dialog to enter your password.

Of course, the whole desktop should not freeze, but it's clearly a bug in
xarchiver not Thunar.

 Regards,
 Manolo Díaz

-- 
Lili


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org



Bug#702062: [Pkg-xfce-devel] Bug#702062: [thunar] [thunar] Can freeze X session used together with xarchiver to open a file in a password protected archive

2013-03-03 Thread Manolo Díaz
El dom, 3 mar 2013 a las 10:34 horas
Lili-Anne Girard escribió:

2013/3/2 Manolo Díaz diaz.man...@gmail.com:
 Hi,

 Suppose that xarchiver is the default thunar action when clicking an
 archive file and that it's password protected (tested rar and zip
 archive types). If you double-click any file in the archiver tree view
 thunar will freeze the X session.

If you double-click a password protected archive in the archiver tree
view, what makes you think that this is Thunar and not xarchiver who
freeze the whole desktop ?

 You can still switch to a VT or
 terminate the X session with Ctl+Alt+Bksp, but nothing more. Unsaved
 changes will be lost. When xarchiver is launched standalone this
 doesn't happen.

I can easily reproduce it with xarchiver launched alone.

Start xarchiver, click on Open in the toolbar or Archive - Open in the
menubar and select your rar password protected archive and click on
Open. The desktop seems to freeze but what's happening here is that rar,
the command line tool used by xarchiver to extract your archive, waits
for a password to be entered somewhere but xarchiver doesn't provide any
dialog to enter your password.

Of course, the whole desktop should not freeze, but it's clearly a bug in
xarchiver not Thunar.

 Regards,
 Manolo Díaz


That's not my experience. When launched standalone, say using xfrun4,
xarchiver fails with an error message and I can easely close it. The
same happens when launched from pcmanfm.

Launched from a terminal xarchiver misbehaves. It's a bug and it's
reported (#633598). Xarchive freezes, but the desktop is still
responding.

When launched from thunar instead I can't close anything. All I can do
is to move the mouse pointer around the screen, change to a VT or
terminate the session. Nothing more. That's what makes me think that is
thunar who freeze the desktop.

-- 
Manolo Díaz


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org