Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
Re: James Cowgill 2019-04-30 <403b111b-ff0a-62a2-71d1-150b3c01b...@debian.org> > > fldigi 4.1.02's configure check probes for mbedtls >= 2.16 using > > pkg-config (and builds the embedded copy otherwise), so it seems > > this has been implemented upstream in mbedtls by now. Can we have > > it in Debian, please? > > I cannot find any trace of pkg-config in upstream mbedtls git. The > issue and (newer) merge request are still open: Retrospectively, I seem to have misinterpreted the fldigi build system. The macro they use adds pkg-config support, but also adds switches to manually specify the mbedtls location, and that's what users are supposed to used, afaict. Christoph
Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi, On 30/04/2019 21:22, Christoph Berg wrote: > Re: James Cowgill 2018-05-24 > >> I've downgraded this bug because it is a feature request. It's >> not as if mbedtls is the only library which doesn't support >> pkg-config :) >> >> As you have seen there has been an open upstream issue about this >> for almost 3 years. I will see what I can do about it, but I >> would not expect it to be fixed soon. > > fldigi 4.1.02's configure check probes for mbedtls >= 2.16 using > pkg-config (and builds the embedded copy otherwise), so it seems > this has been implemented upstream in mbedtls by now. Can we have > it in Debian, please? I cannot find any trace of pkg-config in upstream mbedtls git. The issue and (newer) merge request are still open: https://github.com/ARMmbed/mbedtls/issues/228 https://github.com/ARMmbed/mbedtls/pull/1753 James -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEE+Ixt5DaZ6POztUwQx/FnbeotAe8FAlzItGkACgkQx/Fnbeot Ae+bJg//aLDExeX71V5VK9Nim8zLdFHQFx+1ILyEjULTGxChMZad/Bu6UiAS6FnX 76UHidW94WG03lnS26dst1KSHh5lzOlfELuGg5BKGOBstjNmFamWjUL9F6+WdgIz fsUpf9gnZ6Yvik84BNggit9SeofJ3cyLI3BHN6ioBsTcLhzT20zYR+GffCrKnWcm HoDp+Gv5OkXKRsa8ipAL4+Cu2nfEjKwv0/aYSLCM2cqG0DFyS4JjjnfhFdF8dXtA zaFGda7Dffgir/heME/7mh6gZxp6cbLXgGQ3Op5ThrzrIR4R0DZl3zC5hdi8mxnk 0fR+Gwlms4TLGTqd1QQzTXBlXj+Q+j0YkDlAH4eY+QEvf73mBHh6HVYa4TljP99L tHdosUD84vekrS9ESUjhqOpwU7PAFapLGSnj+HuWThGgWHHOyxWubCSh2mmFT7DS DgKe7mVc6OGGA3ZgESlrFiMz+QDVPyYiHd7UKgSrJ9OAKAxs2RtaksEmbifv2qY0 +OvBha1tBnCydPCsJnqJ3wkHf2SZAkdQ+QW7PQqBpdkVQXhBscOx/enYSPpUl04p k7dGAxJdepRPRm7/o1D8zJKZ57pcYyh2/DjUZzk/RWaG6hpKfFyUxXsThXgVFPRh iTn0K7j7EtfQrQTQ7yF2JEPFWirIK9SVYaxm8EBWaW8C2E9yZAU= =HbtU -END PGP SIGNATURE-
Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
Re: James Cowgill 2018-05-24 > I've downgraded this bug because it is a feature request. It's not as if > mbedtls is the only library which doesn't support pkg-config :) > > As you have seen there has been an open upstream issue about this for > almost 3 years. I will see what I can do about it, but I would not > expect it to be fixed soon. fldigi 4.1.02's configure check probes for mbedtls >= 2.16 using pkg-config (and builds the embedded copy otherwise), so it seems this has been implemented upstream in mbedtls by now. Can we have it in Debian, please? Thanks, Christoph
Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
On Thu, 24 May 2018 18:48:20 +0100 James Cowgill wrote: As you have seen there has been an open upstream issue about this for almost 3 years. I will see what I can do about it, but I would not expect it to be fixed soon. I have half of the required bits here, thanks to Simon Ritcher https://github.com/ARMmbed/mbedtls/pull/1657 (now just need to install the generated files correctly) The geany-plugins and gitgo breakage seems like a libgit2 bug. libgit2 should not have a "Requires.private: mbedtls" directive which will obviously not work. Use Libs.private instead until this bug is fixed. This has now been fixed in libgit2 thanks to your suggestion and geany-plugins build passed.
Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
Control: retitle -1 libmbedtls-dev: add pkg-config support Control: severity -1 wishlist Control: tags -1 upstream Hi, On Thu, 24 May 2018 22:43:28 +0530 Pirate Praveen wrote: > Package: mbedtls-dev > version: 2.8.0-1 > Severity: important > Control: forwarded -1 https://github.com/ARMmbed/mbedtls/issues/228 > Control: block 899036 by -1 > Control: block 899035 by -1 > > lbgit2 now supports using mbedTLS but missing pkg-config support for > mbedTLS is causing builds of many reverse dependencies like > geany-plugins and gitgo. I've downgraded this bug because it is a feature request. It's not as if mbedtls is the only library which doesn't support pkg-config :) As you have seen there has been an open upstream issue about this for almost 3 years. I will see what I can do about it, but I would not expect it to be fixed soon. The geany-plugins and gitgo breakage seems like a libgit2 bug. libgit2 should not have a "Requires.private: mbedtls" directive which will obviously not work. Use Libs.private instead until this bug is fixed. James signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Bug#900015: missing pkg-config support is blocking switch to mbedTLS in libgit2
Package: mbedtls-dev version: 2.8.0-1 Severity: important Control: forwarded -1 https://github.com/ARMmbed/mbedtls/issues/228 Control: block 899036 by -1 Control: block 899035 by -1 lbgit2 now supports using mbedTLS but missing pkg-config support for mbedTLS is causing builds of many reverse dependencies like geany-plugins and gitgo.
